Episode 39
Society Loses

About this episode
The JudgeMental Podcast – Episode 39: "Society Loses" In this episode of The JudgeMental Podcast, hosts Hugh and Christine—two lawyers on a mission to bring transparency and accountability to the courts—dive into one of the wildest days in family court. They break down the drama surrounding a high-profile recusal motion, the culture of courtroom banter, and the sometimes shocking realities of judicial conduct. Key topics include: A behind-the-scenes look at the denial of a recusal motion in Shelly Sentry’s courtroom The impact of judges appearing remotely and how it affects courtroom dynamics The “good old boy” culture and its effect on public trust in the legal system The role of guardians ad litem and the ethical dilemmas they face The importance of zealous advocacy and the challenges attorneys encounter when pushing for judicial accountability Reflections on how courtroom behavior shapes perceptions of fairness and justice Hugh and Christine share candid critiques, personal stories, and sharp insights—always with unshakable honesty. Whether you’re a legal professional or just fascinated by the inner workings of the justice system, this episode offers a compelling, unfiltered perspective. Mentioned in this episode: The “judge-y” app and website: your tool for holding judges accountable and sharing your courtroom experiences. Subscribe to The JudgeMental Podcast for more episodes that pull back the curtain on the legal world, and don’t forget to check out “judge-y” for more ways to get involved.
Transcript
5,161 words · about 22 minutes to read. Automatically transcribed and lightly edited; speaker labels are approximate.
[00:00:00]
ChristineWelcome to the Judgmental podcast.
Christineto the Judgmental
Christinefor the denial
Christinefor
Christinethe recusal motion in Shelly
ChristineSantry
Christinecourtroom.
ChristineUm, can you imagine a scenario in which I'm ever wrong? No, because it's not
Christinehappened on this podcast.
HughMy lord,
ChristineI I win.
Hughabout her not recusing to be, fair, to be fair to me, I, pick the opposite side. Just to pick the opposite side. side. Just to pick the opposite side. I said I don't,
Christineuh, yeah. And let me be clear. I win. Society loses like every single bet we've had. That is true. I want to be wrong. That is true.
HughNo, that is absolutely true. And I thought, I mean, you're more cynical than me. Is that possible? It's a little scary.
ChristineIt is. And yesterday, well I you Sunday and I was like, I have the Sunday scaries. And I haven't had those in a a minute and a Like I did not. I just had a feeling. And y'all, yesterday in family court was truly one of the craziest days of my career.
HughIt was, It was, it was [00:01:00] totally different for me. I went there to see one thing and ended up seeing much more as we'll talk about on, a future podcast, but, it is definitely interesting. You were definitely feeling that, that Sunday and I uh, had no feeling whatsoever. No dread, no anticipation.
ChristineI'm surprised by that.
UnknownYeah. It wasn't
HughI didn't miss anything. There wasn't nostalgia. I didn't dread going in there. I didn't have those old feelings like. Before you're in a big trial where where your you know, has butterflies. Yeah. Yeah. It was just, this place I needed to be and I I was watching something. It, it very, uh, I I felt very neutral. It was strange.
ChristineI have this paranoia because I have this addiction to. Two things. sparkling water and electronic communication. And I have two phones and, uh, a Mac and I am petrified that one of them are not gonna be on silent and they're gonna go off, or I'm gonna be doing something and the, court is so mad at me, they're gonna throw me in jail. So I always like check my devices like three times before I go in there. And so
Hughjust getting out and looking at it constantly.
ChristineYeah. And [00:02:00] just like, well, I try to kinda live update, oh yeah, I
Hughagree. Um,
Christinewe can't, they won't let us have 'em.
HughI miss those days I I don't miss having them all together. I, I hated it when I was trying to find one case, but it would be great for
Christinetransparency. Mm-hmm.
HughMm-hmm.
ChristineI remember it was not in
Hughdivision two, judge Sentry's court, but in a later division I was sitting there and each case I was taking notes, and each case I was thinking, oh God, you can't do that.
ChristineMm-hmm.
Hughthere's something we can about. And then the next one would happen. Then the next one would and then, Then shit got crazy and really crazy. It would be, it would be really something for us to be able to play all of those things back to back to the back in the way that we saw
Christinein real real time. Yeah. But
Hughyeah, alas.
ChristineThey know if if public saw what happened, I mean, and I, y'all gotta think about it like So there are are 10 motion hours that are happening. If the public saw one of them that was randomly chosen, they would be very concerned, [00:03:00] would be an understatement. Do
Hughyou know what I'm saying? And you know that that might be an interesting reform. Yeah. to have a motion hour picked. Each week, just one. Mm-hmm. And it's at random and the judges don't know who it's going to be, so that you might think that somebody is going to see how you act at motion hour. And of course, that doesn't apply to everybody who holds motion hour. Like we didn't even go to some because we generally are bored when we're in there. Yeah, that's true. Um, it's certainly specific ones that are routinely, uh, I'll put it this way. There are ones where I will guarantee we will find some content if we go sit through just one motion hour. we almost never sit through the entire motion hour even.
ChristineYep.
HughLike we're leaving before it's over.
ChristineAnd like, before we get into Shelly, double down again, I win. Um, first off, it was weird. She was remote. I think she wasn't feeling
Hughwell, but I don't
ChristinePersonally, and this is my opinion, I do not like judges not being in the courtroom. I think if anybody needs to be in the courtroom, [00:04:00] it needs to judges. But I'm open to, you know, I guess if you got a communicable disease or, you know, whatever. Well,
Hughyou know, I, I'll take the opposite side shocker, the judges should be there, but, um. If there is choice between I'm off, I'm not gonna have motion hour, and everything gets rolled to the next week and gets piled up, or I'm not feeling well and I'm not coming in and getting my staff So if my only choice is to not conduct the motion hour, but I can actually do do it remotely and move some cases forward, I, I appreciate the effort to do that.
ChristineIt was one of those, I think I said to you, if the general public saw this, they would be mortified because it was like good old boy club. Like Stupid little jokes.
HughYeah. we saw different divisions that that, that I think the general public would be appalled by for very different reasons. Mm-hmm. One was just. Bizarre unhinged and the other was [00:05:00] so over the top, laid back, casual, polite, and the, that's intentional, but that it just, I don't know. I think, I know that it rubs both of us the wrong way. Yep. It It may not rub everyone else the wrong way, but this, I mean, the demeanor and the way that things are handled, if you're coming in. And you are pro se and you see attorneys being treated the way that they are. You. It just feeds right into, oh, everybody's just all part of one system. Everybody's in on it together, and I understand wanting to not make it a nasty, you know? Yeah. Not make family law any nastier than it is. Everyone is in that court something's going on in their personal life. That Yep. Nobody is there unless you are getting a hearing date on an adoption or something like that. It is very rare you're in there on anything that you're happy about. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So that I I get that you're treating everybody. You're, You're trying not to be nasty and [00:06:00] make it worse, but it's
Christinefake af af.
HughYeah, just the whole, everybody, you know, I'm just blah, blah, blah, blah. It is just like this. It's still court. Yeah. It's still court. It needs to be. A court of law, it needs to be, you know, I, I don't
Christineknow. And it almost like, it's my personal opinion, that it is Shelly just rubbing it in that it's one big club and I am the queen. is one big club and I'm now the queen. And y'all, I mean, when I tell you she was not the queen before, she was really, really likable and good attorney, which doesn't make popular in the G-A-L-F-O-C-B-F-F with judge thing, you know? I mean, she, in my opinion, she was cool as shit like,
Hughyeah, yeah. No, no, I, I. Yeah. I mean, and
Christinenow it's like I'm a queen of like girls, it was embarrassing as a female to watch and then like. This one attorney is like the kid in school who ask a question for for the sake of asking a
HughOh yeah.
ChristineThose people make me want to punch a Pumpy
Hughpuppy.
ChristineUm,
Hughit You. Yeah. And everybody knows who [00:07:00] those people are. Yes. Just like you did.
Christinein School. Yeah. It's pitiful. It's while yeah. Blah, blah, blah. We
Hughused, we used to have a game in in law school. we used to have this game called tort Bingo, We'd secretly play, uh, and there was this teacher who everyone kissed her ass. Mm-hmm. He She was an adjunct and she had a cool job and all of this. And we had pe. There were just the people that always spoke up, but they did so even more in her. In her, uh, class. So we, you would make a bingo board and you would put the names on it and oh gosh, if you got bingo, you had to ask a hypothetical and use the name bingo in it. So of course it was always a dog bite hypothetical, but that's how you announced to everyone else playing that you won was you would have to raise your hand and ask a hypothetically where the word bingo are. That's
Unknownfunny.
HughBecause it, it, but it was the same people. Yeah. It was easy to predict. Eventually it got so easy. It was the same five people, every class.
Christineacross the middle and you win. Yeah. And this is like a good old boy thing. It was like, so there was this really interesting case, um, that we're gonna have deep dive in involving paternity [00:08:00] and, uh, being on the birth certificate and then these people acted like it was the first time they'd ever heard anything like this, which is not, yeah, that was a
Hughlittle alarming. I mean, oh, it was super alarming. I could almost name the cases that apply, but literally they, they were acting like this is something, oh, this is a new kind of thing. But
Christineno, it's not at all. Um, but one of the attorneys, I guess. Stood in for another attorney the before, which is so common. It's insane. Like Hugh's on vacation. He asked me the week before, Hey, if I get anything in division two, will you cover it? Yeah. No big deal. You know what I so this attorney, and it was all this buddy, buddy was like, your honor, I just wanna be clear that I was here last week, and I don't want my name associated with this case because I don't wanna not be here and get a bench warrant. And It was was like shut the actual F up. Right?
HughYeah. Everybody knows that isn't going to happen. It's not possibility's, not why I possibility, why I, yeah. You know, in and of itself, that's, that's innocuous. It's banter, it's all this, but all together, if I'm sitting there [00:09:00] from the outside mm-hmm. If in front of this judge against any attorney that's just got this banter and this light, like, um, this, this very, uh, sorority informal, uh, the tone within, within the motion hour. It's very hard to think that you're gonna come in and there's going to be s know, a serious proceeding where someone's gonna be objective about it and all. Yes. You just get this feeling that, that this is just a, you're walking into somebody else's club.
ChristineExactly. Um, country club literally like it. And the other thing, half the people in room are attorneys that were very, very, very, very active when publicly, now, I don't know behind the scenes, publicly they were very outspoken when we in Louisville. And we did have very, and this is my personal opinion, we had, we had, and we still have problems within LMPD. there's good people in LNPD, but they were very vocal and I want them to think about how they would feel if there was a [00:10:00] recording of law enforcement enforcement talking about serious issues and just Kiki and he, he, well,
HughI I mean, think about if they were in, if they, when they were in court on probable cause hearings and stuff like that. Yeah. If they had that banter
ChristineExactly. The
Hughjudge, would you think that there was. Any chance as a defendant that you had a prayer in hell? Um, I, you know, and, and I'm seeing it differently, uh, I feel a little hypocritical saying all of this because when I was in practice and I was sitting there with just tons of cases and I knew I was gonna be fighting with people 10 times that day, and you're sort of, you know, you're halfway through and it's just miserable. You appreciate more of the lighthearted stuff. You do, but I couldn't see it from the outside. Like I'm now seeing it from the outside and you know, looking at it from the point of view of how does this look as a legal tribunal, a place to resolve disputes. Yep. It. It's not a good [00:11:00] a good
Christineall, for the record, I have given him, I don't know, I've never, okay. This is, I've never seen the Matrix, but I hear there's this thing called the blue pill and the Red Pill, and you never seen The The Matrix? No. But if you take one, it's like, now you know the truth. don't know know which one that is. But anyway, he finally took that one. I took it about two years ago. Do you, I don't know which one it is, but is it blue or red or is there a purple? I think it's blue and red. I haven't but y'all know what I'm
Hughtalking about. I don't remember. Yeah, it's, uh, but it's been a long time. I don't remember which one. But yeah, no, I, I mean, I'm just looking at it from a different perspective and I, I can still rationalize things from the point of view of a, of a, an advocate. Yeah. Yeah. Just, you know, much like, um, you know, know, the advocates in some of these cases where we think it should go one way. You know, if, if, like for instance in this case, um, one, one party filed a very good motion to have the judge recuse the other side opposed it. Mm-hmm. We're not saying the other side is necessarily wrong. They're advocating for their client. [00:12:00] Yep. They're making the argument that they can because That's what they're supposed to do. If they didn't do that, they wouldn't be doing their job. do that, they wouldn't be doing their job.
ChristineExactly. And I do think there were two people in that courtroom that I did respect day, in that moment. And I do wanna say both their names. I hope that's okay with you. 'cause we try to, I don't care. Stay out of that. But Abigail Green filed an extraordinary motion to recuse followed up by an extraordinary affidavit that is now pending before the Kentucky Supreme Court and Holly Houston was opposing counsel on that. And she was zealous advocate for her client as required by our ethical obligation. obligation. Um, I think that any attorney, not in the case that was okay with the judge staying on, I would have very, very serious concerns about hiring personally. Would you, do you agree?
HughCase. Yeah. I think it now gets more complex by what judge said, led to her denying the, the motion to alter mind or vacate. But before I get to that point, um, [00:13:00] yeah. Yeah. Holly, uh, the, the, the attorney opposing the motion argued exactly what you had to argue mm-hmm. That this is, this would be. If you allow this judge, people are gonna be looking at every little thing a does and will be form shopping
Christineshe made a legal argument on behalf of her client. Yeah, I will say the argument, it got really weird. Okay, so this is a case where if you're just now listening, you've got a custody battle two moms and a guardian ad litem that's been appointed, so the GAL has basically got decision making rights when it comes to conflicts between these kids in certain circumstances. Right.
HughAnd facilitating com communications, which is weird.
ChristineBeyond weird. I
Hughit's agreed to. It's not something the judge came up with,
Christineright?
HughThe parties came up with, it and the GAL agreed which puts the GAL in one of the most miserable situations one can be in. In any case, the. any case, the person that has to be between two people who aren't allowed to communicate with each other directly. and are in charge of conveying [00:14:00] the tone and all of the back and forth and whether things have been set out of order. It just, I would, I can't imagine why anyone would ever agree to be in that position, honestly. Well, it would be
Christinemiserable for Berro because he a very successful firm and we're making money, being a lawyer for client. But this is a pattern we've noticed with some of these Gs and FOCs, and so. This individual that is appointed by the judge who is that appointment immunity billing, hundreds of dollars an hour. Okay. Um, and so I imagine that it's, if, if it's as contentious as this case appears to be, we're talking by time this is over, potentially tens of thousands of dollars.
HughYeah, no, that's true. But I mean, the choices are. We get things moved through the court system. The court chooses who gets to be the person that makes decisions and and does all of these things. Like the custody statutes, you know, would, would look at if the parties can't communicate and they can't cooperate, or if everybody wants to to to cooperate, [00:15:00] but they want to have this whole weird court apparatus like in the middle of it, facilitating Yeah, that's gonna cost money. It isn't going to be free. Parties get to The parties have to get a choice. in it, but If they want to just have a trial and see whoever wins let's do it.
ChristineI think they did, but it's not their choice. This is what's so frustrating about family court, is that there's this assumption that if can't get along, it's because of both parties, and that's not true when it comes to abusive situations. No, I,
HughI agree, but
Christinebut the GAL has no business being an intermediary That's the attorney for the child. position, in my opinion.
Unknownno. I, agree It's
Hughnot the proper role for
UnknownA GAL. but if the parties want to have
Hughsomeone in the middle and they want to keep this process going,
Christinethey can do it.
Hughyeah. Odd.
ChristineWell, this is weird. There's a weird part of this case though, and this gets to the recusal because there actually was an FOC that was on the case during trial and the court a respond, okay, which means of her own accord. removed the FOC and then [00:16:00] appointed this GAL, and then attended her partisan campaign event. the gal's partisan campaign event.
HughYou mean the motion for recusal, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
ChristineThe grounds for the recusal. Yeah, the motions, the grounds for the, uh, requested recusal, um, and then took the mic at that partisan event. So you can see, I think fact that the Judge Ponte removed one party, added this party and then went to her event, does. Up the ante.
HughYeah, no, I agree. I, I've never considered that aspect of it, but the judge on her own accord Remove someone else from the case and put this person who was running for office and, uh, you know, who the judge, you know, allegedly at a fundraising event for.
UnknownYeah, that's a, that's a really
Hughgood point.
ChristineAnd people that are going through a divorce, like said, you're going through the worst time of your life. There's already this heightened sense paranoia when everybody's getting in, you know, involved in your business. Um, [00:17:00] but this. GAL. This was more upsetting to me than what the judge said. So the GAL then takes this stance, which again, we said on previous podcasts, she should have just been like, I'm I'm out. I've gotta run for office. I'm out. I am very concerned about what she will do in office as far as empowering or building up the family court system. and The fact that she stays in this case. and for reference, she works for the firm. that was like good old boy earlier in the day. But she's like, well, we have two bodies that disagree because we've got the ethics committee for the judges that say this is fine ' cause that's what the judge says, and we'll get to that. And then the attorney called the ethics hotline and said, the attorney need to file because this is an appearance conflict, right?
HughYeah, yeah, that's right.
ChristineSo why did the GAL take that stance? Like, was she just being a politician? Just like, I'm not gonna say anything.
HughWell, she didn't weigh in either way, which I think from a GAL point of view was the smart thing to do. If you're gonna stay on the case, [00:18:00] don't weigh in. And, and I think, I mean, I I think it had not been said at that point, at the, at the motion hour yesterday. Um, I know it it was in the original motion. I know it was argued at motion hour that. Ms. Green, the attorney that is asking for recusal called the Ethics Hotline and was told that, yes, this, this appears to be something that would require recusal. And then, then she filed, it was not brought up yesterday, so to me, the GAL raising that, because the judge had just raised the fact that she had gotten an opinion on something. Was just, I mean, I, you know, to me, I, I interpret it a different way. I thought, oh yeah, that's a really good point. No one raised, no one brought that up. That we do have two totally different bodies that are advising two different ways. Now, I'm interested to know if what the questions were. Amen. In each of those. Amen. Because, Because if the judge asked, did I do anything wrong by attending the event? And they said, that she didn't. That still doesn't go to the heart of the recusal. question.
Christine[00:19:00] Exactly.
Hughremember everyone we're not saying that Judge Ry can't be unbiased or
Christineobjective.
HughCase. Right. That's not the standard. It's just that there's an appearance of it. Mm-hmm. Um, I mean, I have no doubt that she's able to handle a lot of per, you know, she has strong personal opinions that she has to put aside every single day on the bench. Yeah. Um, um. And she should. She's a human. You know what we're entitled to? Of course, people that don't have strong opinions on things I worry about sometimes, but the standard here isn't whether she did anything wrong. And I think that that's one of how this sort of got off the rails is she took it as an accusation that did something wrong. The standard is, does this the appearance that you can't be objective? And I don't how anybody can say that. It doesn't exactly. So did she ask, um. What kind The judicial ethics people, does this create an appearance? And they said no, or did she just ask, did I do anything ethically wrong? And if they said, no, that doesn't matter.
ChristineWell, yesterday in motion hour, I'm like panicking. I'm sitting here with like [00:20:00] my Donald Trump thumbs, just like sitting here saying all this stuff. You know what I mean? Like, oh my gosh. On my Insta story, because I literally did not know y'all that there was a judicial ethics hotline. I did not know that. I knew there was a judicial conduct commission. Um, and so I was like, wait a second. Did she call the JCC? 'cause that's a real problem if she called the JCC. That's different. That's the board where you file the complaints with. Um, but so I did find there is a judicial ethics hotline. called them. and said, hi, my name is Christine and I've never had a complaint. I throw that in there. Hey, because I do think after 15 years that speaks volumes. But I digress. But, and so this person that I spoke to said essentially, I can neither confirm nor deny whether an opinion was sought like this everything is confidential. Um, but what I can tell you is that if a judge. Hypothetically ask for an opinion. That opinion, the judge can do whatever they want with that me Ry, give me that opinion. Yeah. Yeah. And give it to me now.
HughWell, I, yeah, I, I'd be interested to and it, [00:21:00] and mainly, again, I'm wondering what the question was. It was answered because it may not have been pertinent to the motion for recusal. Yeah. It's, you know, again, Abigail Green, you know. when this began, It was just a motion stating that there was an appearance and that you have to
Christinerecuse because of it
Hughwhen this motion was first made, it was just simply, this creates an appearance and you have to recuse because 'cause of that, that's
Unknownstandard
Hughthen it, then it became something more when it shouldn't have.
ChristineYeah, and I think that, I agree, That motion was really good and it was the reaction in court that upset me and every woman who's ever worked for a degree, you as a female, if somebody says something to you in a professional setting, do not ever respond with, I'm not mad. Okay. Okay. That's embarrassing. For us. Um, but the judge did initially said, I'm not mad at you for filing the motion. And then Judge Ry went on yesterday say, you know, I got a lot of heat for saying I'm not mad. So I'm gonna [00:22:00] reiterate again that I'm, that I'm, I'm not mad. And it's like, what, what the, an attorney, a licensed professional filing a. Extraordinarily well written, backed by law. Motion should never make anyone mad. Do you know what I'm Yeah. Like, can you you imagine if a judge was like you? I'm mad that file a woman, judge being like, if you filed a bond reduction motion in a SA case, and the judge being like, I'm not mad that you filed this. our fucking job. It just, I, I go on a tangent. It's so upsetting. Well, it's
Hughso much worse in this situation because it's one thing to say I'm not mad. I know. You know, I. Uh, regardless of of whether you're male or female, it's hard for an attorney to file in front of a judge that they practice in front of a lot of times and ask to recuse It's something that takes some bravery. You have to sort of hold your breath and hope the reaction isn't all that bad, but the way you say, I'm not mad without having to actually say it is rule on the motion objectively and [00:23:00] don't have a tantrum. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. and, and lash out. Very personally on paper. Yeah. you wouldn't have to say it if you didn't react on paper in
Unknowna, I know you are, but what am I sort of way
Hughof
Christinehysterical woman. Seriously, I care. No, I don't care. I'm a woman. I can say it, it, it's like it's like I'm allowed. But I mean, honestly, watching it, I still can't believe it. and I did a video. and I was in Florida. when it happened. And I remember immediately being like this judge, on scale of, you know, zero to is not retaliatory. retaliatory. And I, I meant it at the time. Yeah, I agree. But clearly I was wrong. Like I was bad. Wrong.
HughYeah. I don't take it as retaliatory. I, I took it as she took the motion personally. And no matter how many times she says, I'm not mad, you still took it personally now. Whether she's retaliatory. I, I would imagine. And, and, and, and I, I actually believe that if [00:24:00] nothing else happened and the case went forward, and it was litigated that I, I, know, I've known this judge long enough that I don't believe that she would retaliate in her ruling. In that case, she might overcompensate, in fact, to make it look like she wasn't, except for I, I worry because of the nature of the respon, you know, her initial ruling on the motion. I I don't know. I, I might've filed, yeah, I might would've filed an additional motion instead of a motion to alter, amend, or vacate. I would've done that too, but I might've filed an additional motion to recuse just based on the order on recusal, literally.
ChristineAnd so Green has filed under 26 a, I miss. Spoke in previous podcasts. I said chapter 31. Um, but it is 26 a, so filed an affidavit and moving to disqualify Shelly from the case at the Kentucky Supreme Court pursuant to our rules. Um, and as soon as we know, we will let y'all know. And then we just have to remember too, at the heart of all of this is [00:25:00] literally a family that's obviously going through something. It appears from limited knowledge that both parties have zealous advocates On the case, And it's just unfortunate that persons have exacerbated the situation. yeah,
HughI, I agree with that. I think, um, I think it can get sorted out, but I think it's been a distraction. I think it was unnecessary, and I think that it's. It's representative of a lot of what we see all the time. I think it was a, it was something that it was definitely worth highlighting and pointing out because it is not uncommon mm-hmm. For these situations to happen. Although we were surprised where it happened.
Christinea little surprised where it happened. Yeah, that's true. But um, and it was very clear from what she said yesterday. We were in the audience, but that this judge at least is watching us. So for all the judges listening, get to work on time. Next week we will talk about the mom that was remanded to custody by Judge Lauren Ogden.[00:26:00]
HughThat happened. See ya.
ChristineThat was good. I'm actually glad you, we've gotta remember this. I need to get a little, a little.