Episode 18
Field Trip

About this episode
The Judgmental Podcast – Episode 18: Field Trip (On Location in California) In this special on-location episode, hosts Hugh and Christine take The Judgmental Podcast to Orange County, California, for a deep dive into the state’s family court system. Broadcasting amidst a nationwide protest and documentary filming, they share firsthand accounts and interviews with parents, attorneys, and advocates fighting for judicial accountability and transparency. Key Topics: Shocking stories from California’s family courts, including prolonged ex parte orders, lack of hearings, and the impact on families. The role and power of custodial evaluators, “730 evaluations,” and the challenges of navigating the system. Comparisons between California and Kentucky court practices, highlighting systemic issues across jurisdictions. The ongoing nationwide protest for family court reform, with live updates from Orange County and beyond. Listener engagement: California is the podcast’s second-largest audience, and the hosts share messages from local listeners and supporters. Behind-the-scenes moments from the documentary shoot, including adventures in an RV and the energy of protest days. A call to action for greater transparency, accountability, and reform in family courts everywhere. Notable Moments: Personal stories from parents affected by the system. Reflections on the emotional toll of legal advocacy. A look at the broader movement for change, with listeners from across the country reaching out. Teasers for upcoming episodes and exclusive YouTube Q&A content. Connect with Us: Visit judge-y.com for more episodes and resources. Subscribe to our YouTube channel for exclusive content. Join the conversation and share your story—change starts with awareness! Thank you for listening to this special episode of The Judgmental Podcast, recorded on the ground in California. Stay tuned for more field reports and in-depth discussions on the fight for justice in family courts nationwide.
Transcript
3,504 words · about 15 minutes to read. Automatically transcribed and lightly edited; speaker labels are approximate.
[00:00:00] But
you ready? Yeah, I've I've got it
it recording.
I'm just Okay. Sounds
Sounds good.
All right. Welcome to the Judgmental Podcast, y'all. I am in County, sufficiently traumatized.
thought that Kentucky Family Court was bad.
But I've never seen anything like this. You,
It
sounds like it. So tell me, tell me a couple stories if you can. Well, I mean, and
let me be clear, I haven't seen
it because for the most part, I don't
people are allowed
in there and there's no cameras allowed in courtrooms at all. Like there are no video
of family court in California anywhere at all. But
But you've, you've told me stories of people that have been kept from seeing their child unsupervised for better part of a year and have never gotten to even have a hearing or, or speak in front of the court. No, I mean we had a mom that[00:01:00]
literally
lost her child.
While she was
breastfeeding. I've got a mom that
seen her kid
in nine
Without ever testifying in court based on an ex parte order that
just keeps going and going and going. No criminal charges.
And I, this is like so sad.
This is what I told you. I was like trying to trial prep with her. Just be like, okay,
can you
you state your name for the record?
old are you?
Name your child, you know, who's his or her teacher? And
person was
like, I've never had a lawyer do
and spent more than six figures
on a lawyer. That's, that's crazy. And this is, this is the person you were telling him about have who had multiple lawyers, correct? Yes. And no lawyer has prepped them for court in any way, shape or form.
No, I mean, you could tell looking at
at her face like, 'cause you know, as lawyers we're supposed to kind of prep our clients how to control the narrative. You know, when you get into, when you get in front of a judge, you may have 30 minutes to tell your side of
story. You don't
wanna go down a rabbit hole of something that [00:02:00] happened six years
That's
not really relevant to like, best interest of the child now in the present day. But I can't imagine
figures
and not a single attorney has prepped her, nor this case has been going on six or seven years. Nor has she ever testified.
Yeah,
I, I don't know how that's, how that's possible. How can you have made a decision about a child's best interest and not spoken with the parent?
That's
right. I, I understand that, you know, our understanding of best interest comes from Kentucky statutes, but I, I think they're fairly uniform and the wishes of the parent and. Quite a few factors regarding the parent are relevant to defining the child's best interest. So it's, it's pretty amazing that you don't hear from a parent at all, and yet you're making these decisions.
It's so similar,
like
we talked to Matt Grant on
our last podcast, same Patterns are Happening. It's like they just keep moving the carrot. It's like, okay, well you'll
agree to supervise
visits here and if
do[00:03:00]
this for three months, then
over
and then you go back and there's something else
you have to do.
But we've gotta have a serious
in this country. We
can't
be taking away children, traumatizing children based on ex
parte motions allegations
a bunch
of lawyers
custodial evaluators getting. Filthy rich.
Yeah, it's, that is, yeah, it's pretty pretty shocking. Yeah, it is definitely a common theme. I remember Matt talking about how ex parte order, and then it gets, you know, it's time limited, but yet it doesn't seem to go away, and then it just, mm-hmm. You come back and then a couple months you come back and it just keeps, you know, they keep moving and they won't tell you what you need to do to get that ex parte order or the, the temporary restraining order lifted and. Years go by and then we see it happened. Unfortunately all too often in Kentucky as well.
I know. Luckily, I mean, if we have one positive
thing to say about where we predominantly practiced is,
you
know, there aren't a whole hell of a lot of ex parte orders, and if there are, hell,
not,[00:04:00]
not nine months. You know what I mean? No, but there are plenty of temporary orders, I mean. You go to motion hour a judge without any hearing based on the unsworn testimony or statement by a friend of court or a guardian. Ad litem will take someone's parenting time or drastically modify it and, you know, two years can go by and then all of a sudden you still haven't gotten a final order. You're still living under temporary orders and you don't have a right to a full hearing.
Oh, that's happening all over California. You're Yeah.
You, you absolutely do have a right. You just, they're, they're ignoring it. Yeah. And it, it's just, it is like wild, wild west. It's also very different for me to see this happen where I don't know the players. Sure. Yeah. You know, we're like, we know the judges, we know the people that this is happening to. But like when I've never had a conversation with these commissioners, these judges, these minors, counsels, you know, I like our own bias
it's like,
okay, well I know [00:05:00] so and so works harder. I've had a conversation, but here saying it, it's like too far removed for me. It's just the system is a mess. I mean, it's a mess. I'm afraid that's what's gonna happen in Kentucky. As you know, these third party appointments just grow and grow and grow. The people you've spoken with there, are they largely from within the court? Same court system, or? Multiple. All over jurisdictions. All over. All over. Okay. I mean, I woke up last night,
were
up forming until wicked late.
And you know, we've talked about this before,
we're lawyers, right? Like,
am not
trained to be a therapist. I,
you know, don't prefer, like, I
I don't want
hear about everybody's traumas
all the time. I don't know where
put them. I don't
know where to store 'em. And it
sits with
me and I, my job is to give legal advice. Your job is to, you know.
Say this
is the law and this is how you
your best income, like outcome. And it's too much for me to handle, to be
honest. How traumatizing
of the
things I've heard are, yeah, I
I
I went down a rabbit hole. Well, let's take a few steps back. Why, why did you, how did you end up in California?[00:06:00]
Well, came out here. There's
like the nationwide protest and we are currently filming
a
documentary
talk about family court
and to talk about the need
judicial
accountability and what's happening in family courts all over. And so
we've been out here recording in Orange
County, which
like a very
wealthy I believe
area. And the
the fact that it's
out here
to the egregious
that it is, is
shocking. Oh yeah. You don't remember the, the, there was a TV show about Orange County.
Oh. I mean, I'm a real, I'm a Bravo girl all day, every day.
I actually
past the Quiet woman, which I guarantee you
you you don't know, but I was
oh my God, I've gotta go there
and throw a plate. I don't think you'll get that reference, but, alright. Well this is your second full day. Yeah. Yes. And tomorrow we're
go down to Orange County and actually document the protest.
But, oh, I woke up to
ton of messages. 'cause we've
got, actually California is
second, I know you
don't follow the numbers, but is our second state
we get the most
downloads in and.
and. I probably [00:07:00] had like 50
messages this morning of people being like, oh my gosh, I'm so glad
here. It's worse. I know. I've been trying
to tell you
something report on my case. I had a
a woman be like, listen, I'm
minutes
away from you. If
even need a
a ride, I'll
pick you up
wherever you are.
like hear
my story. That's fantastic. So how many of your people are expected tomorrow at the protest?
I, I'm hoping, I don't know, there's been three days
of it. There's an online protest
been going
on and I think there've
a
a million plus views on that.
And actually the sneaker guy
likes you, which you don't know. They're for frame of reference,
got a huge
following and he just
on staying with Meg, but
they like our podcast a lot and he really likes What you say He's outta New York.
What kind of person or he is in New Jersey?
But
be careful
Somebody
saying, because
everybody knows the
guy. Like he's got like a million
followers. Oh,
awesome. But anyway, I'm hoping, you know,
know, it'll
a good outcome and
and I just would like to see, I'm
try to get there a little early and
see if I can get into
and just like, walk around and get a feel for
the [00:08:00] courthouse, but Sure. I, I don't know if it'll let me, which court specifically is, is it? It's like it's Orange
I
don't even know how many courthouse
are in
in Orange County. Laro is the one we're going to.
Okay. Alright.
Alright. Mm-hmm. And is that one that I've seen from other people's videos?
I don't
think
Okay. So I think
this tomorrow's the last
there was one in
Los Angeles. There
quite a few actually.
Matt Grant had one today in St. Louis County that was well attended and actually the local media picked up on it. Oh, that's fantastic. Okay. Mm-hmm.
So it's just
crazy. Like everything I'm talking to all these parents here, they're like, I thought
was an Orange County problem. I thought it was a
a Los Angeles
And I'm like, you
know, I've
saying
I thought it was a Louisville problem. Mm-hmm. No, I, I really thought it
was
Louisville specifically, not even all of Kentucky. I thought we had a hyper-local problem, and that was all I paid attention to when I was practicing. So this has been, I know.[00:09:00]
Oh my gosh. And then also they have, you know how we have custodial evaluators,
they have
things
called seven 30 evaluations, and it's even nuttier than what ours are doing. I mean,
I don't even know there's gonna be a rec, there's a recording and there's a
a mom story that's coming out, but like there's a custodial evaluator that literally like.
There's all kinds of
of allegations, you know, and
is all, like, some of
of it's allegedly, some of it happened, but there was a orthodontist that's currently under serious
like child abuse charges involving
sa and the custodial evaluator gave the kids to this
and his
custodial evaluators like
involved in so
many other cases here in Orange County. Other lawsuits, all kinds of allegations. It, it's just
wild. Yeah.
Yeah. So what, what is seven 30?
I think that
must be like a statue
something. Like we just say like, but they're like,
oh, my seven 30 evaluator, like, and somebody
messaged
me right [00:10:00] now, like
about seven 30
evaluations and how
they are. I,
I really think it's just a statue, but I'm not a hundred percent. Yeah, I'd like to look more into that because I'd like to see the language that other states are using for the appointment of third parties. We use a friend of court if they use friend of court, how GS are treated, whether they are attorneys for the children, whether they are guardians, whether they are investigators.
So they don't really, everyone I've talked to doesn't understand the concept of a friend of court. I
don't think they have that.
have what they
call minor's counsel, and I
that's
like a guardian ad litem.
And
apparently a ton of problems there, as we've seen from some of
stuff that, like Susan Bassey
has
on out of
Northern California.
But
I don't, everybody also has immunity like
her quasi-judicial immunity, same as in Kentucky evaluators as well. It's my understanding they have immunity
here just like they do where we are, you know, quasi-judicial immunity, which has essentially been interpreted [00:11:00] as immunity. Yeah, sure. I, I can't think of anyone who's actually successfully gone after one.
And then the other thing is, some
of these lawyers, like this is the component,
I don't, I
I know I don't
want
to go down
rabbit hole, or not even
rabbit
but this
arena because. You know, there's so many avenues where
talk about lawyers
and we wanna talk about judges, judicial,
things like that.
But
there
are lawyers that are refusing to give bills.
I've seen the
the emails
please send me an
itemized bill and they won't do it. Yeah. So this is, I mean. One of my, one of my issues with the family court system is that it's a system and it, it sort of creates this machine, this machine that just chews up families and doesn't let them go. And they, they stay, th they, they're just stuck in this system until the children are, are adults. And that can't exist if you don't have other people that play along outside of the judges and the court appointed counsel. Like, yeah. If attorneys [00:12:00] didn't allow this to happen to a certain extent. It wouldn't happen. So I, I think it's an important part of the discussion, if not the, the total focus.
Absolutely. And I
I mean,
listen to like. The way that
some of these lawyers sell themselves. Hey,
know, I'm the good guy. And that's why, you know, when
we first
into this space, I was
like,
know,
we're gonna
a
a lot of hate or questions. Oh, they're a part of
system.
Oh, they
hold a bar. But then I hear how some of
of these lawyers talk to
potential clients
and you're like, you're
them just a bunch of
bullshit and you're not gonna like, you can't
me
you care about
constitution.
And it's
a
a year and your client's never been before a judge. Yeah.
You know, I mean,
I mean, and you make more money. You play along with the system. You keep coming back month after month after month. You keep kicking the ball down the road mm-hmm. And, and, and don't have a final hearing, and you keep getting to bill for. Right.
Yeah. And that's like
the, on the last
and I wanna
investigate this and reach out to our
General Russell Coleman [00:13:00] and
his office, but there's a lot of talk out here about
protection and the fact that they're not getting bills and the fact
that you are entitled
a good faith
S. As far as what these evaluations
what your, the cost is gonna be for litigation. And you and I both
know we got GS and FOCs that do not regularly submit bills to
parent. Or
or to,
you
know, the court. No, that's right. And they don't keep accurate records for their bills because when I subpoena them Yeah. Or, or ask to review them to see who they've met with and for how long. I'm just told, oh, I don't keep very good, accurate bills and I'm, I'm too busy to, to make sure that they're all accurate. Really. So, I mean, why
it? And that's the other
thing, you know, I've always gone to this like, what is the goal here? What's the missing piece? Why is it,
you know, quid pro
quo? Is it,
know, the C
word? I don't like
use corruption collusion just because I feel
like
loses the audience. But like so
often I just think like, I
driving
through and I'm
in like a beautiful area and I was like, you know
what? Like [00:14:00] the, there are some lawyers and we know, I'm not gonna name names, but like.
People that are on the FOC or GAL
list. And again, for listeners, it's not all of them in Louisville, but we know the people that wanna have power.
I
was
like, there
are some attorneys and court appointed people that
get to have
power
people that live Sure.
This life, quote unquote
And
they probably get off on it.
it.
Yeah, I mean, I think there's a long spectrum of C words starting on one side with the people that are complacent with the system and just allow it to happen and just think, well, that's the judge. They're gonna say What I, you know, who am I to do anything? Mm-hmm. And stand up and do anything about it. Then at the very opposite end, you have conspiracy where you have people actually colluding and working together against litigants in the court, which, you know, there, there are that, you know, there, there are some pretty highly publicized, you know, cases. You know, that we've, we've talked about
it's
all bad. It's all very bad. And you know, when we [00:15:00] started this and people started talking about us being part of the system, I, I, that just, I, I didn't understand what people were referring to. And then we start hearing people's regular experiences with attorneys and it's, it's shameful. It is. It
is. And also on a really
positive note
then we will
wrap up. I can't wait
get back,
but we owe you an Adair versus
Berton episode and
we got messages today. Y'all
That was
that was fantastic. Say litigants. Litigants
are
representing themselves in court
are listening to this podcast and telling the court, hell no, we're not waiving our due process. And we got
lawyers that are billing
of dollars an hour in
in Louisville that are still waiving
So, I mean,
collapsed and y'all, for listeners and everybody here
watching, Hugh
was the attorney on that case. So it's a very good case and
talk
about
later. But
anyway, yeah, that made me so happy. You should be, you sent me that the text from the pro se litigant that said, hell no, I listened to you and Hugh. [00:16:00] They're not gonna wave it. That's, yeah. That,
that, that's really remarkable.
Yeah. It's like we have stressful times and it's like there's so much going on with
like,
You know what
want this brand to
be, because we want it
be
100% like nonpartisan. I'm not engaging in
Judges just need to do their job. We need to follow the
constitution. And
you know, the pendulum, we
don't wanna be a part of any talking points, right. Like politically speaking.
No, I, I
No, I, I agree. And it just seems very black and white to me, but I, it apparently it's not, apparently
is a
is a systemic problem in, in family court and, and through lots of other courts.
Yeah.
and we get like
up in that. But then you
come and you meet
people and
it's
like,
it's happening everywhere. And then also we're making a difference with pro se people.
it's like exciting times,
you know? So you're meeting with people from all different states all over the country. Yeah. All over California and like so many
like I got, please come to
Colorado, come to Georgia,
to Minnesota, come to Maryland. It's [00:17:00] like,
we should, I mean, and judge's gonna get there eventually, but yeah, we need a road trip. Road trip LA big big bus. Get a school bus and paint it.
Listen
for the documentary. Last night
took
an rv. We got on top of an RV in Corona del Mar, which
like this gorgeous beach. But I drove there with
the person that's like,
you know, putting
all this together. I
to God on these windy roads. She was
driving an rv. She cannot weigh 105 pounds stopping wet, putting mascara on with
left
hand while
I just
am like, I am on an adventure of all adventures. Oh, fantastic.
So anyways, well, I'll see you when you get back and
thank you guys and also our YouTube. Make sure to go, we did a
and answer that will
only be released on YouTube
and
we talk
how we are human beings and have interest, you know, like what do
do you like to do for fun,
cetera. Judgy y.com, the judgmental podcast. Thank
y'all. Thank you. All right, bye guys.
Speaker 8[00:18:00] Yeah. Yeah. We need some. Justice. Justin found justice.