Episode 14
Change in the Air?

About this episode
The Judgmental Podcast – Episode 14: Change in the Air? In this episode, Hugh and Christine dive into a viral courtroom clip that’s making waves, dissecting the legal and ethical implications of a judge’s actions and the broader issues of judicial accountability. The hosts then take listeners inside Louisville, Kentucky’s family court motion hour, offering a candid, behind-the-scenes look at five different court divisions. Key Topics: Viral video breakdown: A judge’s controversial handling of courtroom conduct, search and seizure, and performative justice. The role of social media in the courtroom and judicial transparency. In-depth analysis of Louisville’s family court divisions, with firsthand observations on docket management, courtroom demeanor, and the challenges facing both attorneys and pro se litigants. The Emberton ruling and its impact on friend of the court (FOC) testimony and parental rights. Notable cases involving domestic violence, parental alienation, and forensic interviews. Reflections on the evolving roles and pressures faced by judges, including personal anecdotes about courtroom culture and management. Highlights: Open invitation to McKay Chauvin to join the podcast and discuss court recording policies. Praise for Judges Angela Johnson and Shelly Santry’s courtroom management and empathy. Concerns about divisions with less effective docket control and the potential consequences for families. The importance of transparency, decisiveness, and respect in the judicial process. Takeaways: The need for clear courtroom procedures and timely rulings to prevent families from falling through the cracks. The value of judicial accountability and the role of legal professionals in advocating for systemic change. Connect with Us: Submit your stories at judge-y.com Follow on Instagram: @judgingthejudges Watch on YouTube: Judge-y Find us on TikTok Tune in for sharp insights, candid critiques, and unfiltered honesty from two lawyers determined to save the system.
Transcript
9,263 words · about 40 minutes to read. Automatically transcribed and lightly edited; speaker labels are approximate.
[00:00:00] You are listening to The Judgemental Podcast. We're Hugh and Christine, the Minds Behind Judgy, the revolutionary app that empowers you to judge the judges. It's pastime for judicial accountability and transparency within the courts. Prepare for sharp insights, candid critiques, and unshakable honesty from two lawyers determined to save the system. We need some justice. Justice, my fine justice. And I wanna ring, be in public. I wanna ring, be in public crowd. Yeah.
ChristineAll right. Welcome to the Judgmental podcast. Today we are gonna do the viral clip, and then we are also going to break down us going to motion hour in Louisville, Kentucky. Yesterday, August 18th, we watched five divisions really started off well and then quickly went downhill. But we will get into that. Let's jump right into the viral clip. ## Viral Video Alright.
HughThink you come forward,[00:01:00]
Christinewho cares? Wow.
ChristineOh my. Wow.
HughWhoa.
ChristineYeah, that's the second time that we have watched this judge. And last time we talked about how performative, but way outta line.
HughYeah. What I mean, so it, it appears that someone the [00:02:00] mother of a defendant was it? Yeah. Someone who was in custody that was in the courtroom and apparently took a picture of her son. In the court and was arrested for it, and the deputy was ordered to or told by the, asked by the judge to take her phone and delete the picture.
Christinewell, first off too, and like, that's a search and seizure, no doubt. I mean, absolutely. Took her phone and then said, delete something, keep it open. Which all, we all know that there's case law, that if your phone is locked, they need a warrant to get into it. Right. I can't think of the case on that, but also just what she was wearing, she looked completely fine.
HughWell, yeah. I mean, you don't arrest someone for that, so I don't think that was, you know, she made a comment about her being in shorts. I've kind of mixed feelings about that. I think sometimes it gets a little bit too casual in court. But that woman didn't look like she was disrespectful whatsoever. And what she was wearing, wearing, and
Christinethey weren't booty shorts. I mean, and, and also that's in Texas, but there's something wrong with that judge in Texas. I mean, she's just doing it for the gram. [00:03:00] Yeah. I mean, I just did not think that was in Texas by any means. I didn't think that was inappropriate.
HughNo, and I mean, I think a lot would depend on how they have it posted when you enter the courtroom or whether there's a sign posted inside that you can't take pictures. I don't think that that is obvious to people unless it's posted conspicuously and they've seen it. Someone picking their phone up and taking pictures is. It's so common. People snap pictures of things all the time, God knows. I mean, people photograph every meal that they take. So yeah, I think there's nothing out of the ordinary about that. I mean, if it was clearly marked or the court was opened, you know, with a admonishment that you do not take pictures, you don't take any recordings. I think I feel a little bit different about it, but hard to tell.
ChristineYeah. I mean, the irony though of the fact that the judge is literally in real time recording and being like, no, little girl, don't you dare take a picture of your son. I mean, it's not, I'm not saying it's appropriate, but the search [00:04:00] seizure, destruction of a photo and then subsequent arrest is just beyond.
HughNo, I agree. And when she called her up there and asked her a question that it wasn't. , It seemed like it escalated really quickly. Yeah. With for no reason. Yep. I mean, you can see someone being belligerent to the court and then them having to hold the person in contempt and lock 'em up. Right. That didn't happen there.
ChristineShe was very apologetic. I'm sorry, your Honor. I'm sorry, your Honor. Yeah.
HughI mean, she said I'm sorry, and then she gets. Locked up. It was like, yeah, it was performative.
ChristineI really wanna talk to an attorney out that practices in front of her, because this judge is clearly, like I said, doing it for the gram. I wanna know how their dockets are handled. Can you imagine sitting there and just knowing that your client that's paying you could be subject to her just like social media fodder? Is that the right word? ## Invitation to McKay Chauvin
HughYeah. Well, I mean that's, that's what we have. Yeah, , that's the standard that our court administrator has set in Jefferson County. So. That is what we do. It is [00:05:00] perfectly fine according to our court administrator for someone to be selectively streaming to TikTok or to some other social media from their court while they're taking care of court business.
ChristineYep. And this is McKay Chaivin who basically said that a judge can record in court for whatever purpose.
HughDidn't basically say it, he straight up said it.
ChristineTrue. True, true, true. Said
Hughthere was no problem. He had no issue. Mm-hmm. Whatsoever were his words about. You know, judges filming and for whatever purposes they want. Mm-hmm. Yeah.
ChristineWhich I would love for them to live stream court. So maybe we can have them do that. And two McKay Chaivin obviously open invite to be on the podcast at any time. We did not run into him on Monday but yesterday ## Family Court Motion Hour
Christinewe went down and watched five divisions for motion Hour. And I will just start by saying I was a little dramatic. Anxious ridden baby yesterday,
Hughhuh? Yeah., You said that, and , I felt the exact opposite. I, every time I go over there now, it just confirms how [00:06:00] miserable it was to be going through that slog each and every week. Tots, and it was so much more fun just being there without anything at stake, without having to make arguments, without having to. See if the other side showed up. Mm-hmm. Figure out, you know, constantly check your email to see if someone has filed a last second objection or ask for something to be called. You know, , and you never know what the, the court's gonna do. I I do not miss that one bit.
ChristineNo, I, I did this weird thing where like in the morning I texted you just like, and I was just kind of hoping that you were gonna be like, like a little kid that like, doesn't wanna go to school. And you were be like, are we really doing this today? Huh? Like, can we get out of this? I don't know why I was so anxious. I guess because we really, for whatever reason, not on purpose. We just haven't watched a lot of one, two, or three.
HughNo, no. And, and we've been covering well. I mean, we go over there for other reasons. We go over to get things that's usually in the afternoon. It's sort of in the schedule of how we produce things here and we need to be watching all of them equally, I think.
ChristineYes, I agree. And I will tell [00:07:00] you, you said this yesterday. You were spot on the second. Judge Angela Johnson started talking. All that anxiety went away. Yeah. I was just like, okay, there's not gonna be some radical calling us out. She was really, I mean, I thought the day started surprisingly well.
HughYeah. And I, I remember that from practicing. I, I don't know. , I always, if I had something in one and you're just starting Sunday evening, you start just dreading Mondays if you have a lot of motion on, in Jefferson County, we have motion hour. All day on Monday. Mm-hmm. Basically in family court and I guess in circuit court as well. It's going on everywhere. But she usually starts things off with an attitude one and two, just this positive and you could be arguing the most horrible thing. But it was an easy division to be in. , It was serious, but. More lighthearted than, than most other divisions. And usually coming out of those, I felt the same way. You sit down in her court and Yeah,
Hughthat's not that
Christinebad and relatively confident. I mean, there wasn't anything that struck me as far as from [00:08:00] her that I was like, oh hell no. I can't believe you did that. I can't believe you said that. Like, not at all to give her accolades.
HughNo, no, no. The thing that stood out to me was and I, and I guess I didn't pay attention to it as much when I was in there and arguing motions. And I would leave the division right after. To see how she handled pro se litigants. Mm-hmm. The dignity and the way that she spoke to them. That was I. I thought that was great.
ChristineShe has a little bit of an air of funny sarcasm, and I don't mean that in a condescending way where she, you can relate to her as a human. She's no nonsense. Oh yeah.
ChristineBut very much is like, we're not gonna go off track. Kind of thing. I know
Christinethere was that one case that was like super fascinating. Like procedurally I would, you know, I thought she did great as far as docket management and handling the docket. There was a case, just the standard it seems to be nowadays, allegations of domestic violence, allegations of parental coaching, and then there was that forensic interview, which I thought was so bizarre.
HughYeah. I want to, I wanna follow that. I wanna see [00:09:00] how that turns out. There were just. Yeah, that didn't make sense.
ChristineAnd there's so many cases now where you have all of these, if you ever have an allegation of domestic violence. Then on the flip side of that, there's gonna be the allegation of parental alienation. And then you have all these quote unquote experts getting involved and forensic interviews, custodial evaluator interviews, therapy interviews, FOCs. There was an FOC on the case. That was a little interesting.
HughYeah.
ChristineSo we had a common theme while we were there. I guess, is it okay to talk about this? Yeah,
Hughabsolutely.
ChristineAnd so for people that don't know, actually, Hugh created, well, it's not it's case law. It's a fabulous case. It was his firm and he was the attorney that appealed Bryan Gatewood. And we got this case called a Adair v. Emberton We do not have time to go into it today, although it is extremely important and we promise to do a full, like in-depth, probably it'll be an hour long break. Down. Sure. Because if you're in family court and you've got kids, you need to know this case, right?
HughYes, absolutely.
ChristineAnd he is an expert as far as this goes, but short, [00:10:00] my little short quip of it basically is just that an FOC can't speak unless they filed a report. Am I wrong? Yeah.
HughI mean, they are tasked as a fact witness to do an investigation regarding some aspect of best interest of the child, some aspect of the case, and the rules say for them. Before they, you know, before a proceeding, before the court, they have to file a report. They have to get that report and their notes and or give access to all of their notes and their processes 10 days prior to the proceeding.
ChristineAnd so the FOC, of course, this judge immediately goes to her, the FOC, and is like, well, what's your opinion? And she did something that at the time, you know, you and I looked at each other and we were like, oh, they're watching our podcast. But then it became a common theme. She was like, well, they're not, you know. I'm an FOC judge and I don't wanna waive Emberton. That was the verbiage, right? Or
Hughor unless they want to waive Emberton. Yeah. I can't say anything and I think the reason, I mean my opinion because there was nothing. There was the [00:11:00] Emberton case was very egregious in what the judge did. Oh yeah. But I don't think it was uncommon. It certainly, I didn't believe it to be legally novel and, but I think they were getting fed up with the practice of courts, just asking friend of court, you know, leaning on them for advice mm-hmm. And asking what they should do. And it is, it's one thing where you, you take your court appointment and you do your investigation. You file your report, and you get cross-examined at a hearing. That's the way the process is supposed to work. You're not supposed to just show up, have an opinion, have your opinion rubber stamped, and talk to the court as a person not, and not ever be sworn in. I mean, there were so many issues. With that. They were dressed in Emberton and it was just sort of longstanding practice that I think the Court of appeals was getting sick of,
Christineand it was common practice in Louisville. Again, the case you had was just this judge in particular is egregious with courtroom demeanor, but what was a little weird is basically what the friend of the court said too, was like, well, counsel, you can say what I said to [00:12:00] you, and I'm just like, oh my goodness. I mean, this is hearsay, but. Counsel basically just said, well, the FOC feels da da dah da da da. Super inappropriate. The judge allowed it. They're trying to figure out ways to get around, filing the report. Definitely a case to follow forensic interviews to, are done well, like immediately after. If there's allegations of like SA or, I mean typically I think essay or physical abuse at
HughYou say immediately after. I almost never see it immediately after.
ChristineWell, it would be immediately in time from the report to the professional as opposed to if you were in family court, they would allow the child to leave. And so a forensic interview in order to be accurate, typically is gonna be done like in immediate. If you report it to a trooper, you're gonna be taken to whatever agency in that county does it? ## Forensic Interviews
ChristineThey, my understanding from speaking with psychologists is that forensic interviews are the most reliable. Now I don't have an expertise in that, but that's just my [00:13:00] understanding. Have you ever listened to one?
HughOh, yeah. I've watched them. I've watched some of the most.
ChristineMm-hmm.
HughThe, uh mm-hmm. Most misguided Never asked the correct questions. Just absolutely worthless forensic interviews I've ever seen and think. Well, the kid didn't say anything here, so we can't really say that anything happened. It's like you never asked a single question. Oh. I mean, it was just, and, and it wasn't like slowly working into it and being, being good, you know, like a therapeutically getting into a subject. It was just. Shoddy work.
ChristineOh, I've seen forensic interviews when I was a juvenile public defender. I saw one, one time that like, literally the hairs on my arm stood up. When I just talked about it. It like traumatized me beyond, traumatized me. It's difficult for me to even like, think about, but I think that could go back to, to the just the Louisville component of doing things the way Louisville does it, which is. Probably, you know, Louisville thinks a lot of times that they're like the best and the brightest of every, everything. I don't necessarily think that's the case. It's funny because I didn't,
Hughit's, the interviews I've seen in [00:14:00] Louisville have been good. The ones that I've seen from out of county were, yeah, shocking. And I was measuring them against some of the ones that I saw that were done very well. Well, here. So that, I mean that was just my experience.
ChristineThat's funny. But there was notion too, the, it seemed the court ruling and we'll move on. Sorry. We're talking a lot about this when there were so many cases that were interesting, but it seemed like the judge said, I'm gonna give the forensic interview only to the FOC and no one else.
HughYeah, that's what it was.
ChristineI mean, that's idiotic. 'cause there a better word.
HughWell, I just don't understand how it can be used. The friend of the court can't come in and give hearsay evidence. There are a few, there's some case law where there, there are a few exceptions to that, but they, they're not gonna be able to come in and talk about what a report says if the parties are barred from being able to review the report itself.
ChristineAnd even big picture though, it's just like there are allegations a. Mother and father's child was abused. [00:15:00] The mother and father have a right to see the recording of their child talking about their abuse. Yeah.
HughThis is, this is exactly facing your accusers, the constitutional right, but also as a, as a practitioner, I, you know, if the friend of the court was against my client and the weight of the evidence seemed to be against my client, I might want them to review that report so that when they're testifying I can. I can on cross examination, get them to admit that their their opinion was formed based on a third party statement. That's inadmissible and, and high level. High level, yeah. Oh, I have no, I get it, but it just sets up my, my point is it sets up. So many problems if this case goes to trial, the, the, the admission of evidence and things, it just causes so many problems.
ChristineYeah. Idiotic. And also most forensic evaluations too, I don't wanna say most, but a lot of times it could be the perpetrator could be not the mom or the dad. I mean, parents also the right to face the accused, but also parental. The constitutionally [00:16:00] protected right to parent your child. You have a right to see that as a parent.
HughYeah, but I mean, I just think, again, as an attorney, you're preparing for the report of a , friend of the court. You're preparing the examination at trial of a friend of a court, but you don't get to see what I mean. It's insane and. The rule says that they prepare a report 10 days before and have to give you full access to the materials they use to give that report. How does that jive with a, with an order that only the front of the court gets to review? Certain evidence. Absolutely.
ChristineAnd I will tell you, I would say as far as being an expert on friend of the court, what they can or can't do, I practiced for 10 years and Hugh literally knows everything. I feel like you're, you should give like Ted talks on what a friend of the court is in Kentucky, you know? Seriously. 'cause people don't follow the rules and I don't think that attorneys know how to preserve the issues either, really?
HughOh. I think the way that the system has been used a way friend of the court's been used, I don't think there's anybody that can tell you. What it is anymore. ## FOC & GAL
ChristineYeah. And real. If this is your first episode with us, very, very briefly, two types of [00:17:00] attorneys, GAL for children that are appointed by the court. GAL, guardian ad litem, that's actually the child's attorney. And then a friend of the court, like he was saying, is a, not, doesn't have to be attorney, typically is, but is appointed to be a fact witness and investigative body. Right. And so then we had a, you know, in one we were kind of chilling. We saw some people we knew had a good vibe. Motion hours typically go an hour, but they're stacked in half hours. So we immediately bounced over to Shelly Santry in Division two. Division two. I know. You, you wanna start with this one? 'cause you were Yeah.
HughI, my, my biggest takeaway though, this was the one that blew me away for the day, the fact that she was giving out hearing dates from the bench. And most judges, you go back and you talk to the staff to get a hearing date. And. Everyone else in the courtroom doesn't hear. Mm-hmm. Getting hearing dates, it just, I mean, it just speeds things along. She was just giving out hearing dates to people while they were arguing the case, which gives us some insight into how quickly, like how open her docket is and how quickly she can get people in. I was blown away. She was getting people in [00:18:00] first week of September, and I think that she offered somebody sometime that had opened up like on August 25th.
ChristineSo blown away, good or bad.
HughOh, good. Like phenomenal, like so many divisions you go in, you would be three, four months out. Mm-hmm. Just to get a basic hearing. She was giving people half days in October, which is really short amount of time when you're requesting a half of a judge's day. When typically if they have district court dockets different dockets three days a week, they only have four halves of days to get anything done. You're taking half of one of those to be able to get someone in October. That was mind blowing. And, and the, my big takeaway is if they can do that in two. Why the hell can't we do that in other divisions?
ChristineYeah. I feel like I looked over and your mouth like was agape because it was like, oh God. The first time she said
HughSeptember something, I was like, wait, what was that September?
ChristineYeah. And I did think it was really shocking that division for me for like two reasons. I thought it was run really well. Yeah. I didn't necessarily, so what [00:19:00] she does on her docket is she kind of does like a first call, like which is done in other states. So she kind of was like, if you have a quick thing Yeah. Like. You could have your case called, and then she's gonna handle all of the attorneys and she's gonna handle all of the pro ses which I kind of like.
HughYeah. And, and the way she described it and explained to the proces why they were last. Mm-hmm. And it didn't mean they were less important. She could give them more time. Yep. The attorneys can move on. I thought that was excellent.
ChristineOh, that was a really good point. Like if you were in her courtroom and you had never been to court before, I think you would've understood the process immediately
Hughand you would've been so much less nervous. Mm-hmm. And worried about it given her demeanor in the way she handled it.
ChristineYes. Now, the other side of it, just for me, is seeing what happens to a judge once they take the bench in the sense of having known them before. Right. Like, judge Santry was, I donated to her campaign. Y'all know I'm very vocal about the fact we should not be able to do that as lawyers. But I did endorse her. I did donate to her campaign. She dedicated her life basically to [00:20:00] domestic violence. And the way the bench has sort of changed her in some ways is shocking to see. And ha, I do have some sympathy for her. She looked. Dramatically different. Just very, you could feel the stress, could you not?
HughYeah. I mean, , I see that with most of 'em that are on the bench. I, I didn't know her well enough personally , to really know. Mm-hmm. I mean, she certainly seemed different then when I used to practice against her a whole lot. But that was, when I actually think back, that was a long time ago. We probably all look very different. I, I just know that,
Christineto me it was like a dramatic shift. See, she's the first judge in Louisville family court that I knew as a litigator before that went on the bench. It was, it was a starly dramatic
Hughbecause she was actually a litigator before she went on the bench. That's pretty rare. That part.
ChristineThat part. It's very rare. I was very disappointed in Shelly for not vocally coming out. Saying, Hey, Denise Brown, you shouldn't have selfie recorded the domestic violence hearing just because she dedicated her life to domestic violence. But [00:21:00] you could just feel it made me have sympathy for the judges and I know to our listeners, but I did because I could see the lack of joy and happiness that was like emulating from her. And I don't mean to say that to be mean. I'm not kidding. I'm like, literally, I had sympathy because. She did seem a little bit like just the, I could feel the stress. Yeah. Is that wrong to say? I'm not trying to be mean in any way. I mean, she handled the docket very efficiently and it
Hughwasn't the only one that we felt that in.
ChristineYeah.
HughYeah.
ChristineThe other thing too, I loved how she handled the docket, but just for perspective of us not seeing what happens to pro se people, if pro se stuff is handled at the end, there's just no way a lawyers would know. And I'm not saying it makes sense 'cause lawyers are getting paid hourly. The judge is actually saving money to people that have attorneys. Oh yeah. Like I'm not criticizing her, but that could be one of the reasons why we don't know what's happening in cases involving two pro se people.
HughNo, that's right. And that's what I mean. It was interesting for me to see, and oftentimes when we've gone to motion hour. The, [00:22:00] the latter division, some of the ones we've been to have taken long enough, we haven't gotten to the pro se cases 'cause we've had to run to the next one. Mm-hmm. And, and judges get to attorney cases first so they can get to the next motion hour. And one judge isn't holding up everything happening in the other division. So , it makes sense to do that, but also they can spend the time necessary for the pro se cases. Mm-hmm. And I just as a practitioner, I ran to the next division, didn't see those pros se cases very often. So it was interesting to see how. how each judge handled it, and I guess to a certain extent how differently it was handled between each division. Although I didn't see a huge difference between the divisions that actually addressed pro se people specifically.
ChristineI would say nine outta 10 though. Courtroom demeanor. Courtroom control.
HughOh yeah.
ChristineCourtroom respect. You knew you weren't gonna get yelled at by her, but you also knew not to step outta line. I got that feeling, you know what I mean? With her?
HughWell, well, she's always been that way. Do you remember her as a, as a litigator? She was. She was tenacious and intimidating, but was also always just very professional and friendly. She was one of the most. [00:23:00] Fun people mm-hmm. To, to have hearings with. And you always kept you on your toes. I always, I always en enjoyed same practicing with her.
ChristineAnd then I think this is probably when it took a turn for the bad as it started in three, the,
Hughthe first two, it was just like, wow, we're not gonna get anything good out of this day. And then we, then it just, yeah.
ChristineOh my word. I mean, we went into three and then packed house. Louder, less courtroom control. Now this is Lori Goodwin personally. I like, I don't wanna say I probably do. I like her the best of all of them as far as like personally, like, and just I, when she was at Legal Aid, she was fabulous to have a conversation with. She was always seemed to be like super prepared, knew the law. That was my experience with her. But this case, it just started to get outta control. And then we had the kid not in school.
HughYeah. One of the things that stood out to me in our, the first time we sat through the latter divisions. Mm-hmm. Were there, there were two big takeaways. One, [00:24:00] the difference in, and we talked about it, the difference between say division eight and division nine, like the docket control, the efficiency. Yeah. The way you handle things. That was my, a big takeaway. But also certain judges, now that I've, I've, it had been a couple months since I've seen them and see how stressed , some of them looked, it was sort of similar here. There were, there were two themes. One was the competency in the way you handled certain issues, or maybe it's not so much the competency, it's the authority, the way you acted as a judge. Okay, this is what's going on. I recognize it. And you have clarity. Yeah. As to either I can do something or we need to have a hearing so I can do something and then move on. Uhhuh,
Hughit just started breaking down in three. The other was, yeah. Yeah, the other was. It was the demeanor and then the way that it sort of felt in the courtroom and it just felt plaus. Like very different, palpably, different, going from two to three.
ChristineAnd so attorneys, we are used to like, if we can get away with it, we will. And we're not saying like outside the bounds, but like. [00:25:00] Oh yeah. To
Christinetake it outta context, there was an attorney, I mean, there was a judge age to practice in front of an eastern Kentucky, like literally the person that spoke last one. And so you would know like, okay, I don't care. I'm just gonna keep arguing my case. And then there was an attorney that was like, if you did that, they were gonna be like, I've made my ruling. Like they, the, the management of what attorneys knew they could get away with. But when we got to division three, and it was also just the first case we walked in, was an absolute shit show. We got a kid. That like literally is not enrolled in school. It is August 18th. The judge is like, what do you mean the kid's not enrolled in school? And then you picked up on this, I missed it. There was a hearing in 2024. I,
HughI believe that's what they said. Now I don't know if that's the one that's still outstanding. You know, whether a ruling is still outstanding. It, it sounded like that's what was going on. In any event, this is under submission. , The custodial where the child's gonna live and therefore where the child is going to go to school. Yeah.
HughIs outstanding for the court to rule on. [00:26:00] Right. And there's no answer. So the parties have just decided to play chicken literally, and the kid's just not in school. And the judge was shocked by it. But that happens all the time. Mm-hmm. Not necessarily children not being in school. Things that are normal. And you think, how, how in the world could this happen? Well, it's because they're waiting on you, judge. Yep. To actually rule on a case that you've heard.
ChristineYeah. And make a decision. And it's like, that's what was so amazing about Judge Santry is the fact that if you had an issue about holiday time, I mean, if you called me when I was practicing on August 18th and you're like, I don't have a parenting schedule for Christmas. It's like. Nuts and bolts. 'cause you screwed, you know what I mean? We're not totally luck. Yeah. We're not gonna get in front of a judge now. We can try to get an agreement between the parties and blah, blah, blah. But like you are not gonna get in front of a judge. But then this case was just super bizarre because now the kid is a hundred percent set up for failure because there was something about private school that the private school might not even accept the kid anymore. And then [00:27:00] JCPS, the kid's gonna be late getting enrolled coming in. And the judge was just basically like, I'll get an order out, but the kid needs to be enrolled. It's like, okay, well like where?
HughYeah. Just give some guidance. Yeah. You are the judge.
ChristineOr make a fucking
Hughdecision. Yeah. Just do something. And so three was where that kind of started and that got, well, I mean, that case was weird. There were allegations Yeah. By one attorney that the other attorney was behind the kid not being in school and advising his client to do that. I mean, it was. , I wanna pay attention to that case, but it's the judge not controlling things. Yeah, yeah. And moving things forward and, and taking, you know, taking a position or doing something to solve the problem. Sort of began in three, but it was just out of control in four.
ChristineYeah. I would say one, two, and three real quick. They all, I would say the judges had read the motions that we saw though before court. I was really pleased by that. Yeah. Like they were, which, you know, we shouldn't, that should be basic. But then we get to four and I'm telling y'all, I [00:28:00] mean, wild, wild west, we had three cases on that involved court of appeals, at least three that we know of. But she. This is Judge Lauren Ogden. I mean, I don't even know where to begin.
HughWell, she there. There are things you can do. You can do, set a hearing, control your docket, things you shouldn't be ruling on from the bench. Get a hearing date, send them on. You don't need to let them just talk and talk and talk and talk or. If there's something you can handle at motion hour, handle it. There were times where she would, someone would suggest something or say, this is what should happen, and instead of having an opinion on it, she would turn to the other son and go, what do you think about that? What if you just did, and it was just like, like half heartedly mediating the cases and never. Making a stand on anything.
ChristineYeah. And then this is a division two where it's like last one to talk because there was a case [00:29:00] on and one of the attorneys was late and this is nothing against the attorney. I think they were either maybe may have
Hughbeen still in two. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
ChristineI mean three. Yeah. But the judge basically was like, there's no way I'm putting this case on for at the end of August. And then once the attorney jumps on and they make their case, and she's like, well, I think I'm gonna put it on for the August hearing. Oh yeah. And you're like, you just as a judge, you should never, and I don't want judges to not admit when they're wrong. It wasn't
Hughthe, even the end of August. It was seven days from yesterday. Well, which means you've added an issue to a hearing. There will not be an order coming out that says seven days before you have to exchange exhibits 'cause there's no time.
ChristineYeah. I mean, I'm a, you know, criminal's, how I was raised, I mean, which we had very serious hearings in seven days. I don't necessarily have a problem with the ruling in and of itself as far as big picture, , but you had rules
Hughthat said you have a right to the evidence as a defense attorney. You got, what was there? What the prosecution had. You had a right to see it before you [00:30:00] had a hearing on an issue specifically about it. Here you don't, the person didn't include the basis for the motion. With the motion. Allegedly. Allegedly.
ChristineBut the thing, well, my thing was just though as a judge, like it's okay to admit when you're wrong, but you can do it in a way that's not for all of the crowd to see. I adamantly ruled A and then someone else speaks and I just completely, 180. To be. Yeah. And so then everyone watching is just like, oh, I can get her, you know, no client man. I mean, no courtroom management. Whatsoever.
HughI mean, , I used to issue guidance for young associates or new associates at my firm and would talk about the tendencies of judges, and that was definitely in four Speak last, but, you know, interestingly just letting people argue and talk and then the next person talk and then they were talking over each other and would sit there and listen to the arguments of them talking over each other and not control her courtroom. Yeah. But then there was an occasion where one attorney started talking. And was explaining emotion, I guess, you know, technically the [00:31:00] other side wasn't there and she needed to call the case back when the other side got there, but she just, right in the middle of a statement, put him on mute and said, oh, I just had to mute you because I just, I forgot about that. Just muted his mic. It was, I mean, but. I always got the impression that there just was never any courtroom control.
ChristineNo. And you wanna know what's interesting? We saw one attorney that had the exact same issue in division two and in division four, literally identical issue. The issue was a hair follicle drug screen. This attorney was saying it doesn't rise to the standard. This is an invasion of privacy. This is a violation of constitutional rights. Yep. And the way the attorney argued it in two compared to four. It was so different because that's what is allowed and what works. Yeah. And I mean this attorney was about to lose it in four, like I'm talking about, was just trying to explain to the, there was a frustration 'cause I don't think the judge maybe fully understood the argument, which I don't know how you wouldn't, it's so basic, but it just really showed the difference in. Courtroom management [00:32:00] Ha. The respect level that attorneys kind of have like, and this attorney's very respectful in court. I'm not trying to say anything nefarious, but it was just, it was the exact same issue. I mean, you
Hughcould just, the frustration. Mm-hmm. And the arguments. So the attorneys would make the arguments in some divisions and. You knew the time you had, you made the argument, the judge listened to it, allowed the other side you know, to, to respond. And if you needed to follow up, you asked. And the judge would let you respond. And then the judge would consider it and would say something and the attorneys wouldn't be frustrated If they lost, they would be, you know, it was disappointing. Mm-hmm. And if it, when it gets you. But it was just, that's the ruling. Yeah. They thought about it, they listened to the arguments. That's the way it's supposed to go in four. You could tell how just. Frustrated the attorneys were Oh. And they just knew they could keep arguing and we keep arguing afterwards and just would argue with the judge. Mm-hmm. And she would engage in it instead of saying, I've made my ruling, get out, you're done. Mm-hmm. Get out. It would just engage. Engage the parties in it.
ChristineI talked to an attorney afterwards that was like, I go to this [00:33:00] motion every week just to watch the show.
HughI sat next to someone who came in and didn't have a case on, didn't argue anything, and then just left, and I'm just like. This is the, this is either their entertainment or they've I, I don't know, but it, it was something other than having a case on and it, it really was fascinating watching. You went on to five. I stayed in four Just 'cause it was, it was like the accident you drive by and you just keep staring at it as you drive by.
ChristineOh, you have? Okay. He says that about four. Well, I left, I went on to five and it was probably three minutes in that I was texting you and I was like, you are. This is insanity. Yeah, this is absolute insanity. So then I go to division five and we are what, 11 o'clock? Right? So we've been there for two hours and it's so, I mean, you can just like feel it percolating in the air. The chaos, like it is just, but in division five, this is Judge Jessica Stone. She [00:34:00] did not have. Any idea what the legal arguments that these attorneys were making? There was a case with four attorneys, all well-seasoned litigators from all different spectrums, and the one attorney finally just said, all right, and they were fighting about. It was a very contentious case from like 2013 and there was talk about a therapist and reunification and then one attorney who's probably been practicing 40 years, maybe 50, I don't know, was like basically, alright, we're just gonna take this like really basic and start from the beginning. And then this other attorney who has known, what's the opposite of brevity. Ha
Hughha. Verbosity.
ChristineWhat is
Hughit? Verbosity.
ChristineVerbosity. Okay. We're gonna have a thing where Hugh teaches me one, how to pronounce words and two, how to use them appropriately. Oh, I've just been
Hughaccused of it quite a bit in my, what's it one more time? Verbosity.
ChristineVerbosity. Okay. This attorney literally said, [00:35:00] your Honor, I'm gonna make this real simple for you. I think the exact opposite of what she just said. I just
Hughthink that is so brilliant when you're in a situation. Where you're arguing something and the, the court is just not getting it, and you run the risk of, and the other side lays it out very simply, and you just don't wanna muddy it. You just wanna make it clear that w. The facts and the law, we see the exact opposite way.
ChristineYeah,
Hughit's just,
Christineand then there were two other attorneys in and it was shocking. And then all the lawyers are looking at me when they come back that are like diametrically opposed, and they're just like, what did, what just happened? Also, this case, get back to our theme. So in three we heard something about waiving the Emberton rule, so then this case. One of the attorneys was like, I'm not waiving the Emberton rule, because the FOC was on Zoom to make a recommendation. And I'm telling you this case, you could [00:36:00] tell just from the attorneys, they were all high paid attorneys, you know, 12 years of litigation. You gotta think this is a six figure case on each side, right?
HughOh, I don't know. I,, I have no idea. They, you know, they, they were acting as if it was, it sounds like,
ChristineI mean, 12 years, even if you're just at 10,000 a year for heavy litigation.
HughI mean, I, the part, yeah, I mean, I would think the parties have, have easily, easily, easily cleared the six figure mark. I just even, I don't have any personal knowledge of it.
ChristineI don't even know what the other attorney was up there for. And all this attorney said was like. These kids are in real danger, like something along those lines. And the judge was just like, oh, well I'm gonna take it under submission. And I don't even think it was something that you could have. I, I don't know. I got so confused and then you popped over. But I will tell you one, in division five, there no case manager they no docket control whatsoever. Did you feel?
HughNo, no, no, no. And I, and I got the feeling in both four [00:37:00] and five. The demeanor from the court was just like, well, I don't know what I can do about that. Okay. And
Hughit's like, well then who the hell can, right, right, right.
HughIf anyone else could do anything about it, they wouldn't be in family court. This is a court of last resort, and you are it. Yeah. The buck stops with you. You are the only person right, that can do anything about this. How in the world can you sit there and say, well, I, I just really don't know what to do and, and. But say that out to everyone who was just staring and thinking, what, what bizarre universe am I in?
ChristineAnd then there was a case on about, and this is where the judge really went on, like this diatribe, and this is where it makes me think it comes just like straight from Mike o Connell because the whole notion of the name change thing, like making this a big to do when in family court, a name change is like of no importance.
HughI don't know if I'd say that. I've had some serious fights over her names. Okay. So no, no names. I'm
Christinenot talking about like a, as far [00:38:00] as what your client thinks is important, I'm talking about Oh, you're talking about just
Hughgetting it done.
ChristineBest interest of the child. Oh yeah, absolutely. Like or just like Oh, absolutely. Safety of the child. Danger of the child. Like something that should be, you should be on your soapbox on as a judge. But she is requiring now for new petitions to be filed for a name change if there's a family court action and for new service. Which to me is just a bizarre, because essentially if you have a custody case, if you get divorced in 2022, right? That case is like open. You can file motions in it forever and ever and ever and ever, and you don't have to. There are some circumstances, but if you file a motion. In that within six months you don't have to get new service. Right?
HughCorrect.
ChristineAnd she was saying for the name change you did. So you have to get new service to change a child's name, but not new service to suspend someone's parenting time.
HughYeah, I mean, it's strange because there is a, you know, a petition for name change. It's usually have, you know, handled in, it was handled in probate court over in district court district. Yeah. [00:39:00] And it required, I mean, you've a new filing fee, a new and. I'm, I don't know, maybe it's just about getting another filing fee, but in family court it's regular that mm-hmm. Judges change kids' names. Mm-hmm. It happens in almost every single adoption. Yep. It hand, I mean, it, it, and they, they change adults' names all the time as well because, and it's legal
Christinestandards, best interest. Right.
HughAnd or consent if you're an adult. Mm-hmm. But yeah, I mean, there's just, there. We don't make adults. For instance, when you are going back to your maiden name, if you choose to do so at the end of a divorce. Yeah.
HughIf you are just, if you were not going through a divorce proceeding, we. The way to do it was you go fill out that a OC form over in district court and you would go through and file a new a new action and there'd be service. Well, I don't know. There wouldn't be service in that case. Mm-hmm. But you would have to go through that. But you don't because it's already within the jurisdiction of the family court. The court can actually do that. I don't know why you would need another one other than just. Another filing fee to the [00:40:00] courts.
ChristineYep. And I think that was 100% a talking point or something that was fed to her by either you know, somebody on the clerk side or somebody else. Because I don't think that the thought was original. It could be, and I'm not trying to be disparaging, but I'll tell you I am.
HughIt. It really sounded like, okay, here's how we've been told we have to do it now
Christineand not by no other court's doing it. It's just division five, who literally has no family court experience whatsoever. None. Well, I don't
Hughknow. Did we see that issue in other courts? Do we know that they're not doing it?
ChristineThe verbiage that she spoke about was like, no, that's not how, it was very much like, this is just my court. Okay. Yeah. That's how I took it. If I'm wrong, I will apologize. But I don't, I think it's something that only someone that only practiced in district court would ever think is a. Important personally. Like it's just like, bless your heart. You know what I mean? You ain't in Kansas anymore. But I have serious concerns about Division five, serious concerns about Division five. Like there was more enthusiasm and. [00:41:00] Attempted knowledge or the thought that the judge had knowledge about this name change than there was about the case with a child that was seriously endangered. Seriously.
HughYeah. I mean, and, and allegedly what was really remarkable is attorneys that just we know personally aren't necessarily fans of one another. Mm-hmm. That just, you see them walking up on a case and everybody just shuts up and watches. 'cause you know there's gonna be fireworks. Yeah. You would see their collective experiences when they turned around to walk back from the bench, they would be on the same side. Just like, oh, good lord. Uhhuh, what did we just encounter? Yeah, they had just gone through something together. Yeah. And they weren't fighting anymore 'cause they were both just ran into the same brick wall.
ChristineIt was like bonding and they were looking to both you and I. Like it was just for help. Yeah. And even attorneys that don't necessarily love you or me, you know, they're just like, oh my gosh. Because it's, it's just hard to explain. Like how the lack of understanding of just basic procedure and legal,
HughI remember doing that. I [00:42:00] remember being in motion hour and just thinking, you know, I would come in, I would expect that this is going to happen. This is gonna be the result. And then it would be the exact opposite. Yeah. And I would turn around and I would look for someone in the crowd to sort of look to see what their expression is like, help me. Yeah. Well the, or not necessarily that it would just be like. Am I wrong or was that really bizarre? You could tell from their expression. They would communicate back to you just like, oh damn, I didn't see that coming. And you would realize, okay, I'm not crazy uhhuh. And so we, we saw a lot of that.
ChristineThat's so funny. And we went on our little tangent. We could break down all of these and just, I could just in real time, like. Follow court. We're gonna get the tapes so then we can start doing breakdowns of that. We have a plan. ## Takeaways
ChristineWe know y'all love the breakdowns of what's actually happening day to day. I think that's about a wrap for today. I do want I guess real quick, your rose and thorn of the day, like your highlighting your low.
HughOh, oh. The highlight was the docket control in the first couple divisions, especially division two. That that made me very [00:43:00] hopeful. Yeah. That there is a way to manage the amount of cases that are coming through the family courts. Yeah.
HughAnd still get people in and out and make decisions that keep families from going through the, you know, the, the process uhhuh for years at a time.
ChristineI would say my high too was. Probably Angela Johnson. Really? And Shelly, I thought, you know, it was a little different, just like 'cause of the sad factor a little bit, or sympathy factor, but both of them I was, you know, really impressed with how they handled it. Do you have a low,
HughI don't even know where to start it. Just
Christine30 seconds or less? Four,
Hughfour. Four and five. Just. Seeing how the courts just can't, they not, can't act as judges. Mm-hmm. With any kind of authority. Yeah. Or any kind. I mean, if you cannot. Be decisive and actually be the one to determine what happens. Mm-hmm. What are you doing on the bench?
ChristineYeah, I'm split two with four and five. I would say the thing about four is that she's gonna get it wrong, or if she's overturned by [00:44:00] the court of appeal, she's gonna fight tooth and nail to keep doing it her way and not the way that's ordered by the law in five. I have a legitimate fear that a something bad is gonna happen because I even think in four, if there are really serious allegations or something, then there is that little bit of a flip with Ogden to take it more seriously like I, but in five, I am terrified that something bad's gonna happen.
HughThat's an awful thought. ## Sign Off
ChristineYeah, and I don't say that lightly. But to wrap up housekeeping stuff, submit your stories to judge y.com if you send stuff to me at Kentucky. Christine, I have no problem. I love hearing from y'all. I cannot respond to everybody. I'm getting so much, but it doesn't go into quene so there's no guarantee that it's getting investigated or being properly allocated, getting hundreds and hundreds of messages. So. Judging the judges on Instagram, judge y.com. Judgy on YouTube. And there's another social media platform. I'm [00:45:00] forgetting TikTok you got any housekeeping stuff? I don't. Awesome. See y'all soon. See ya. / Next call. We need some justice, justice, justice. And I wanna ring bells in public. I wanna ring bes in public nor crowd. Yeah, but I To the fo Yeah. I To the fo Yeah. I to the fo fo teaser.