Judge-yGet the app

Episode 40

Mommy Jail

The JudgeMental Podcast27 minFull transcript

EP 41 Mommy Jail
Watch on YouTube

About this episode

The JudgeMental Podcast – EP 41: Mommy Jail In this gripping episode of The JudgeMental Podcast, Christine and Hugh break down a shocking incident in family court where a mother was abruptly jailed by Judge Ogden. The hosts recount the courtroom drama, including the judge’s reaction to claims of due process violations, the role and neutrality of the Friend of the Court (FOC), and the controversial use of psychological evaluations as punitive measures. Key Topics Discussed: The events leading up to a mother being remanded to jail during a motion hour. The judge’s handling of courtroom decorum and due process rights. The FOC’s emotional response and questions about neutrality. The use of psych evals in family court and their impact on parents. Broader patterns in Louisville Family Court, especially regarding the treatment of Black mothers. The importance of transparency, accountability, and the need for reform in family court practices. Christine and Hugh invite listeners to share their own stories and experiences with family court, Judge Ogden, or FOC conflicts. Connect with the show and join the conversation at the judge-y app or visit judge-y.com. Disclaimer: The content of this podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice. Always consult a qualified attorney for your specific legal concerns. Listen now to get the full story and join the movement for justice in family court! LEGAL DISCLAIMER The content of this podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only. It is not intended to be, and should not be construed as, legal advice. Engaging with this content does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and the hosts, guests, or their firms. The views and opinions expressed on this podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of any law firm, company, or organization. We make no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, completeness, or applicability of the information presented. Any reliance on the information in this podcast is at your own risk. Laws are constantly changing, and every situation is unique. You should always seek the advice of a qualified attorney for your specific legal concerns.

Transcript

5,188 words · about 23 minutes to read. Automatically transcribed and lightly edited; speaker labels are approximate.

[00:00:00]

ChristineAll right, judge Ogden. Put a mom in jail.

HughShe did. She did it rather abruptly. And it was, honestly, I've seen some, I've seen some stuff in my time litigating in family court. I've seen people arrested try to run from the judge to keep from going to jail. Yep. I've seen all kinds of stuff. I don't think I've seen. Anything like that before

Christineit was completely disproportionate. And for let's be very, let's use the right verbiage. During a court hearing, the judge remanded a mother to a holding cell in the back. And while we were there in motion hour, indicated that this mom was gonna spend a couple nights in jail. Right. And

Hughthen order that she get a psych eval.

ChristineYeah, yeah.

HughBased on her. And said specifically based on her conduct in the courtroom.

Christine[00:01:00] Yeah. , I have seen people say and do all kinds of crazy things in court. Oh, I've seen

Hughattorneys, yeah. Be far more disruptive and disrespectful. In their arguments at motion hour and not even get a rebuke from a judge than this person did that ended up getting, being locked up. And you know, , I know she has now been released.

ChristineShe was released same day.

HughYeah. And, but the judge said you need to. Been a few nights or a few days in jail.

ChristineAnd so we, I immediately requested the tape, but, and this is one of those, you know, I love the, like psychological studies or whatever where it's like, how much do you actually remember? But this is, if I had to say under oath, what I remember happening, it was a motion to remove an FOC on the case. Correct. And the woman, the mom that was remanded, had an attorney that was there on her behalf on Zoom.

HughOn Zoom,

Christineand the mom was there

Hughin person.

ChristineThe mom was there, she was sitting at counsel's table very respectfully. Like actually she had this cute sweater on that said Mother on the background. I [00:02:00] really, on the back, I really loved it. I remember seeing

Hughit. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

ChristineAnd it was like funky. I really loved it. It was kind of like eighties vibe. Yeah, it

Hughwas. That's right.

ChristineBut anyway, so they're, there renewing emotion to remove the FOC based on some new stuff, which I think was grounds for removal in my opinion. The FOC had a very emotional reaction. The FOC had not filed a report as required. The FOC wanted to stay on the case

Hughand, well, , the new information in this new motion was that there is litigation not related to this family court case that involved both the FOC and one of the parties.

ChristineYeah. So this mom had filed to have the FOC Pashens Fitzpatrick removed. I don't know when really, I think months ago. Based on the fact that the FOC and opposing counsel were sorority sisters, the judge calls the motion, the judge says something along the lines, oh, they were sorority sisters. That's not enough. Then mom's attorney says, there's more information now. Mom has been [00:03:00] subpoenaed as an adverse witness in a circuit civil case, and the judge, of course, judge Ogden hadn't reviewed hadn't read the motion, in my opinion. She,

Hughbecause she said, you know, when she said, oh yes, I know you're asking to recuse her because they were sorority, they were sorority sisters. Mm-hmm. Or something. You know, this mother's attorney said, no, judge, it's, you know, these are new grounds. Mm-hmm. And the judge had not said, oh, I hadn't seen that. Of course. Yeah. It was prominent in the motion. It was the crux of the motion being filed and then being heard that day. So clearly the judge had not read the motion that was before her.

ChristineSo then the FOC kind of goes off and is talking, defending herself. I think she does a dog whistle to the court, basically. Because this other. Civil action is apparently there's some litigation or some mention of litigation against a different family court judge, judge Ward. Mm-hmm. And that's what really caused Judge Ogden to change, in my opinion.

HughYeah, that's true., There was mention, so there FOC [00:04:00] is. Getting to speak to the judge. Mm-hmm. Now, this FOC is not an acting attorney in the case. It's not a GAL not making legal argument. This is a person that's there to investigate and, you know, we've, we've been through, over and over , the requirement for them to file a report and then have 10 days. This is a little bit of a weird situation because there's been allegations about her ability to handle this appointment correctly and needing to be removed, but. If the judge needs to hear from someone who is a witness, someone appointed as a, an investigate in an investigatory role, that person needs to be under oath.

ChristineYeah. No one was sworn in. We need

Hughto have a hearing. Yeah. So instead, judge Ogden gave the floor to the FOC to say whatever she wanted. And during the FOCs. Rather long response, emotional defensive response. And I get it. I would be a little no res, I would be a [00:05:00] little defensive with allegations are made, but I,

Christineno,

Hughthe way that she respond and spoke about the mother basically highlighted why she should not be on this case a hundred percent and she can't continue on as this case. But the judge didn't seem to react that way to it. Yeah. But when another judge, an action against another judge was mentioned, you could tell that there was a change , in the way that the judge's demeanor was. Yep. And the facial expression and everything.

ChristineAnd FOCs are supposed to be neutral. That is literally on the order of appointing most FOCs, like you're a neutral investigative. Fact finder to issue a report to the court 10 days prior to hearing blah, blah, blah. There's no question in my mind there's that the FOC in that moment was not NOT acting neutral.

HughThere's, yeah. I don't think there's anyone in, even the best attorney in the world isn't gonna be able to argue against that. Yeah. It was a very pointed [00:06:00] response. It was emotional, it was. It just showed that there is a conflict, real or perceived between this FOC and the mother, which I think is what the mother's attorney's been saying for multiple motions now. Yeah, to remove her, aside from the fact that she also hasn't filed a report or any of this stuff that she was appointed to do, allegedly, I don't know. I looked at that wasn't part, that's not part of what I'm necessarily looking at here. I'm looking at how the judge is handling things here, not necessarily the attorneys.

ChristineWell, for the listeners, I did look at the file and I did not. See that a report had been filed. Okay. Now it's possible. I guess that one had not been e-filed, but I, I didn't see one. That's true. You know? Yeah.

HughAnd sometimes things get filed through the clerk's office and they do not get scanned in into court net, so we don't see them. Mm-hmm. Sometimes they get notated in court net, but the scan isn't there for us to see. So there it is possible that one was filed there, but the allegations were That one hasn't been. Yeah. So we're, we're taking the, yeah. The attorney who filed the motion at their word, they're saying that no order was filed. , And when Christine looked online, she [00:07:00] didn't see an order. I mean, sorry, a report.

ChristineYeah.

HughSo

Christineand so the other thing is we are probably like 10 minutes into this podcast. We got a mom that was. Put in jail in a holding cell in the back. And at this point in the story, mom has not said anything. So you had the attorney make the argument? I thought it was a well, well-made argument. She was, yeah,

Hughshe did, she did a good job. She explained it out. She said it in a very analytical way, but a very clear way laying out why this FOC needed to be removed from the case.

ChristineAnd so then the FOC responds, and then after the FOC responds. My recollection is that Mom said something along the lines of everything she's saying is a lie. Your Honor, we have evidence.

HughYes, and I think she said it. So the FOC. And in, in my experience in front of Judge Ogden, she can let people just go on and on as long as they want. Mm-hmm. So she was letting the FOC go on, she was making statements about the [00:08:00] mom. Mm-hmm. And the mom was sitting there quieting quietly listening to it, and finally spoke up and said something. Now, if you speak over someone, and it happens all the time in court, you usually will hear from the judge and the judge will say, let them finish. I will give you a chance to speak. I've done it many times. I've done it as a tactic many times to break the cadence of someone that's just going on and on and on there, there. It's just something that happens in the court. It is not something that if someone you go to jail for speaks over someone else that you go to jail for and honestly. There have been plenty of times where I have been in Judge Ogden's court where someone keeps speaking over me and she won't say anything and I think there's no courtroom control at all and I'm getting frustrated 'cause she lets people talk over each other. So it is. Out the ordinary for Yes, the mother to speak up this way. And I think she said, judge, or Your Honor, and she, she was polite about it. Yeah. And she wasn't yelling, she wasn't screaming.

ChristineShe was emphatic. I mean, she was a little spicy, but Yeah.

HughWell, she, yeah. I mean, she [00:09:00] felt that there were lies, but the judge's reaction that basically said. You're not gonna interrupt this proceeding. Basically, you don't get to speak. Yeah. You have an attorney here. You don't speak, you have an attorney. You don't get to speak and basically I'm gonna let the FOC, who isn't sworn in, I'm gonna let her say whatever she wants and you don't get to say anything about it.

ChristineYeah.

HughNow

Christinethen it just seemed like it, the judge heightened. This emotional response, I mean, times 10. Oh yeah. And then it was like very much, you know, you and I are in the courtroom watching, there were other attorneys there, and then there's something about like, you know, you're not gonna get to talk and you need to leave. And then the mom says something and then the mom says about appealing to a higher court and you're not violating my due process. Well,

Hughso the, so the judge said, do you need to go in my holding cell? Yeah. And cool off. And the woman said. Something to the effect of, oh, that's fine if you just want to [00:10:00] deny my due process rights.

ChristineYeah. Or violate. Yeah. Yeah. Violate my

Hughdue process rights. And that was, that was the end.

ChristineYep. And that was like, oh, you're gonna spend a couple days in jail. And again, we'll get the full tape, like we can't record it in real time. And there is a recording of it. I've already requested it, but we were taking

Hughnotes and

ChristineYeah. But the second that due process, and y'all know, judge Ogden has been overturned by the Court of Appeals on numerous occasions. Numerous two emergency orders where she blatantly violated due process.

HughAnd that's always highlighted in those orders.

ChristineYeah.

HughThe, it's, it's for the violation of people's due process. So that's a hot button issue. It should never be, due process should never be a hot button issue. No, not in the United States with a constitution.

ChristineBut, and it shouldn't be violated like, you know how rare it is. For the court of appeals to be like you blatantly violated due process. Like there could be other procedural issues or like an issue of first impression that goes before the court or like interpreting a statue. But just, I mean, it, it's truly wild. And you know, this podcast we have called for Judge Ogden to either resign or be [00:11:00] removed. It's too much at this point. I know that she feels the pressure on her. I do think her reaction was unhinged. I think she's under an immense amount of pressure. Publicly.

HughSure. I mean, there wasn't really a proper warning. There wasn't I don't, I don't remember her asking the woman to leave before, before I think she did okay. But I, I don't remember that. I just remember as soon as the woman said something about due process, the judge said, I'm holding you in . I'm holding you in contempt of court. You're gonna spend a few nights in jail and order the, the bailiff to. Lock her up.

ChristineYeah. And y'all, the mom's like, you're gonna said something about she was a, had a special needs child, like you're gonna lock up a mom with a special needs child. Or, I'm just trying to advocate for my special needs child and the judge puts her in the back or you know, orders that she'd be taken to the back in the holding cell. I went and looked at the file and the father doesn't even live in the state.

HughYeah. So this, this is a kid that. I, I'm, I don't know what arrangements were made or whether she was allowed [00:12:00] to make arrangements for this child to be picked up who was caring for this child, but clearly none of those things were considerations for Judge Ogden. She just got angry about, you know, the statement that she was violating her due process, right? Yep. And. And so she just locked her up, didn't engage in violated or due process, right? Locked her up. I'm not gonna let you speak. I'm gonna let a witness speak against you, not gonna let you speak or respond to it. And then when you try to and state that you have a right to do it. I'm gonna lock you up. I mean, it was, I. And, and

Christinein 15 years I have never, I have seen people act out of pocket in court for sure. For sure. This didn't even come close to rising to the level of incarceration, in my opinion.

HughNo,, I agree with that. And, and, and to be fair, judges have broad discretion in maintaining the decorum. And the order in their courtroom if this woman had stood up and was yelling and trying to interrupt the proceedings and keep it from going forward. Absolutely. [00:13:00] That's the kind of thing you use this for. Mm-hmm. But that isn't what happened here. No. And there were lots, there were a lot of people in the courtroom while we were sitting there. There were really audible and I can't wait to hear the video to see if you can hear people, but there were gasps. Yeah.

Christine, In this. I didn't know what to do. Courtroom.

HughIt caught everyone's attention. And then afterwards, people were talking about multiple people. People have been practicing longer than I ever practiced saying they'd never seen anything like that. So it was, it was significant.

ChristineYes. And I mean, honestly, it's, I think we got a lot of questions afterwards. Do we think that our presence heightened it? It's possible.

HughSure. But I mean, I mean,

Christinewas she sit, was she putting her, her like an innocent person in custody as a warning to us to shut our mouths and stop talking about it?

HughNo, we weren't talking in court, so no, no. We can't hold stop publicly from talking here. Yeah, I don't know. All I know is she is under a lot of scrutiny, not just from us. She is constantly being scrutinized by the court of appeals. There are other appeals that are, you know, pending [00:14:00] there. There are plenty of things that have been filed because of her behavior. I was just really surprised. With all of the heat that's been on her with us sitting in the courtroom, that she would act that way. Yeah. And that tells me, you know, we've questioned in past podcasts, why, why would she be doing this? Yeah. Does she just not know? Is it an, is it intentional? Is she, is, is is something wrong? I, I think that the intentional actions with us sitting there while she's under all this scrutiny. I think is really informative about what's really going on here. That's all I'll say. I

Christineagree.

HughBut yeah. And,

Christineand it brings us no joy. I mean, and I've talked about this on other podcasts, like, and I know this is like a girl, you know, emotional moment. But you know, judge Ogden is a kind person outside of court. She's always been kind and respectful to me. Me too. And a lot of the judges are not okay. They are not, they're judges that I have very, there is one judge in particular. Y'all know who she is, that I [00:15:00] literally can't be objective. Like I can't be objective when it comes to her. There have been too much, there's been too much that's happened personally and that affected my clients and that that is not Judge Ogden. That being said, what Judge Ogden is doing, like what she did to that mother. It was just so unnecessary what she did in the baby case, insane and unnecessary what she did in the Nevada case, like truly shouldn't happen in the United States of America.

HughNo, that that is true and , I will reiterate what you said. I mean, she is. One of the few judges I've ever seen where we have events within the family court bar where you can sort of speak openly and speak your mind. Judges to attorneys, attorneys to judges. She's one of the only people that I've always felt that I could just come up to , and give feedback and she would take it and talk about it, and there just didn't seem to be an ego there with that at all. Yeah, and I always. Found that to be very, very refreshing.

ChristineOh, that is a brilliant point, what you just said. And we can kind of, we'll pivot a little bit to the [00:16:00] psych eval, but there wasn't ego in the moment of incarcerating her. Like there was ego in the Santry. Recusal, yeah. There was almost like I, she didn't know what to do and she just reacted like an, like a like, don't challenge me. Yeah,

Hughyeah. You're not, you're not gonna. Yeah, I, I agree. And it was, it was

Christinebizarre.

HughI mean, I've seen that, so, you know, it's not a secret. I filed some of the appeals that have been published against Judge Ogden, and in those instances, I also saw that side of her that I'd never seen when she was a practicing attorney or earlier on while she was on the bench. And I definitely saw it in locking that mother up, that You're challenging me, you're going to get my wrath.

Christine, It, it was very retaliatory, but it wasn't like. What is the word that I'm looking for? It wasn't like it was pre-planned or there was like this mal intent. It was like this like immediate reaction and like not [00:17:00] knowing what to do. Like still in that moment I felt sympathy for everyone involved. Now obviously there's a power imbalance and , the only victim in that room no doubt was the mother. Okay. Obviously, I'm not saying that, but it was just kind of pitiful is the word I'm looking for.

HughYeah, no, it was, it was someone that didn't, was. You were watching someone that was put in a position that was very uncomfortable and didn't know how to handle. Yeah,

Christineyeah, yeah. That's, and

Hughit, it's a very basic situation. Literally like when you have pro se persons litigating in front of you all the time, like our family court does. Pro se people, while they are held to the same standards as attorneys, they've, most of them have never been in there.

ChristineYeah. The

Hughdecorum, they don't understand that people will react. They will talk over one another. , They will speak out when one person is telling their side of the story saying that's not true. They get redirected to not do that. Yeah. Over and over. Over. And when I was an attorney representing people, if we had someone on the other side without an attorney, it would happen multiple times in every hearing. Yep. That [00:18:00] person would react while my client was testifying and the judge would have to say, okay, you're going to get to speak. I will make sure your side gets heard, but you don't speak while that person's speaking. Yes sir. Ma'am. That's how you handle it. And you know, there's no doubt that Judge Ogden has to do that all the time on an almost daily basis dealing with Pro Se persons hundred. So this was not. A situation that doesn't come up over and over and over each and every week in this court.

ChristineAnd that's why I think it was the dog whistle. I think it really was the FOC, just being able to spew all of this information about the other civil lawsuit against the FOC. I really think the court was kind of just reacting quick in time and defending the FOC at all costs, insanely inappropriate. And then let's get onto the psych eval. I mean, psych evals are the new lobotomies. In family court?

HughI wanna say in response to what you just said, , I think that using the words due process had an effect on the judge when, when she said something about due process. Yeah, the psych eval part, [00:19:00] you know, so after she remand her to custody, locks her up, makes a comment about she needs to spend several days in jail or several nights. I don't remember what the comment was, but it was multiple days. Couple. Yeah. Yeah. Couple. That. She said to this woman's attorney who was still on Zoom because of your client's behavior in this court, I'm gonna order a psych evaluation like. Based on someone pointing out that the FOC was not telling the truth.

ChristineAllegedly.

HughAllegedly, yeah. And

Christinewell now there, there was a motion on for a psych eval, but I think psych evals are utilized as weapons in family court psyche value course they are. Psych evals are stupid. And you guys, I have decided that I'm gonna get one. I'm gonna get several. I'm gonna get tons. I've actually, I'm gonna reach out to Marvin and McCrary to see how much, much it would cost for them to do a psych eval on me. Kathryn Burle, I'll reach out to you to see how much it would cost. I will have any psych eval that anyone will pay for. And we'll fundraise some money to try to get me psych evals. Oh man. And they can be completely released. [00:20:00] I'll sign whatever it is. I will limit, I will reduce all liability to anybody and everybody. I don't have to read 'em. You can publish 'em. Love. I can't object to anything that you say. I can't object to anything that you do. Because you know, and I, we already know what it's gonna say for the most part.

HughBut I, oh, it'll be so much fun for people to confirm what I already know. Yeah.

ChristineGeneralized anxiety disorder, you know, like, a little bit of a hypochondriac, LOL, but, and maybe something else, but it is what it is, but it's, it is such a weapon that is utilized by people going through one of the most difficult times in their entire life to take away their children.

Hugh, Yeah, it is one thing to have ordered that it's one thing to order it punitively. Right after you've locked someone up, so it was okay. Locking you up is not punishment enough, but. And you, you pointed out that there had been a motion filed for it. Yeah, but the judge made clear it wasn't because of the motion, it's because of what she did in court. She's asking for she's requiring a psychological evaluation. [00:21:00] She was punishing this woman with a psycho evaluation for making those statements that we have. You know, revealed here? Yeah, just those statements and you get a psych evaluation.

ChristineIt's like, from the review of the file, it appears that she's the sole provider of this special needs child. And so it, what is the point of the psych eval? Like to punish the person that's been the sole provider of the child their entire life. Like I just, psych evals, the involvement of psychiatry, psychologist. Therapist, play therapist, court ordered therapist, you know, and again, all these people that are doing these things. Once you're appointed by the court, it comes with immunity. What are we doing and I'm gonna say it in Kentucky, and I follow more cases than you probably. Yep. And this is my belief and , I'll stand by it, but we've got a real problem in Louisville Family Court where black mothers are being painted as crazy and this is happening in every court, [00:22:00] regardless of the judge's sexual identity, race, religion, gender, it is a pattern that I cannot not see.

HughOkay. This is not something that, that, you know,, I'm very concerned about that, and I, it's something that I'm going to be watching for and I'm gonna be, I'm gonna be looking at as well.

ChristineWell, and this woman that was remained a custody, she was a black female, black mom. Correct. And I have seen men. Attorneys fathers say that's a lie, nothing happened to 'em. I have, I'm following a couple cases right now, out of all different divisions, even when there are high asset cases involving black or African American females, it seems to be this propensity to say they're crazy. Hmm. And that's just , you know, that's a pattern that I'm looking. We wanna hear all your stories on Judge Dash y. That mom was released. I looked at the court order. Court orders were not entered as far as the confinement or whatever, at least as of like an [00:23:00] hour ago. And today is what is today?

HughThursday.

ChristineOkay. And so that's four days later. And this

Hughhappened on Monday. Yep.

ChristineBut there was an order for the psych eval and there was some other orders setting the hearing. So we will wait, but I think. There's no question that first off, the FOC should be removed and Judge Ogden can't stay on this case.

HughYeah, so I, I think this is, there are a lot of things here I would be interested to hear from practitioners about. Number one, what you've brought up about the pattern re related to black females is fascinating to me, and I would like to hear. If other people have noticed that kind of a pattern, because I think that's something important to highlight if it's happening. Number two, whether or not an FOC should be able to speak in motion hour. Now we've talked about it in situations where if they are giving their report or talking about the case, this was a little bit different. Yeah. 'cause there are allegations that she cannot properly do the job, but the role of the FOC. [00:24:00] As an investigatory witness doesn't change, even though the allegations don't pertain to the parents themselves necessarily. Yep. I still think, you know, the rules are the same about whether or not they can speak at the motion hour, but. It's something that I'd never considered before, and I'd like to, I'd like to hear what people think about whether or not an FOC should be able to defend themselves from that kind of a motion, or whether they should have a hearing and the FOC , they should be able to hash out those facts with the FOC serving as a witness testifying about those facts.

ChristineI think the notion that an FOC is ever quote unquote defending themselves in and of itself is a problem. Well, that's

Hugha different question. That's a different question. Also a very good point, but that's a different question about Totally. You know, whether or not you, you have, you know, what we talk about as Emberton rights. Yeah. You know, to, if that FOC can really come in and. Speak the way that this fo this, the [00:25:00] judge permitted this FOC too. I'm not saying that FOC did anything wrong here. The judge ask her to speak. Yeah. And whether or not that was proper and whether an FOC should be able to speak without being sworn and tell the court things that the court acts on in any capacity, even if it's not directly related to the clients in the case. I, I'm interested to hear what people think.

ChristineAbsolutely judge y.com. Tell us your Ogden stories. Tell us your FOC stories. We're really gonna do some deep dive. We had so many recusal motions and removal motions. Yep. We're gonna start really kinda looking at, into conflicts of interest within the family court bar.

HughYep. I think I think we're gonna find a lot

Speaker 6Yeah. Yeah. We need some. Justice. Justin found justice.

Speaker 2Content of this podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only. It is not intended to be and should not be [00:26:00] construed as legal advice. Engaging with this content does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and the hosts, guests, or their firms. The views and opinions expressed on this podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of any law firm, company or organization. We make no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, completeness, or applicability of the information presented. Any reliance on the information in this podcast is at your own risk. Laws are constantly changing and every situation is unique. You should always seek the advice of a qualified attorney for your specific legal concerns.