Episode 19
A Rant

About this episode
Episode Notes: The JudgeMental Podcast – EP19: A Rant In this special solo episode, Hugh takes the mic while Christine is away in Los Angeles, shining a light on the urgent issue of court transparency and public access to justice. Drawing from Christine’s experiences in California family courts and his own legal practice in Kentucky, Hugh explores the stark differences in how courts operate across the country. Key topics include: The fundamental importance of open courts and public access to judicial proceedings How transparency (or the lack thereof) impacts justice, accountability, and democracy The troubling trend of increasing secrecy in family courts, and its consequences for vulnerable people Historical and constitutional perspectives on open justice, from Anglo-Saxon England to the U.S. Supreme Court Real-world stories of how closed courts can enable abuses of power and deny justice The role of public oversight, media, and citizen activism in holding the legal system accountable Hugh also discusses the mission of the Judge-y app and this podcast: to inform, empower, and support people navigating the court system—especially when the system seems stacked against them. Whether you’re a legal professional, someone with experience in the courts, or simply a concerned citizen, this episode offers a passionate, insightful look at why justice must not only be done, but be seen to be done. Tune in for a thought-provoking rant, and get ready for Christine’s return next week with more stories from the front lines of family court reform. Would you like to add a guest bio, resource links, or a call to action to these notes?
Transcript
4,290 words · about 19 minutes to read. Automatically transcribed and lightly edited; speaker labels are approximate.
Speaker[00:00:00] And I would, I would urge those within our court system here in Kentucky who may be listening to this podcast to not react to criticism coming from this podcast, and other media outlets by trying to shut down public access to the courts, it is going to have the opposite effect and it does not serve the citizens.
HughAlright. Hey everyone. Welcome to a special edition of the Judgmental Podcast. I am flying solo today while Christine is in Los Angeles fighting the good fight of family court protests and making the rounds on quite a few other podcasts and other media outlets. So, rather than simply not having an episode post for Thursday. I wanted to take some time to talk about something that's been on my mind after hearing about Christine's experience out in California and how their courts are handled, especially [00:01:00] the family court out in California. So, I'm of course talking about access to courts, open courts. The right of the public to view what's going on in court, to be in courtrooms, to have access to recordings of court or possibly case files and follow what's really going on in court. So I know what you're thinking. Great. Another frigging law, you're talking about legal theory or legal terms, but stick with me here because this isn't just about legal precedent. This is something much more fundamental. And not to sound cheesy or extreme, because we hear this a lot in the media nowadays. But. This is really about whether we live in a democracy and whether the government is accountable to the people. And we have to decide whether we're okay with justice happening behind closed doors where no one can see what's really going on. And there's [00:02:00] a lot of pressure on the courts from a lot of sides. I know that we join a lot of people with different political views people from both sides of the aisle that are looking for different types of accountability. Different kinds of access to government, and I fear that because there is a movement toward government accountability and especially court accountability, both from people on the right and people from the left, I fear that the reaction is going to be to close the courts down more and to keep people out further. What I've learned is that we are very fortunate here where I practiced in Kentucky and where I still have a limited practice. We have videos in the courtroom. We have cameras in the courtroom. We have the ability for media to be there unless there is something, some, you know, proprietary secret or some something that is really [00:03:00] privacy concern that would warrant sealing a case file. And this has become, I mean, it was, it was a very important part of my practice as an attorney and my ability to remedy errors made by the courts and hearing about how closed off things are in California and some of these other states has sort of sent me on a deep dive into looking at the different rules and different jurisdictions. Made me think about not only the effects of how I practiced as a family law practitioner, but also my client's rights and their ability to address injustices that occur in court. So to the cheesy side a little bit Jeremy Bentham, the legal philosopher once said, publicity is the very soul of justice. And I thought that court was, that quote was worth mentioning. Because it seems like that side of justice is sort of [00:04:00] at risk here and maybe being eroded a little bit. So lemme start with what we have here in Kentucky. 'cause I think it'll help illustrate just how stark the contract is. When you walk into a Kentucky family Court, you're walking into a system that, while certainly not perfect, at least operates with a presumption that justice should be transparent. And what I mean is every proceeding is recorded on video. The public can attend most hearings with only specific con confidential cases excepted from that, the press can also observe and report on what happens now. There has been some talk behind closed doors, I understand about further limiting people's access to watch what happens in family court because of the scrutiny that the, the Jefferson County, especially Jefferson County, Kentucky Family Court has been under. So I, you know, I, I'm concerned that. This transparency may erode quite a [00:05:00] bit. We also have covered several cases, but are going to cover several more cases where the judges are sealing their cases. We have a judge who was recently divorced and her own case was sealed. Interesting to know whether or not it met any of the legal requirements for sealing the case and keeping out of public view. So, like I said, it's not perfect here, but contrasting that with what Christine is witnessing in California family court proceedings that aren't recorded. That many of the proceedings don't even have a transcript produced that you can request and read. No recording is allowed by the public at all. People can go to jail just by taking a picture inside a courtroom. And when judges violate people's constitutional rights or or don't afford them due process and affect parenting time and custody, it makes it much harder to address these errors with the appellate courts [00:06:00] or, you know, with. As some people are doing in federal court or in the, in the sphere of public opinion when errors are made, especially ones that are, that rise to the level of getting something overturned by a higher court. We're oftentimes talking about rulings on evidentiary presentations and objections. So a judge gets to determine what evidence comes in and gets considered. And this is very important, both when you have a jury and when the judge himself or herself is the only person determining what facts are true and making legal conclusions. And so the judge is the gatekeeper for evidence. And I would say it's more often that errors occur where things come in that should not come in than than evidence being left out and not [00:07:00] allowed into the record. I would be interested to hear other people's experience with that, especially attorneys to see if my assumption is correct, but that certainly in my practice, that was the case. So when you don't have a transcript and you don't have a recording of what's going on, there's not any record that these errors ever occurred. It's someone's word against the judges. You can imagine who usually wins in that battle. Now, in other proceedings we've heard about in this country, there are what's called minutes produced by the prevailing party. After a hearing. Now that means the only recording of the proceeding, the hearing, or, or whatever goes on in the courtroom is actually produced by the party who wins, and they get to draft the facts and the conclusions of law for the judge. And that becomes the record. I, I don't think I need to really go into how many different problems there are with that while letting one [00:08:00] party to litigation draft findings of facts that involve the other party. So this isn't just a California problem, by the way. It's happening across the country, particularly in family courts where vulnerable people, children, domestic violence victims, parents fighting for their kids are most at risk when the system fails. So why does this matter? So let me take you back about 250 years to understand how we got here. The principle of open courts isn't some modern invention that goes back over 700 years to Anglo-Saxon, Saxon England. Even back then, legal proceedings were conducted in public with community members not just allowed, but required to participate and attend. This wasn't an accident. It was recognition that justice must not only be done, but must also be seen to be done. So when our founders were crafting the Constitution, they understood this principle. Intimately, they'd seen what happened when government [00:09:00] operated in secret. John Adams himself defended British soldiers after the Boston Boston massacre in a very public trial. Knowing full well that transparency was essential to legitimacy, but here's the thing, the Constitution doesn't explicitly say courts must be open to the public. The founders apparently thought it was so obvious, so fundamental to the concept of justice, that they didn't feel the need to spell it out. They were wrong about that assumption. As we're seeing today. It took until about 1980 for the Supreme Court of the United States to explicitly recognize what should have been obvious all along in Richmond newspapers versus Virginia. The court held that the First Amendment guarantees the public and press the right to attend criminal trials. The case arose when a Virginia judge simply closed a murder trial because the defense attorney had asked him to no findings, no consideration of alternatives. Just sure, let's kick everyone outta my courtroom. The Supreme Court [00:10:00] said absolutely not. Chief Justice Berger wrote that criminal trials have been presumptively open throughout Anglo American legal history. And this openness serves vital functions, ensuring fairness, deterring misconduct providing that what we call community catharsis and maintaining public confidence and justice. And those two things are. I think we see them most when we deal with very public criminal trials nowadays. I, I think of high highly publicized trials. Most recently the police that have been accused and convicted of excessive force against minorities. I think of the OJ Simpson trial where there are things going on in society that are. Underlying the public's feelings about justice in the country, and that there is a real importance to watching these trials and seeing [00:11:00] how justice is played out in, in understanding that while the justice system oftentimes misses the mark, and oftentimes justice isn't done that. There is a process and that there is a legitimate mechanism for getting justice in the United States. So without that transparency, justice Berger said that natural human reactions of outrage and protests are frustrated and may manifest themselves in some form of vengeful self-help. In other words, we get vigilante justice. You know, I, I can't help in light of the news that's, you know, I've seen today people being assassinated and people being burned. I worry that our system of justice is starting to fail in this country and that people are taking justice into their own hands. And that's something that we've been largely able to avoid in the United States. Something that's plagued many other [00:12:00] countries and that, you know, that frankly terrifies me. Now, here's where it gets interesting and frustrating. The Supreme Court has never explicitly said there's a First Amendment right to attend civil proceedings. Likewise, they've never said there is a First Amendment right of the press or to the public to. View cases or view anything in civil court, they've only ruled at a federal level on criminal cases. And that's left a huge gap that state courts and family courts have been exploiting for decades. But think about the logic here. If transparency is essential in criminal cases to ensure fairness and accountability, why would it be any less important for family court? The way that the courts function, family court, criminal court, they are very different. The preliminary hearings, jury trials, certainly the right to a speedy trial. Those are things that just don't happen in a lot of family courts. I know some still use juries and some have initial temporary hearings, but the proceedings are [00:13:00] very different. But what is common is that constitutional rights are at stake. So. The right to your freedom in criminal cases, whether or not you can be put to death or placed behind bars and your freedom taken away in family court, you have the rights to your property and more importantly, the fundamental protected constitutional right to parent your kids. So the stakes are enormous in both spheres. And I think the interest that the public has in making sure the courts are protecting these rights and. Making sure that proper procedures and laws are followed, certainly are equal between family court and criminal court. In both spheres. The stakes are enormous and the potential for abuse of power is huge. Yet, in state, after state, family courts operate like secret tribunals, [00:14:00] and that sounds a bit extreme. Except the judges are making life altering decisions and they are closing everyone out from those decisions. No one can go and review and see how a judge is ruling on certain types of cases, whether they're following the law, when those decisions that the judge makes are wrong, and when constitutional rights are violated, children are put in danger. Justice is denied. There's often no way to prove that it even happened. So lemme tell you why this matters beyond just the individual cases. Public oversight serves as what Jeremy Bentham called the ultimate check on government power. He wrote that without publicity, all other checks are insufficient. Think about what he meant by that. We have appeal processes, ethics rules, oversight bodies, but none of those work if there's no record of what actually happened in the first place. When I was practicing in family court in Kentucky. [00:15:00] We would have hearings. You expected that there would be some errors. There is no, there is no court, no judge in the country who is perfect and isn't going to make some bad evidentiary rulings. Especially when a, when we're dealing with a larger trial, they're human. We're human. We make mistakes in trial. They make mistakes, but. If that mistake is fundamental to the ultimate outcome and there is a right, at least as an attorney, if there's a right for my client to appeal, I need to know what happened and I like to know, I like to review what happened when it was fresh, so. I would always order the video of the proceedings. We would have it transcribed because there were certain motions that we had to file to protect our client's rights, and those motions often had to be filed immediately. We had to file them within 10 days, and then the judge got to try to correct some of the errors before we had to file for an appeal. The openness [00:16:00] of the courts deters misconduct, I appealed cases, and some of those cases resulted in reversals from the appellate courts with admonitions to the courts, to the trial judges to stop violating people's due process rights. That was an essential part of keeping the, the judicial process in check and making sure that it's following the law. So just as in criminal cases, you get corrupt prosecutors, bias judges, lawyers who don't adequately represent their clients. All those problems are much more likely to surface when proceedings are public. Sunshine really is the best disinfectant as they say. I think public court proceedings also. Form to educate the public. I mean, most people won't ever go to law school, but at some point, a [00:17:00] significant portion of people end up. In court in one way or another, and they need to see how the system actually works, what to expect, how to navigate it. And that's one of the things that we are really excited to try to help doing with, with Judgey and, and with this podcast to help people that are going through the court system may not have an attorney or may have an attorney that is not, properly informing them of what's going on, which is something that we've been hearing a lot about and help people navigate the court system. When the system's closed, it remains a mysterious black box that only insiders can understand, which, you know, it's, is part of the reason attorneys have the reputation that we do, and I, I get that. Finally open courts provide legitimacy. People are more likely to accept and respect court decisions. And the rule of law when they can see that process is fair, even if they don't like the outcome. And [00:18:00] one of the things that I really took away from my 20 years of law practice were when court proceedings went well, where a trial was clearly fair, even handed everyone had a chance to present their evidence. My clients often if, if things didn't go exactly how they wanted, when those proceedings went well and were so clearly fair, they respected a decision, they were much more likely to follow that decision and move forward from that without continuing to fight what the judge was ordering for them to do. Now, I'm not arguing that every single court proceeding should always be open to everyone. Clearly not. There are legitimate reasons for limited closure. I mean, we have to protect child victims. We preserve national security systems sorry, national security secrets. We've gotta protect trade secrets. But here's the key. Those [00:19:00] should be the exceptions. Those require specific justification and they shouldn't be the default. And what we're seeing instead, particularly in family courts, is a system where secrecy has become the norm. Judges routinely close proceedings, not because there's a specific need for confidentiality related to that case, but because it's easier and because it avoids scrutiny, because it allows them to operate without any accountability. The Supreme Court cases I mentioned earlier established that before court can be closed, there must be an overriding interest articulated in findings. In other words, the judge has to specifically explain why the closure is necessary and find that no alternatives would work. You can't just say family court proceedings are confidential and call it a day, but that's exactly what's happening. And part of that is our Supreme Court First Amendment cases apply currently only to criminal cases. So we have. Inconsistent [00:20:00] applications of the rules, inconsistent interpretations of the Supreme Court rulings as it pertains to civil cases and particularly to family court. In my humble opinion, this creates a, a particularly perverse situation because family courts where some of the most vulnerable people in our society end up parents trying to protect their children from abuse, domestic violence, victims seeking protection, people with mental health issues or substance abuse issues who need help, not punishment. These are people who most need the protection that transparency provides, yet they're the ones most likely to find themselves in the proceedings. That happens entirely in the dark.
SpeakerAccess to the courts. Also, it provides a greater democratic benefit in that many of the judges in this country are elected. We don't appoint judges in many of the courts. If we are going to. Determine as voters whether or [00:21:00] not to reelect a judge, how are we supposed to know what type of job they're doing? If the public is completely shut out from their courtroom, we just supposed to look at whatever they post on social media, the people they have lunches with, or the funny videos that they're creating while inside their own courts. How do we reevaluate whether they deserve to be retained or replaced? This is a broader problem that we all need to be concerned about. And the irony is oftentimes the intended purpose of sealing the courts, the, the purpose of protecting privacy. It, it does the opposite. When family court proceedings happen in secret and people feel they're treated unfairly, what do they do? They go to social media. They start blogs, they create websites. They organize protests. The one, like the ones that are going on right now in California. The very secrecy that was supposed to be protected ends up [00:22:00] generating more publicity and not less, and that's something that can, should concern everyone. Once we accept that courts can operate in secret, like in family law, where does that stop if transparency isn't required? When you are determining whether or not to take someone's child, why would it be required for contract disputes or any other civil matters? We're seeing an erosion happen every time a court system is made private and kept away from the public, and more and more civil proceedings are being closed. More court records are being sealed. The presumption is shifting from openness and accountability to secrecy, and that should terrify anyone who believes in democratic accountability. Now, courts and judges often justify the secrecy by claiming they're protecting. People's privacy, and I get it. I have often thought about how my clients must have felt sitting there having every aspect of [00:23:00] their life picked apart. No one wants their business splashed across the front page of a newspaper. But it's also gotta be terribly uncomfortable already having a judge and attorneys dig through the intimate details of your parenting and your personal finances. But here's the thing. There's a big difference between proceedings being open to the public and proceedings being publicized by the media. Most court proceedings are boring. Talk to any attorney and ask how many exciting trials they've had in the last year. Most don't involve celebrities or sensational facts or anything that would interest reporters or anyone else other than the parties that are in the litigation. The vast majority of public court proceedings never generate media attention at all because it would not get. Anyone's interest if they publicized it. But what public access provides is oversight, not publicity. It means that if something goes wrong, there's a way to document it and address it. It means that judges know that someone is watching and it incentivizes better [00:24:00] behavior. It means that the systemic problems that we talk about here on this podcast can be identified and fixed, and there are plenty of other practical solutions for protecting privacy. The sealing everything off to where. Proceedings happen in secrecy. That is, that is a drastic restriction when there are many things from changes to venue to restrictions on just recording or gag or orders. To the media to protect jury from finding out information. There are lots of tools available. You can have live streaming. It could be allowed, but with delays so that things can't get back to those involved in the proceedings or that witnesses can't use the media coverage to prepare and to know what someone else said before they testified. There are lots of safeguards that can be put in place. These are all compromises that many courts have already successfully implemented across the country. We cannot accept the idea that the entire [00:25:00] categories of court proceedings, like family court should be presumptively secret. And that's not how democracy works. That's not how constitutional rights work, and that's certainly not how justice works. So let me bring us back to where we started with Jeremy Bentham's observation that publicity is the very soul of justice and what he understood and what our founders understood and what the Supreme Court has now recognized is that democracy depends on informed citizens. We cannot govern ourselves if we don't know what our government is doing. We can't hold officials accountable if we can't see how they're performing their duties and courts aren't separate from this principle. And I would, I would urge those within our court system here in Kentucky who may be listening to this podcast to not react to criticism coming from this pod, podcast, and other media outlets by trying to shut down public access to the courts, it is going to have the opposite effect and it does not serve the [00:26:00] citizens. The good news is courts can change their practices. State legislatures can pass laws requiring transparency. Citizens can de demand accountability. But it requires recognizing that this is a problem, which is why we're talking about what we're talking about. And we have started this podcast and the, the various different media properties that we're building. In order to do just that, inform people and help people deal with and navigate the court system. So Christine's doing that right now in California. She's shining a light on the system that's operated in the shadows for a long time. She's documenting cases where secrecy is enabled. Enabled abuses of power, denials of justice. She's building a movement of people who refuse to accept that justice can be done behind closed doors. So we're, we're fortunate here in Kentucky. I've learned that. I mean, I've known that, but I really didn't realize how open our court system was here until this week, hearing the stories of what's going on in California and in Arizona and some [00:27:00] other places. Thanks for listening to the special edition. I'm sorry to just fill it with. Stuff of a rather serious nature, but I, I think it's important for people to understand why we have this podcast and why it's important for people to know what's really going on in the nation's courts. We'll be back next week with our regular format. Christine will be back, I believe she's flying back tomorrow and I suspect she'll have plenty of stories to tell us about people that are fighting within the court system there. I'll leave you with the final thought. Justice that happens in the dark isn't really justice at all, so have a good night. Peace.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah. We need some. Justice. Justin found justice.