Judge Ogden Suspension
"They Don't Do What I Do Every Day": Six Months of Ignoring the Court of Appeals
The Court of Appeals reversed Judge Ogden's restriction of a father's visitation. She took six months and five hearings to comply.

Trial judges get reversed. It is part of the job. What a trial judge does not get to do is decide that the Court of Appeals was wrong and refuse to follow its ruling. In Vannatta v. Vannatta, the Judicial Conduct Commission found that Judge Lauren Adams Ogden did exactly that, at five separate hearings over six months.
The original order
In September 2023, Judge Ogden gave April Vannatta sole custody of the couple's three children and gave Michael Vannatta liberal, rotating parenting time. Months later, April alleged that Michael was living with a woman who had an open Cabinet case and who was under a no-contact order with the children.
After a hearing, the judge found no proof that the woman had any contact with the children, and she declined to hold Michael in contempt. Her own findings were favorable to him. He was not abusing drugs. He had a steady job and suitable housing, and he was getting appropriate mental-health treatment. The Friend of the Court had visited his home and testified that the children loved their father, wanted more time with him, and that contact with him was in their best interests.
Judge Ogden nonetheless cut Michael's time to two hours of supervised visitation a week, plus three 20-minute video calls.
Reversed
Kentucky law does not allow a court to restrict a parent's visitation unless it "would endanger seriously" the child. On February 28, 2025, the Court of Appeals unanimously held that standard was not met. It found that Michael's past "bad decisions" about other children did not show the Vannatta children were seriously endangered. The trial court had known those same facts when it gave him liberal time in 2023, and "the court's decision to find this problematic now, but not then, is unreasonable." Restricting his visitation was "an abuse of discretion."
Refusing to comply
Under the mandate, Michael's parenting time was to be restored. The Commission found that Judge Ogden "refused to do so in five separate hearings." She explained her view of the appellate judges: they "[do]n't really recognize . . . they don't do what I do every day and we have to worry about the kids more than anything."
At one hearing she let April's lawyer talk loudly over Michael while he tried to ask a question. She then said "I'm done" and "This is crazy," and ended the hearing abruptly. At another, on Michael's motions to restore his visitation and to recuse her, she grew angry when he tried to point out the appellate ruling and said: "I'm going to excuse you."
The Commission found she did not restore the previous schedule until six months after the mandate. That is six more months of a father seeing three children two hours a week under supervision, under an order an appellate court had already held unlawful.
Why it matters
The Commission's order says Judge Ogden has since changed her practices so that "rulings of the Court of Appeals are implemented promptly and completely." That commitment should never have been necessary. A family court's concern for children is real and important. It is not a license to override the law or the courts above it. When a trial judge treats an appellate mandate as optional, the parent pays, and so do the children.
Sources: Ky. Judicial Conduct Commission, Agreed Order of Suspension; Vannatta v. Vannatta, No. 2024-CA-0726-MR (Ky. App. Feb. 28, 2025) (unpublished).
The record
Every judge has a record. Find yours.
More from the record
All posts- BlogKentucky Judicial Conduct Commission The Kentucky Judicial Conduct Commission (JCC) initiated formal proceedings against Chief Circuit Court Judge Daniel L. Ballou (34th Judicial Circuit) based on three primary counts of alleged judicial misconduct.
- BlogLouisville Family Court Judge Angela Johnson NEVER conducted an evidentiary hearing. Despite objections from state child welfare officials, a family court judge ordered her reunification with her mother, who was in ICE custody, and later deported to Guatemala in September.
- BlogFayette Judge VanMeter Ousts Beshear Appointee MoynahanDespite active support and intervention from Governor Beshear on behalf of his appointee, voters selected VanMeter to serve on the appellate bench, elevating a seasoned circuit judge with a 5 star rating on Judge-y