Episode 17
Shady Dealings

About this episode
The Judgemental Podcast – Episode 15: "Shady Dealings" Hosts: Hugh & Christine Summary: In this episode, Hugh and Christine dive deep into recent developments in Louisville’s family and district courts, focusing on judicial accountability, transparency, and the controversial practices surrounding Friends of Court (FOCs) and the Adair vs. Emberton case. Key Topics: Courtroom attendance and judicial roll call: Observations on which courts and judges are showing up and which are not. Listener feedback: Real-time reports from court attendees via the Judge-y app, highlighting late dockets and delays. The Adair vs. Emberton case: What the case means for FOCs, their required reports, and due process rights for litigants. Concerns about FOCs and judges allegedly coordinating to bypass statutory requirements. The importance of the 10-day rule for FOC reports and the right to cross-examine. Discussion of whether attorneys can or should waive these rights for their clients. Due process in family law: Examples of hearings lacking proper notice, preparation, or sworn testimony. The impact on pro se litigants and the broader implications for justice. Audience engagement: Listeners are encouraged to share their stories if they’ve been asked to waive Adair vs. Emberton, especially without proper client consultation. Call for transparency and adherence to the law from all court participants. Notable Quotes: “Let’s not come up with plans to circumvent the law out of convenience. Let’s follow the law. Let’s give parents their due process rights.” “If there has been some sort of coordination with the judges and the FOCs to find a way to waive a Kentucky statute that is there to protect parents... that’s frightening as hell.” “Due process, in the simplest terms, is just notice and an opportunity to be heard.” Calls to Action: Submit your stories to Judge-y if you’ve been asked to waive Adair vs. Emberton or have experienced questionable court practices. Follow Judge-y on Instagram and tag the show in viral clips. Links: Judge-y.com Instagram: @judgingthejudges Thank you for listening!
Transcript
4,747 words · about 21 minutes to read. Automatically transcribed and lightly edited; speaker labels are approximate.
Christine[00:00:00] if we had that kind of effect and people were listening to us and making decisions based on what we said, and if that is the case, all I'm asking you to do is follow the law. Mm-hmm. Follow the law.
ChristineAll right. Welcome to the Judgmental podcast. Let's get right into it. We were down at court yesterday, Tuesday. We did judicial roll call twice per usual, district court not showing up like they should be, huh?
HughYeah,
ChristineI mean there was a lot of, a lot of activity on one floor.
HughThen
ChristineThen nothing really happened on another floor. The, the first floor actually finally had some activity. '
Hughcause we're using one of the courtrooms
Christinea jury room while they remodeled the one over in the hall of in the Judicial Center. Oh yeah. That was like a total trick. I just think district court literally is operating with courtrooms at half capacity, period. End of story most days. Oh, it seems like it. I mean, every, I mean, everything about that building seems like [00:01:00] it's, barely running. You had the help desk, you have two different help desks there. One's been shut down every time we've been in there, the escalators are shut down and never work. Mm-hmm. You've got floors that are pretty much dark and all the doors locked and you've got, you know, basically half the courtrooms if that. And some of the judges were on the bench both in the morning and the afternoon, but it seemed like a lot of 'em switched. I think there were two judges actually, and now one of the judges, I think that was the first time we've ever seen her on the bench. I wanna verify that before we say her name out loud. Yeah. But I was really happy with Circuit Court. I think 11 out of 13 at 10:00 AM I mean that's 85%. Like there certainly we get a lot of. About from attorneys, I think or people that are in the court system and other jurisdictions, like, just because they're not on the bench doesn't mean they're not working. You and I have obviously said that 1400 times on this podcast, you know what I mean? Yeah. But [00:02:00] generally speaking, I think in particular Mondays and Tuesdays, most courtrooms should be open most of given the way, the structure of how courts work here in Louisville. Yeah. No, I, I can't disagree with that. I was impressed with the Circuit court, uh mm-hmm. Family court.
HughIt
ChristineIt was about like last time we were there. Yep. Half 70%. Half and a half, yeah. Oh, 70% of family. Yeah. Was that a,
Hughgo ahead.
ChristineOh, I was gonna say, the other thing though too is they have all of these confidential dockets. And so we can't see how the judge is, like, what time the judge is actually getting to court. We actually got a message on our Judge-y today, like I'm sitting outside the TikTok judge and she's late and it's like, I think that's happening all the time. Like 8:30am dockets are starting at 10, 10:30. Which unacceptable. Well, we, We've heard now in 24 hours from three different people, in fact, they have been waiting since the early morning docket. And we spoke to a gentleman yesterday who was sitting there, oh, what [00:03:00] was it, one 30 ish? Yeah. And he had been there since the morning docket and,
Hughand you know, just
Christinesitting there waiting to be called. And the, we've been hearing that the dockets have been starting eight 30 docket. Actually the cases start being called in at about 10 to 10:30am because the judge. Didn't arrive until then. Right. And that's just all in the last two days. We, we received another message from someone about being over on one of the dockets. So we, we get, we get messages from people that are sitting over in court and are messaging Judge-y. So, which is amazing. And the fact that so many people are like waiting to go into court and like watching us, like, I mean, judges just pay attention to this. Go to work. Like that's the easy part. Go to work. Which I think kind of segues into, you know, I've talked a little about this on my personal page, but we felt like something was happening last Monday when we were in court, right? for sure. Oh, there was no doubt. So we heard multiple references to waiving Adair, which is [00:04:00] Adair versus Emberton. case that came out in July of 2024 that sort of. Reiterates what the law already said about FOCs and their role and what they have to do, and that they have to file the report 10 days ahead of time before they can advise the court. There's a right cross-examine the FOC. And so we saw FOCs appearing at motion hour, but refusing to actually speak about their opinion, which is par for, I mean, what is nor what the normal thing at a motion hour is the court. Ask the FOC what they think about the motion. Yeah. Yeah. And they just don't file the, they don't get sworn in. They don't file a report. And that happened all the time. We've seen a change. And that part, I think, you know, that there's actually a change to it is fantastic. The change that we saw, however is, is quite concerning. Yeah, absolutely. Well, I think we were in Angela Johnson's courtroom and it was an FOC and of course Angela [00:05:00] looks to the FOC says something. Well, this FOC was like. Your Honor, Emberton hasn't been waived, I think was her exact verbiage. And then we saw in three division three for sure, and then also in division five about we're waiving Adair. It was almost like it was a talking point, like there had been some sort of meeting or something where this was gonna be the new strategy. Yeah, I, that's what I thought. I was very interested in that too. The similar language being used by multiple FOCs. Tells me that there's been some sort of communication, some sort of a meeting you know, where been guidance maybe from the courts. I don't know. It's concerning though, because the rights in Emberton are set out very clearly in the Kentucky revised statutes. Like this is not, this is not just a local rule. These aren't just procedural things. The FOC has to file a report 10 days before advising the court of what they feel is in [00:06:00] the child's best interest. They don't get to show up for motion hour. They don't get to show up and, and. Advise the court without being sworn in and without having filed that report, which is the way that they've been treated for so long. yeah, and it's like, I don't think people don't understand fully, even me, when I was practicing, like I didn't use a lot of FOCs. I'm not a fan of FOCs. I know there are attorneys that are big fans and it's an, and I think that, you know, when I'm wrong, I'm wrong. I think that if it's done appropriately, properly and thoroughly, I could see an avenue for where it would be really helpful. this is for all the listeners too. This is literally your case. Like you literally appealed this case and yes, you are the one that got, and this was a case that when it came out, I remember I did a TikTok on it and it kind of blew up because it was Brian Gatewood and just the demeanor to to the litigants was in and of itself a but FOCs are fact witnesses, They're fact witnesses. [00:07:00] they are supposed to investigate what is in the child's best interest, correct? Yes. That's what the statute says. And they're supposed, yeah. And they're supposed to issue a report and give it to everyone. And I think the rule, like the KRI statute says it has to actually be properly filed with the circuit clerk. Right. Am I right on that? Actually, the clerk is supposed to send it out to the, to the parties or to the, yeah, to the, to the litigants after it's filed It's clear from the legislative intent that the purpose of this FOC role is to get something in writing. That way the court has something to look at to make recommendations, but yet all of the attorneys and people involved have the ability to cross-examine and to investigate the investigator. Right. Yeah. I mean, I think the idea is that
Hughfact
Christinefamily law cases are very fact specific. They're very different than, let's say, a contract dispute. Or a slip and fall that you, I mean, they, they involve sometimes [00:08:00] years and years of, you know, there'll be therapists, there'll be doctors, there'll be, there'll be all kinds of things. And it's difficult for courts to make those findings of fact on their own, just from the contents of, of testimony, a hearings. So I understand the theory behind it that you have someone appointed. then can advise the court. But because they are advising the court on facts and giving a a, a recommendation under the best interest of the child, there are very clear due process rights at stake there. So this is someone that's, that's making factual findings almost for the court. I mean, they're, they're proposing certain things. The courts usually go along with them. So due process says you have a right to cross examinee. And it's very clear from the statute that the, the friend of court has to, has to give the names of the sources of the in information, and it gives the parties a right to call and cross examine the sources of that information as well as the So, [00:09:00] yeah. And the 10 day rule is so important because that allows each parent the time to prepare. And that's what these FOCs weren't doing. Sometimes they were filing it in cases like day of if they filed it at all, if they filed it at all. And. I, I, I remember when I started raising, you know, objections when things were filed a day or two before the hearing or on the day, and I'd file a motion to strike, or I'd make a motion in limine to strike it. And, oh, man, people would get so annoyed, including the judges, they'd get so annoyed that, well, this would be really helpful to me. Well, don't care if it's harmful to my client, and it hasn't given me the opportunity to prepare. And it wasn't filed within the 10 days. It needs to be stricken. And I, I don't know, it seems like they're, they're still trying to get around that now. The FOCs are apparently asking people to waive their rights under Emberton, which is interesting because the Emberton decision states very clearly a party may not [00:10:00] waive his or her right of cross-examination prior to the hearing. So. I want to know what they are asking people to do prior to the hearing by sending out emails, asking if they will waive Emberton so that the friend of court doesn't have to file a report and can just show up at a motion hour or hearing and give, give a report to the court. Exactly like so when we first heard it, it's like, well, your Honor, they haven't waived Emberton, but I wonder if the next move, and I think this is, this is a gut feeling mixed with. Some information that we have gotten from a plethora of people. My favorite word, but like there is something percolating where they are trying to not have to file a report and they are working in an orchestrated manner to do so. Yeah. And I find that to just be a radical notion, to think that instead of just doing the job, which the statute, if I'm right, it says the FOC shall file, right? Yeah. You gotta file a report. Yeah. It has to file a report. [00:11:00] And so I don't even know one, if these attorneys have the capability of waiving that for their client. Like I, that makes me nervous to think an attorney would ever do that in the first place. Right? Yeah. I mean, from my point of view, if you're an attorney and you're asked to waive this and you haven't had a very specific conversation with your client about this is what we're giving up, if this person shows up and says something. I don't get to cross examine. I don't get to know the sources. I don't get to review the materials or the notes ahead of time unless the attorney has had that conversation with their client and they say, oh yeah, that's fine. We'll waive Adair Emberton. I don't know how that's not malpractice. I don't know how. Oh, yeah. The attorney should not be liable if the case then goes against their client. I mean, I think that creates a huge problem. It was the first time we saw it. So I wonder if they're gonna try to get clients to waive Emberton at every motion hour or if they're trying to look for like a blanket waiver. I mean, it's [00:12:00] problematic either way, and it would have to be, I frankly, I don't think it can be done. I don't think you can waive a due process, right, like this. It's by statute and by case law. Yeah. I mean, it's the law twice now. I mean. Gary 4, 3, 300 sets out the, the rules for, for FOCs and the, and the report requirement. Emerton versus Adair didn't create anything new. It just basically said, follow the law. Here's what the law clearly requires. Here's the number of ways that the court in that particular case didn't follow the law. And it says you can't waive the right to cross-examine prior to a hearing. So if an attorney is asked if they would waive Emberton at a motion hour and they've not discussed it with their client. And they waive it. The client's not even there. I, I don't know. I, I think that creates a huge problem for the practitioner, but I, but I, I also think that we have a, something that to me is very, very troubling. And if there [00:13:00] has been some sort of coordination with the judges and the FOCs to find a way to waive a, a Kentucky statute that is there to protect parents. waive the actual law and case law that came down and said, you can't waive this. And now if we have judges and FOCs coming up with a scheme in order to do that, which I don't know that that's happened, it was just. It was just amazing how many people were using the exact same language and how the procedure had just changed so dramatically in multiple motion hours. That, that's, that's frightening as hell Well, it's, I mean, to me it's, I'll use the word, I mean, if. There actually is a meeting and there is an attempt to have a meeting of the minds. It's a conspiracy. It's two or more people. And there's an overt act, and I don't even wanna say it's a statute, like you said, it's a statute to protect parents. Yes, of course. But let's take it a step further. Like literally your right to [00:14:00] parent is constitutionally protected. Yes. So this potentially has the potential allegedly to be a group of elected officials. Attorneys appointed that are granted quasi-judicial immunity and parents that have a constitutional right to protect their children, and there is an orchestrated event if this is happening to circumvent that. I mean, that's fucking insane. Yeah, no, I, I agree that that scares the crap out of me because it's, it's I mean this is a statute, the statute gives rights. The court, you know, the Court of Appeals has said in a published opinion, these are the established rights. These are things that can't be waived. And now it looks like we're just, I mean, there's, there's some sort of workaround now to allow FOCs to come in and give testimony filled with hearsay, not be sworn in and not file a report pursuant to the statute in order to advise the court on what to do on matters of [00:15:00] parenting time and custody.
HughWell,
Christinethe bigger thing too is let's look at the timing of this, right? So this order came out, I think you said July, right? 20, so a year ago. July of 2024. And there was none of this alleged orchestration. Then. What's the factor? Us going to court and talking about it? Oh, if only. No, but I mean, I really do think that us reporting on this is what's caused them to realize they need have some sort of plan because maybe they weren't following it anyway until we just got on a podcast and started saying, Hey, this is a real problem. But like, I think that makes it even more potentially nefarious. Well, I mean, listen, I, I would be honored if people, if we had that kind of effect and people were listening to us and making decisions based on what we said, and if that is the case, all I'm asking you to do is follow the law. Mm-hmm. Follow the law. Let's not come up with plans to circumvent the law to get around out of convenience. [00:16:00] Let's follow the law. Let's give parents their due process rights. Mm-hmm. Let's take away the power from the FOCs and give it back to the judges so that they do their job. Yep. Instead of just having the overworked FOC who, like in the Adair case, didn't reach out to the client, even though the court had even recognized that the FOC really needs to talk to the child before making recommendations and then. Makes recommendations anyway, and the judge goes along with it, let's just follow the law. Let's just follow procedure. Let's give people their due process rights and then no one will have anything to complain about and we'll move on on this podcast. Yeah, this is like my big thing. This is where I get so frustrated. It's like everybody that you know, a lot of times in the public, they'll be like, oh, it's a quote unquote. They're these people, they're gonna be outspoken because they didn't get the, their kids right. But imagine if you were going through it and then come to find out the judges, the family law attorneys and the FOCs are like getting together and meeting and making these decisions. Like [00:17:00] how is that helpful to not making someone like, feel a certain kind of way about family court? I don't know if I said that articulately, but do you know what I mean? Yeah, absolutely. I'm, I'm. It seems that there have been some, been discussion amongst the FOCs in the way to handle Adair vs. Emberton. The, the idea of waiving a case law is just, it's something that's odd enough that I don't buy, that people are just coming up with that independently and saying virtually the exact same words. Yeah. Now I'm, I'm interested to see, and we did not get a chance to see a lot of actual practitioner reaction to that. Right. So. To the extent that there are any family law, practicing family law attorneys involved in coming up with that workaround? I don't know. I would hope that people that are asked to waive, that would be up in arms about it. In fact, I know that some are, some have reached out to us and say they've been asked to waive Emberton prior to hearings [00:18:00] and that, that, you know, can you, can we believe that? I so I'm hoping that's the reaction of most of them. But just the, the whole idea of this scheme in general is, is.
HughJust disturbing. It's
Christinebonkers. And also, you know, you wonder if, like we have FOCs that have their own private practice, so I wanna see if the FOCs in their private practice are waiving Adair versus Emberton. And also are judges giving people that waive the rule of favorable outcome or more appointments. I mean, it just seems that there is this feel that there could be the potential for quid pro quo. Quid pro quo, you know?
HughSure. So,
Christineyeah,
Hughbut
Christinewe're gonna have to, it feels dirty. Yes. We are gonna have to do a full deep dive of Adair vs. Emberton, just because it's like a 20 minute hearing. I got it. I had been done practicing for a year, and it's all of the things you can imagine in one. About the problems and what happens every single day in Louisville prior to this opinion. [00:19:00] I mean, just a judge being unprepared, an FOC being unprepared. The demeanor in the court. And just for clarification purposes, I know I know this, but you were not the attorney at the No, I wasn't the attorney at the time. The actual hearing that was appealed
Hughtook place. The
Christineclient was not represented mm-hmm. At the time and came to me after I'd had some success with the appellate court on, on another case and asked me And it goes back to a common theme where when we were practicing you and I, we did not see what happened to pro se litigants. And you just wonder how often was this same fact pattern happening if. Your client had not gotten the means and the wherewithal to hire you, who knows what would've happened? Oh, I agree. I, I, I, I agree. I mean, you say that this case sort of represents things that we see all the time in family law. I mean, one of the things that that happened was court went forward on a hearing on three things, and the hearing [00:20:00] was only set for one of those things. The other things were. One was filed the night before, or sorry, the day before, and the other was just a renewed request, I guess, on the spot by one of the attorneys. And the judge went forward and granted that request, granted it before even admitting the mother into the courtroom, not swearing someone in. Anyway, we can get into that. Mm-hmm. But those are just things that happen so regularly and that sounds bizarre to anyone outside of family court, I'm sure, and, and maybe outside of this jurisdiction, but we hear about it happening. In, in cases all over the country.
HughBut
Christineunfortunately those are things that just happened. You go in, well, let's just have a powwow. We won't go on the record. Oh, wait, hold on. We'll go on the record in the middle of this little powwow, and then I'm gonna make findings based on what was just said to me. In this case, ex parte just in a basic conversation, in complete violation of statute. And I'm gonna make the findings and I've already written them. And then we will just call the parties in and tell 'em what we're gonna [00:21:00] do. And that stuff happens. Oh yeah. And I think that's why, again, you have people that say, I got so wronged in family court, or there's no due process in family court. And if you want an example of where there was no due process, you just need to watch the hearing from a dairy versus eEmberton because due process was like out the window. I mean, it was just crazy. And for everyone listening due process is so, the simplest terms is just notice and an opportunity to be heard, you know?
Hughknow?
ChristineThat is the foundation of the American judiciary. I mean, it should be. Yeah. I mean, certainly it's the only way that our court system can work. You don't, you should never expect to go to court and for the court to be presiding over an issue that you had no notice of. Right. No preparation for. Mm-hmm. And that you're going to have a quote unquote quote you know. Expert or appointed witness that gets to basically tell the court what they think they should do. And you don't get [00:22:00] to ask any questions. It gets to play judge, just like literally. And typically in, in this hearing was not sworn in, right? Yeah. It was not sworn in. No, one, it didn't seem like anybody was sworn in. Which is a whole nother ball game. But now I, and tell me if I'm wrong, but I don't, we can't obviously give legal advice, but I do want anyone and everyone that is asked to waive Adair vs. Emberton one. I wanna know that story and I wanna know the players in your case. So submit those to Judge Dash y. But just I think generally speaking, I cannot imagine a situation in which waiving adera versus Emberton would be a good idea. Can I say that? yeah, that's your opinion. I, I mean, if I put my ADV advocate hat on Yeah. And I've got a case where I want something done at motion hour and the court, I mean, would I feel good about it? No, because it's, I think it weakens the entire system. But if the judge asks [00:23:00] if, let's say the friend of court wants to. Say something that benefits my client and basically means I win the motion that's before the court, and the judge says, do you mind if I, you know, will you permit me to speak so and so? Mm-hmm. I don't know. I think as an advocate, if it benefits your client, I, I can see why in certain circumstances people would do it. I think that's an interesting quandary because it isn't. I don't believe that it's lawful. That's my my opinion, not advice. But I want to know, I would like to hear from someone who's been asked to waive it and to tell me the circumstances why you believe that it was in your client's best interest, how you handled it, and if, if you felt that it was safe to do without first speaking to your client. I mean. I, I maybe if the friend of the court had said right beforehand, oh, this is how I feel. And it's very, very strong. But I will say in my career, I've had people tell me that on the phone the night before a hearing, they feel very strongly one way and then come in and say something totally different the [00:24:00] next morning. Yep. And I, I wouldn't trust it. So I, I would like to hear the stories. I'd like to hear both sides, but I, yeah, like, like, Christine said, I would like to hear.
Hughyou
ChristineI'd like to know what these communications are like, what's coming from the FOCs, asking to waive it prior to a hearing. Even though the case law says very clearly, you can't waive it prior to the hearing. Yeah, and I also just think this is also just general opinion, but like judges, FOCs, lawyers, like getting together as a group and trying to circumvent the law and taking an overt step to do that. All it takes is for one of y'all to do an overt step too. I mean, this is like basic, basic crim law type stuff. Like what is it? In the event these things are happening at like if there's like a meeting or like a function, but just like think about what you're a part of because this is not gonna end well if this is actually their strategy. In my opinion. [00:25:00] Well said. Okay. Awesome guys. Well Judge-y.com. Judging the judges on Instagram also tag us in viral clips. Thank you guys so, so, so much. Thanks. Yeah. Yeah. We need some. Justice. Justin found justice.