Judge-yGet the app

Episode 59

Flippant

The JudgeMental Podcast25 minFull transcript

EP 59 Flippant
Watch on YouTube

About this episode

JudgeMental Podcast – Episode 59: Flippant In this episode, Christine and Hugh dive deep into the challenging and often heartbreaking realities of de facto custodianship in Kentucky family courts. They discuss a current case in Judge Lori Goodwin’s court, exploring what it means to be a de facto custodian, the rights and limitations that come with that status, and the inconsistencies in how courts handle these sensitive cases. Key topics include: The legal definition and implications of being a de facto custodian The difference between de facto custodians, temporary custodians, and foster parents Real-life stories of individuals who step up to care for children in crisis The emotional toll on both caregivers and children when custody is uncertain The impact of court delays and inconsistent rulings across different divisions The role of grandparents and non-relatives in custody disputes Systemic issues in dependency, neglect, and abuse dockets The importance of due process and the dangers of judicial bias For more information and to join the conversation, visit judge-y.com and follow us on Instagram at @Judgingthejudges. LEGAL DISCLAIMER The content of this podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only. It is not intended to be, and should not be construed as, legal advice. Engaging with this content does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and the hosts, guests, or their firms. The views and opinions expressed on this podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of any law firm, company, or organization. We make no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, completeness, or applicability of the information presented. Any reliance on the information in this podcast is at your own risk. Laws are constantly changing, and every situation is unique. You should always seek the advice of a qualified attorney for your specific legal concerns.

Transcript

4,646 words · about 20 minutes to read. Automatically transcribed and lightly edited; speaker labels are approximate.

Christine[00:00:00] all right. Happy Monday. We're gonna talk about a super heavy topic probably today in a case that's going on in Lori Goodwin's court in Louisville, Kentucky.

HughYeah.

ChristineWe have what's called a defacto. This person has been found to be a de facto custodian. So what's that mean? Well, the court ordered it. Yeah. And

Hughso what that means is you have equal standing to the parents in the case you have standing to act as a. Custodian with you know, you're fighting, you are a custodian level playing field. Yeah. I mean so the way that the statute works, especially since it's been changed somewhat, you can aggregate. Periods of time, it doesn't necessarily mean you are the custodian at the time that it happens. And in this case, the court looked into the past and found that during the past two years, there was a six month period or more because the child's only [00:01:00] three that. This person was a primary caretaker and financial provider, so she found that she has the standing as defacto custodian. It doesn't mean you are actual custodian at the time that that's being made, or you even have contact with the child,

Christinebut once you've been found to be a defacto custodian, you get to fight in perpetuity. It's assumed standing, assumed you have the same rights as any other parent.

HughCorrect. You have a right. You have. Okay. Not necessarily you have standing to seek custody the same way a parent can, whereas a parent, I think you automatically have custodial rights to your kids. A defacto doesn't. Okay. Have automatic, have rights they have standing now to participate on the same playing field as a parent to seek custody.

ChristineSo is there the presumption of equal parenting time, does that apply to de Factos or is it still more just the best interest standard?

Hugh. The statute includes defactos in the best interest standard. So Defactos, once they are found to be defacto, you gotta make a decision [00:02:00] between those people. But I think that the, when I'm talking about the same rights, you don't have a fundamental constitutional right, 'cause you are not. You're still not a natural parent. So it is, you have a distinct set of rights. You have standing, and this is, there's a lot more about standing,

Christineand this is one that I think that you are particularly passionate about, not necessarily this case, but in previous podcasts you've talked ad nauseum about people that take care, care, didn't do that. Yeah. People that take care though of children in emergency situations, or even if it's through no fault of the natural parents. Yeah. But you've seen some pretty horrific things, right? Sure.

HughAnd then they get run over. Mm-hmm. The typical way that we see that happen all the time is with foster parents, and that's written into the system. They don't actually get custody. The cabinet has custody, and then they can be just completely discarded at a moment's notice. Mm-hmm. Even if a kid's been living with them for years, and that sucks. And , I would, I really would like to see that change the. Time that you also see it is when you get temporary custodians who are actually made legal [00:03:00] custodians of kids and then are treated as if they never had any rights whatsoever, even though there's a piece of paper that said they have temporary custody. Mm-hmm. But then they get discarded. I have an even bigger issue with that because. You know, foster parents for good or bad, you know that's the case. Mm-hmm. You've never had legal custody or legal rights established by an order.

ChristineThey're participating in a game in which the rules are clearly established.

HughYes. No, that's exactly right. And whereas if you are one of the ones that steps up and you are temporary custodian, especially in dependency, neglect, and abuse cases. Mm-hmm. And while they're supposed to be done within 60 days or whatever the statute says now, they last years, especially in Jefferson County, they go on forever. Mm-hmm. Things keep getting continued, keep getting continued. You might have 12 court appearances before you go in for anything substantive and it's ridiculous, but. It's likely that if you're a temporary custodian, you are going to be fulfilling the role as a parent for a very long time. Only for at some point , the [00:04:00] everything just be pulled right out from under you and you discarded as if you don't have any right to participate in anything. And, and I I have a big problem with that, but I'm seeing that this case where someone was named defacto. Custodian and then later is completely disregarded and not held, you know?

ChristineYeah. It appears like that. Yeah. It just appears that like the court's so frustrated that this defacto custodian is still like, Hey, I want parenting time with this child, or I want time with this child. And the court is very much, and this is a natural mother whom they're allegations that there has been a death involving another one of her children, for which she was at least a. Witness to, or like in close proximity when, when it happened? Mm-hmm. That there are allegations that this natural mother has had her rights terminated to other children, or

Hughone child at least.

ChristineAnd there are allegations that she's picked up at least two, if not three new criminal actions like. [00:05:00] While she is the, as the natural mother. And these aren't

Hughtraffic ticket criminal actions?

ChristineNo, no, no, no.

HughSome of them, I think, alleged organized crime, if I remember correctly. I think criminal syndicate

Christinewas one of the charges. I think per usual it was amended down and it probably pled to something else. But it just seems in reading the. Pleadings that the court, and this is in Lori Goodwin's court, the court is so frustrated with the defacto that's filing motions, like, I'm not getting the time that's ordered, or this isn't in the child's best interest. You know, can, it would be terrifying for a child to be in a situation where the. Parent was arrested while they had parenting time. Yeah. You know what I mean? That would be a terrifying thing for the child. And that puts the child in danger of going to foster care or anything like that, even temporarily.

HughThis was something that I would see and would be very frustrating in my practice when, when it, especially when it came to grandparents. Grandparents, if they're not. Temporary custodians in a dependency case, or they're [00:06:00] not de facto custodians in a custody case. They have finite rights under the law. Mm-hmm. They can very often play an outsized role in custody issues and they can tend to drive litigants, attorneys, judges a little bit crazy because. You know, they are very interested in what happens with those kids, but legally they don't have a lot of standing. Mm-hmm. I can understand if I'm sitting on the bench and I have lots of grandparents on my docket involved in the actual parents' cases that you, because grandparents' rights are so limited, you might. There might be this preconception about any grandparent who's in a case, but it's just once they're made defacto, custodian. Yeah. And they have that standing to seek these things, you have to treat them like the other litigants in the case. Well, in

Christinethis case, the defacto is not a grandparent.

HughOh, it's not a grandparent. No.

ChristineOkay. Is [00:07:00] this is the defacto that took care of this child? The allegations, or I guess, I mean, there's a finding of defacto, but mom was incarcerated and I think father was out of the picture. And so this is a person that quote unquote raise this child, and I'm using the word raise this child as how we would just talk about it in day to day life. Yeah. And so there's also a difference, like this is a person that stepped up. You know what I mean? This is. One of those tragic stories, like in reading this and you're just like. Oh my gosh. As far as the humane thing to do and the right thing to do, took this child in, raised this child, and then now the child is put in a very different circumstance and the person that stepped up and raised this kid, that's not even a grandparent. And I think the person, you know, I don't know. I could see where you get in this situation because you get attached to a child and you're like, oh, maybe I'm just watching this kid for a short period of time while somebody's in jail. And then it just goes on and on and on, and you're like, oh, it happens all the time. Yeah. And you're like, oh, now [00:08:00] and the saddest part about that is, is like, I remember talking with a guy that did do foster care and. It took years, obviously to get the adoption finalized. And this person told me was like, it would be a hundred times worse now if I lost the child. Not only, not just for me and my husband, because me and my husband are gonna be a mess no matter what. Like, we're dead. Like it's over for us if we lose this baby. Yeah. But now this baby, when we first got her, it could, you know, like we were the ones that were immediately attached and now she would never be the same. Like she, she. Looks to us like if she scrapes her knee, you know what I mean? It's enough to make you cry. Yeah. Like the last three months of it, it was just like he and his husband were like, oh my God, like this has to get finalized. Because not only you think it would all be only be happening to you, but what it does to the child, I guess is what I'm trying to say. Like the child needs that source of the person that provided them care.

HughYeah. And most of the cases that I actually took up, you know, into higher courts were. [00:09:00] Temporary custodians or primary caretakers who were not related.

ChristineYeah.

HughAnd you just, yep. You're not family by blood, so you get treated differently and you know it once you have custodial rights either or custodial standing. Mm-hmm. Either through defacto or temporary custodian or something like that. You now are. You're in the case. Yeah. You, you need to be given consideration. In fact, you are the person that has stepped up and actually done the parenting and taking care of the child. It drives me crazy when people are basically discarded. Yep. That, oh, now the parents are, you know, for a nanosecond, you know, having clean drug. Screenings and all this, you need just to get outta here. And it's like, well no, because I have legal standing, I get to ask for these things.

ChristineExactly. And it goes to show, so this is a case where you have someone that stepped up, like the de facto custodian. I think I read somewhere in the pleading that it took over a [00:10:00] year to get a court order, which we are getting a ton of submissions out of Lori Goodwin's that it's taking. Six months a year. And remember that time we were there and there was that stupid fight. I say stupid fight, but that fight about where the kid was gonna go to school. And one of the attorneys was like, judge, we've been waiting on an order for you.

HughOh. It was the the person. Oh gosh.

ChristineIt's the case where the child literally wasn't in school. Yeah. At the beginning of school, like two or three weeks into school, allegedly. We can go back and look. We did a podcast on it, but the kid was not enrolled in school at all because the judge hadn't issued a ruling from like months and months and months ago. And that's the real life ramifications of not issuing these orders, you know? Oh, yeah.

HughYeah. I mean, you create these problems by not issuing orders if you have someone who is in a temporary caretaking position. There have been, I've seen, especially out of dependency neglect in abuse court, defacto custodians are made because. Nothing happens and the case isn't moved [00:11:00] forward and the person meets the statutory deadline. Mm-hmm. It meets the statutory period of time and then it becomes much more complicated. Yep. Which is why issue were the cases I took up on appeal because. Yeah. All of a sudden you've got judges that are saying, okay, well now we're ready to conclude this dependency, neglect, and abuse action a year and a half after it started, and we, you know, the statute says, we gotta return. Well, you know what? The statute also says that you've waited so long. Now you've got this other person who can claim some standing to custody in this filed in action. This is far more complex than it would've been if you hadn't taken this long. To dispose of this action.

ChristineYep. And then it goes back to just the equal protection under the law or how these courts have little to no consistency. Because just to recap a little bit, we have a natural mother who is incarcerated at the early portion of a child's life that has picked up new criminal charges, that there allegations was present when a child passed that has allegedly had rights. Terminated to [00:12:00] another child, and she is having the majority of the parenting time with this child. Where then you go to another division and one expert can say, you're doing this, and all of a sudden you have therapeutic visitation with your child.

HughWell, not just an expert, you can have FOC say it or the other parents say it like,

Christineyeah,

Hughyou know, you, you, had someone tease your child at a birthday party or something like that, and you don't see your kids unsupervised except for through supervision for years. Yep. And temporary order hell.

ChristineYep. Temporary order. Hell

Hughyeah.

ChristineAnd also, you know, it just makes zero sense. Like there should be some level of consistency because you have someone jumping up and down saying, oh my gosh, I am the, defacto custodian, I'll take care of this child. Mom's violated the law, got arrested again and obviously has the presumption of innocence, but it's just like, and there's a GAL appointed in this case. And I really hope. That that GAL has met with the child to see what the [00:13:00] child's wishes are. It's a younger child, but it's just like, how is it that if you had the same fact pattern and we have 10 divisions in Louisville in one situation, you know, if this case that's in front of Lori Goodwin were in front of Lauren Ogden, that mom wouldn't have seen her child for years.

HughYeah. I don't, I, but I don't think that's a necessarily a systemic problem. I think it's a problem. I mean, to the extent that, aside from the judges themselves, because the law is clear on what you should do. There could be some formality type rule, you know, there could be some procedural type rules that could help saying that orders need to be issued within a reasonable period of time and things like that that would, would keep some of these things from happening, but. If the law is pretty clear on how you handle things and how you treat people and who has standing and who doesn't. Mm-hmm. I think the inconsistency, a lot of it is just failure to apply the law as it is, and failure to actually acknowledge what the rules are and to carry out I mean. [00:14:00] You get tons of inconsistency, for instance, on dependency, neglect, and abuse cases. Totally. Like tons. Yeah. And that is spelled out that entire process, step by step, what you can and can't do. That is spelled out more than anything else that we do in family court. I don't, you know, it's not that there, this inconsistency happens because of all this gray area in the law. It's just ignoring the deadlines, ignoring the procedure, and not putting in place written orders, just saying things and never writing it down. Yeah, and I think.

ChristineWell, and also for listeners, dependency, neglect and abuse is gonna have different legal standards sometimes, right? They have sometimes, yeah. They have clear and convincing as opposed to preponderance of the evidence. There is much more statutory requirements in dependency, neglect, and abuse cases because of the constitutional, it triggers the constitutional protection, which is why parents are appointed attorneys in that scenario. But like you said, even though that's a stricter or higher scrutiny, scrutiny can have a [00:15:00] legal. Mean connotation to it. I'm kind of using, using it loosely here.

HughYeah.

ChristineBut it's a stricter scrutiny. We still have vastly different outcomes depending on the division. It's

Hughnot even just the scrutiny, it's the fact that the procedures are spelled out.

ChristineYeah, yeah, yeah.

HughHearing shall be held. This needs to be held with this many days. Like, I mean, it's, there is, in fact it's annoying how much there is in the statute 'cause it's very constraining. Mm-hmm. As a litigant, but it should make the job so much easier for the court system because it says you have to do X, Y, and z and that it's just, there shouldn't, there's not room for the inconsistency between, if you are, if you have your kids taken. It could be the difference between six to seven, eight months if you land in this division, whether versus landing next door. Yep. And the way that those dockets are handled and hearings are carried out and the the authority given to appointed people. And it just, the [00:16:00] inconsistency is not in the law. I think it's in, it's,

Christineit falls back on the judges is what you're saying.

HughYeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think so.

ChristineAnd big picture. If y'all, we can't show you what happens on the dependency neglect and abuse docket. Nope. If y'all saw it, it would unite this country in ways that I can't even fully agreed, articulate, agreed. Because the trauma, the. Inadequacy, the ineffectiveness, the incompetence, the true danger. How we allow as a society, children to live and be governed. People would be at the courthouse the next day protesting

Hugh, If somebody recorded, just the interactions that happen in the conference room where the decisions are made. Yeah. And what happens with these kids. And the flippant mm-hmm. And disrespectful way that people are referred to and talked about and the generalizations made about the kid or this problem. Mm-hmm. How it just, it's so factory like, it is [00:17:00] so different than talking about any other actual human. Issues. Yep. Yep. If you showed that video and then told people, this is how decisions are made for kids, the most vulnerable in society mm-hmm. That are being removed from dangerous situations from their home. I would be blown away if every single person seeing that wasn't shocked. Mm-hmm. Unless they've. Become jaded like a family law practitioner who's actually just seen it too many times.

ChristineOh, it could bring a grown man to tears. It would be so unbelievable that I think it would be like you're joking. Yeah. And every single person, every elected official would lose the next election. That's how horrific it is. And this is not a one-off. And this is something too that disproportionately affects lower income people. Period.

HughOh yeah, absolutely.

ChristineAnd it's just, I don't wanna say they don't give a, but the system is designed in a way that it's sort of, the system enables, they don't give a type vibe. Right.

HughWell, and the, I mean, you're [00:18:00] appointed, you get appointed an attorney because the constitutional rights that are at stake, but wasn't that attorney sitting right next to the prosecutor and everyone else in the same court, you know. Conference room, and they're just going one case by the note out of a bin and looking at 'em and discussing them in generalities. It's all part of the same system. Yep.

ChristineAnd then if you get the luck of the draw and you get one of the badass dependency, neglect and abuse parents', attorneys. Yeah. And they make a legit legal argument and kick the ass of somebody that works for the child support office. Yeah. Or you know, the prosecutor's office. You there will be absolute hell to pay. There are two incidents that happened in Louisville. I'm not gonna go into specifics about where the retaliation from, quote unquote, the establishment for the attorney that spoke out hell. Didn't you tell a a story about that?

HughWell, I mean, I know that it happens to private attorneys. I would get involved in cases and yeah, but I wasn't court appointed. But there are some, there are court appointed attorneys over there that fight [00:19:00] like hell for their clients. And do a great job, and they frustrate the hell out of everyone over there. And even when I don't necessarily agree with them, I absolutely love that. Mm-hmm. I love that there are people in there that, you know, they, they do their job.

ChristineThere is a small group, well not a small group. There's a group of people within that system that just want to, they think it's almost the same. I didn't even think about it until this moment, honestly. But you know how we have, in private cases, the judges treat GALs and FOCs higher than they treat other attorneys in these dependency, neglect and abuse secret dockets that involve CPS. The judges treat the caseworkers and the county attorney's office better than the other attorneys?

HughWell, it depends. It depends if you're a parent's attorney that was appointed by that court and regularly practice as one of those groups of people on that docket. Mm-hmm. I think you generally get treated fairly well. If you're private attorney coming in from the outside, you got an uphill battle. But when I got [00:20:00] appointed, I mean, I've talked about this in previous podcasts, I get appointed as a GAL just to represent. Someone who's incarcerated. Yeah. Just to make sure they're served and they get to file a response to something like custody related or whatever. You know, everyone would be frustrated with me because. I would come in and they just expect me to say, okay, I've served him, whatever, you guys move on and do whatever you want. But I actually read the pleadings. Mm-hmm. And if they were deficient, I put on a legal defense and I would make people have to refile things. Mm-hmm. And that would be a pain in the ass. And I love to see that there are some people within the system that are doing that, but I also hate. That a child's entire future and a parent's rights are dependent on whether you get appointed one of those attorneys, you get appointed one of the ones that's just gonna go along with every single thing that happens at that table where you sit.

ChristineTerrifying. And we will do some more deep diving on this case. Truly just traumatic, but it shows if you had to put a pendulum is that the right word? Like as far as the differences [00:21:00] in how Jefferson County courts are done, you'd have Ogden on this side and you'd have good one on this side, don't you think? Not

Hughspectrum,

Christineyeah. Yeah, the spectrum. As far as and somewhere's, somebody's gonna fall here in the middle and like what behavior would cause you to lose your child or children?

HughI don't see them all that differently because in both cases things were done that affected people's rights to their kids without, I mean, without process. Not necessarily in that one we're talking about, but one of the issues that I've had in three in the past and been involved in sort of as. Council Advisory Council on some big appeals and some things that were going on where I was, yeah. I was brought in by attorneys to sort of talk through and help with Ritz and things like that on, are both of them do things without hearings that deprive people of custodial rights, and so I don't see them as opposite ends of any kind of a spectrum. I see laws not being carried out, people withstanding being ignored [00:22:00] and. Things being entered just because at this moment I think that this is int the kid's best interest. I'm gonna do it. You know, go do what you have to do. Take me upstairs, go to the court of appeals, whatever. I'm ruling this way without, with, or without a hearing.

ChristineI think you just completely won that argument. And you're right, I'm wrong. It is, it's like two sides of the same coin or whatever that fucking saying is. I have, right. No

Hughidea. But I'm scared.

ChristineI know you win. I'm scared you. No, you're right. They're just doing it differently. It's almost like, if you think about it, they just came early. Chris, this is the actual fundamental, this is the problem. I'm not gonna say that anymore. I say it too many fucking times, but that these judges are doing the same thing by violating due process, allegedly, and doing whatever they want, but they're just bringing their own bias to the bench. And so the outcomes may be different, but the fact that they're violating the law or how they treat and respect the law is the same. That's fucking genius, dude.

HughBut I think that

Christineyou're right. My issue

Hughwith division three. For a long time has been how people who stepped up either got temporary [00:23:00] custody or our defacto custodians get discarded and treated as if they have no standing. They shouldn't be included in anything. And you know, the court of appeals has. Has actually acted on requests for relief. And, and Writs saying that, no, you don't get to do these things unilaterally. You have to consider these people's rights. Yeah. So that happens.

ChristineWell, we'll keep following, submit your stories. We are in the thousands upon thousands of stories. Judge-y you'll be out soon so y'all can judge the judges like they judge you. See ya.

Speaker 6Yeah. Yeah. We need some. Justice. Justin found justice.

SpeakerContent of this podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only. It is not intended to be and should not be construed as legal advice. Engaging with this content does not [00:24:00] create an attorney-client relationship between you and the hosts, guests, or their firms. The views and opinions expressed on this podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of any law firm, company or organization. We make no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, completeness, or applicability of the information presented. Any reliance on the information in this podcast is at your own risk. Laws are constantly changing and every situation is unique. You should always seek the advice of a qualified attorney for your specific legal concerns.