Episode 32
Resistance is Futile

About this episode
Welcome to another episode of The JudgeMental Podcast! In this episode, we dive deep into thought-provoking topics, share candid conversations, and bring you fresh perspectives from our unique panel of guests. Whether you're here for insightful discussions or a bit of lighthearted banter, we've got something for everyone. Today we discuss changes in the legal industry that are well underway as a result of the swiftly-changing technological landscape. We also discuss updates the the Judge-y app. Don't forget to check out our app and website at judge-y for exclusive content, updates, and ways to connect with the community. If you enjoy the show, please rate, review, and subscribe to The JudgeMental Podcast on your favorite platform. Thanks for listening, and stay judge-y!
Transcript
5,126 words · about 22 minutes to read. Automatically transcribed and lightly edited; speaker labels are approximate.
Hugh[00:00:00] Boom. We got, we have professionals for that that are great at kid stuff, but they're not. They're not. They're not. It's everyone offloading the kid stuff 'cause they don't wanna deal with the hard stuff. Yep. And appointing people who are no better qualified. Yep. And are way overworked and don't have time, you know, the time to put into it and it's just too much delegation
ChristineWe're back. We're talking about AI and an update on the app. I saw it in all of its glory for the first time, really today, and I'm so beyond excited. It is gonna be so functional. Obviously I am not the expert when it comes to this coding.
HughI love, it's gonna be so functional.
ChristineIt's so
Hughfunctional. That's that's funny. No, it's ugly as homemade in right now, but we're working on all of the functions where making sure the back end and everything is working. Everything is, , it's, yeah, it's fantastic., I'm very happy with where it [00:01:00] is. And then we make it pretty and go through the testing phase, which hopefully will start, , early next month. We'll have. The testing going and be ready to launch.
ChristineYeah. I mean, come hell or high water, we're gonna get this to you by Christmas. It'll be the best Christmas present. But I do wanna go ahead and make this announcement. I hope that's okay. So we have really sold this app so far as to be something that will be reviewed by attorneys, which is verified litigants and Court watchers. But Hugh has added a community component of this that I think is gonna be a fucking game changer.
HughYeah, I mean, I, I hope, I hope that it allows, it becomes a tool for, . Discussion. I know, I think, you know, in, in the last CO or one of the last couple episodes we talked about, or maybe we didn't mention in the podcast, so one of our guests, , some people came together as a result of an episode and reviews that were left online and sort of. Figured out that they had seen similar things in their cases and it resulted in a really great outcome for multiple people. And [00:02:00] it just got me thinking about having a cohesive community where, you know, these discussions , can be moved to, I think will. We will, , promote that and help that happen in a lot more cases.
ChristineYeah. And we want people 'cause family court's so isolating. And there are patterns and there are certainly patterns that I see with different judges or different GS or FOCs or custodial evaluators. And we wanna give it to you all to rate the judges. We want to be wrong about some of the judges. We want accountability, transparency, we wanna hear the good, the bad, the ugly. But I think giving you a community, and I would just urge everyone I know no one's gonna listen to me, but the family court reform movement to just stop trying to come, you know, at everyone within the movement instead of going big picture to change the system for the better.
HughYeah. And for, and for instance, so I mean, if, if we're able , to, , tag names people that are involved in the case, and then people can, you know, if they have a case and they can run through our community features. Run those names through and see other people's experience with them. I mean, that could be life and death , in some of these [00:03:00] cases. Mm-hmm. To realize that this is, this is why this is happening. Mm-hmm. Here's how they've dealt with it. I mean, , it can make the difference in winning and losing , a custody case.
ChristineYeah. And for everyone listening too, like, we really get this. Same players all the time. Yeah. Like there are a couple judges that we very rarely, if ever get complaints about. I mean, and one or two that doesn't, that's not necessarily representative of the system. There are the same GALs FOCs, the same custodial evaluators. Yep. And the same judges that we get over and over and over with the same fact pattern.
HughOh, sure. No, and, and what we've realized, , since we be began doing this and talking to people throughout the country is it's similar everywhere. Mm-hmm. That it's not, you know, that so far we've not talked to anyone where there's just this huge pool of FOCs or GALs that work in the case. There's, there's a handful. Mm-hmm. They're relied on all the time. They have too many cases and you hear the exact same complaints and, and [00:04:00] problems with, with the system that you, that we saw here.
ChristineYep. And custodial evaluators, and I'll go out, this is my opinion in particular, but custodial evaluators, and we'll go down this rabbit hole. I don't believe in 'em. And I think there is like some inherent, , evil or inherent. Badness that comes with those. Like, I, I can't, what we're seeing nationwide and the problems that we've seen with custodial evaluators and like the evaluator outta Colorado that faked her credentials and got sentenced to four years in prison, or the case, , where somebody was, you know, charged with something and then completely acquitted and there's a defamation lawsuit. You have a lot of these custodial evaluators that are just kind of, , doing some nefarious stuff again, in my opinion.
HughYeah. , And. Through either the podcast or other, . Reviews online or just other channels online? Some of these people, you know, once they found out that this, , a specific evaluator got in trouble and had to refund money in a case, they realized, oh, that's the person in my case, that was the same thing that happened in mine, and now [00:05:00] they've been able to go back in , and get money back , and change things in their cases because they've heard about it. Yeah. That's why we want to be, we want to be the hub of the community so that we can help people do that. And people aren't just having to search far and wide across Reddit and across, you know, online. Mm-hmm. We, we want those communications occurring in one place so that people can find that information that could be really critical in their cases.
ChristineAnd I literally cannot wait for you all to see it. , Speaking of apps, there was an NBC thing that I sent Hugh last night talking about a woman. , That utilized AI to win her appeal. So we're gonna dedicate this episode. This will be short and sweet. Listen to it on your way to work all about how chat GBT and AI are the future of the legal profession.
HughYeah, I mean there's, I agree. Now then this particular case, I think she was, , evicted. So this was a very basic here in Kentucky to be a district court matter. Really one criteria, one set of criteria. Very simple. But, she had been evicted and felt that there had been [00:06:00] an error in reaching that, decision. She didn't have money for an attorney, , especially for something that simple and started looking, , for answers through Chet GPT and got the answers and, and started asking it about, you know, what to do about it. And it guided her through writing an appeal that she was successful at writing and that. That doesn't surprise me because you know, the, the output is only as good as the input. But if you and I can see someone who comes in and doesn't know much about AI and doesn't know how to manipulate it and prompt it correctly, and just treating it as very conversational and maybe. Maybe giving it a little bit too much information. Mm-hmm. Might have stumbled onto writing a really good prompt. Yeah. And it giving the right the results. 'cause it certainly is capable of doing anything and everything , on a case like that.
ChristineYeah. I mean, you know, AI makes me nervous and there are circumstances where you can get to circuit court for evictions and I'm gonna be honest. Are there. [00:07:00] Yeah. , I'm not familiar with that law. Me either, but you're going to have Ms. Me Oliver on, , and she is the one that was incarcerated by Tracy Davis after there were allegations that she had recorded during a court proceeding. , And she also currently has litigation talking about the school to prison pipeline, , against President Donald J. Trump. I can't wait to have her on. , And I think she probably utilizes ai. She's a pro se advocate, litigant. , That's done a lot of stuff, but I do think as far as AI helping pro se people, it's gonna be a game changer.
HughWell, I mean, it helps in so many other ways. So, I mean, , I know that the controversy over, oh, it could never do what attorneys do. , If you mean like, here's the problem, write my brief. No, it's not going to. But if it is. , The legal research and cross-checking things and looking at transcripts and comparing those to the findings, there is nothing better than AI for doing that. And there are programs that attorneys have used for a long time that are very expensive, where you'll [00:08:00] load mm-hmm. Two PDFs in, and it'll give you a list of all of the differences in all of that. It may be like hundreds and hundreds of dollars a month to subscribe to that. , These you know, the, a free version of Chet PT will do a better job of that. Yep. And we'll give you a, you can customize the details all you want. Now, are you gonna go in and cite it? No, absolutely not. But you're going to potentially save yourself six hours of reading through hundreds of deposition transcripts and comparing them against court orders Yeah. And things like that. And it will give you the starting point. And then once you have the starting point, it, I mean, it's. The, it's so contrary to the hourly billing model. Yep. That I, you know, definitely concerns about it hallucinating and it making stuff up.
ChristineThat's a word, right? That's like a term of art.
HughWell, hallucination is just where, , AI will invent a fact. It won't find citations for it. So you ask it to LOL, I'm gonna start using that
ChristineIr in real life. I'm,
HughI just hallucinated. Sorry. It's [00:09:00] like the AI equivalent of a brain fart itself for the, it will write it convincingly as if there , is, , authority for it. Mm-hmm. And apparently, you know, according to this article, , sorry, the, the news story, hundreds of citations that were just completely made up, if already made it into court cases, I would wager a bet that it's thousands and thousands. Yeah. If you look at the actual state court level. 'cause you know, people are using this.
ChristineOh yeah.
Hugh, And. There are easy ways to get around that. I mean, you can simply ask AI to tell you the citation and pull copies of any citations that users, there are 20 different ways that you can make sure that that doesn't happen. But yeah, there def definitely problems that you run into. But I think that most of the pushback against this is going to be from those who stand to lose money from efficiency. And I, and I think there, there are lots, there's , a lot of technology. That attorneys are going to push back on because they can't bill as much for each task. Oh yeah. And that's Well, and I wanna asks a real shame
Christinetell attorneys right [00:10:00] now, , and I'm gonna do, we're gonna do a little experiment in real time, but I guarantee you chat, GBT is never gonna wave a dare versus berton. So I don't wanna hear from y'all. Oh, I can do better. I can do better, you know what I mean?
HughOr sign an agreed order that gives a third party judicial. Powers.
ChristineOh my gosh. That is case that we case
Hughjust, just reviewed. Yeah, I mean, it's definitely not going to replace every single thing that attorneys can do, but there are certain things that it can already do much better than a lot of attorneys. And , I know that'll make people angry saying it, but it really does.
ChristineYou should see this answer. I mean, it is so good.
HughOh. No, what, what's the experiment?
ChristineI said, should an attorney waive a Adair v. Emberton in a Kentucky, , custody case? And it gave me a full breakdown. It's got due process in bold. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. And everyone listening, this is Hugh's case. It talks about KRS 403.300 proper use of [00:11:00] friend of the court, and
Hughyou didn't feed it the case.
ChristineI fed it. Should you waive Adair vs. Embertson,
Hughbut you didn't give it a copy of the case to read. And this, this is what a free ver is. This the free account? Free ChatGPT? This is, this is Google Gemini. Yeah. That's free. Oh, this is just Gemini. Yeah. The free built into a browser. Gemini Answer. Yes. Researched, read the case, understood it. Recognized the due process issues. And gave an intelligent answer.
ChristineI'm gonna screenshot this, we should put this up with Yeah, I,
HughI agree. But
Christinein summary, Adair vs. Emberton is a tool for an attorney to ensure due process and proper use of FOC evidence. Waiving, it could mean relinquishing the right to make those procedural objections. , They should have said that at the. Freaking CLE, the Louisville Bar Association. Y'all did? Yeah. Don't wave Adair v. Emberton, in my opinion, not legal advice.
HughYeah. And you know, one of the things, you know, computers are good at black and white type things. Yeah. And, and I think a lot of the criticism of AI working in professional capacities , is the nuance and the, and the, and I think, I think those concerns are [00:12:00] unfounded, but when there are there. There's a lot that we talk about here, like due process and constitutional issues that really are black and white. Mm-hmm. And this, you know, your little experiment there really shows when looking at things on, on a bigger scale, black and right, white constitutional rights issues. Where it really has its strengths.
ChristineYeah.
HughIs outshining a lot of what we've seen actually in the courts.
ChristineAnd I'm screenshotting this and I did not have a plan to do this. One thing that I will say though, and I think there's a really, really strong argument that it's not just a procedural due Right, , due process. Right. That it's substantive.
Hugh. Yeah. No, I think that's interesting. It probably pulled that language from the, court of Appeals decision.
ChristineIt probably did, but I think as far as like preservation and things like that. Yeah. Like I would argue that it's substantive and I can't ever say that word. Right. \\ And there's so much, I mean, you're gonna be like, I wanna see, [00:13:00] 'cause he has like an, you have like a real ai don't you?
HughOh, I, yeah. I have a lot of custom things that I've trained for various tasks that I use. All day, every day.
ChristineI want you to, I'm gonna, I screenshot all this, but I think you should ask the same prompt to yours and see what the difference is. Okay? And I think we should put this up for everybody 'cause it is interesting to think about, you know, , AI being utilized along with an attorney. And if you have a good attorney, an attorney, a good attorney wants you to do your research, wants you to question, then want you to have these conversations.
HughI mean, anything that you can do to help your attorney
Christinemm-hmm.
HughI if your attorney is upset that you're doing things that further the case, then you know, there's a conversation that you need to have with your attorney there. But, , no matter how deep they are and passionate they are about a case. They have a lot of other things going on, and attorneys are just always extremely busy. So, you know, if you can just take away. Some of the need to educate you about these things. If you can go in and do [00:14:00] research about, you know, what is, what's the difference between procedural and substantive due process? Yeah. And go through and read some of that and not have to pay your hourly rate for an attorney to walk you through that stuff. The, I promise you, the attorney would love that if you came in with an understanding of it. I loved talking to clients who really were up to speed and understood things, and you didn't have to sit and think about how you explained everything. You could just. Say what you felt about the case and like, . You know, talk about the legal strategy knowing that they probably understood more about it.
ChristineYeah. 'cause we love the law and I think that's the unique thing that you get in family court that you don't get in all other areas and it's not a good thing. But so much is of the emotion is talked about. And I don't like talking about that like at all with people. Like, I don't like with clients like having to do the management. Of the emotional aspects of it now. I mean, I do, and I don't wanna say like, but I like talking about the law, making legal arguments. When I first started in family court, I was like, if I'm on your case for more than a year, you need to fire me and find somebody else to get it done. Now obviously things [00:15:00] changed and the delays and everything. Yeah, were exacerbated now. It's
Hughalmost a guarantee. If your case is litigated, it's gonna be a hundred percent. Yeah.
ChristineOh, it's almost guaranteed to get a divorce. I mean, to get into mediation if you had. Any sort of disagreement. Yeah. Not just the whole case. Yeah. Yeah. It's disgusting, quite frankly.
HughNo, it's, it's, it's, yeah. It's bad.
ChristineYeah. , I, I
Hughalways, when I first met with people, I talked about getting a counselor or someone they could talk with, you know, and just Oh. Saying, so. Okay. It's not necessarily saying you're depressed or you're anxious or anything, but there are certain things that they can help with and just talk about that you're wanting to talk to me about and. Happy to talk to you about it, but I'm a lot more expensive. Mm-hmm. I'm extremely jaded 'cause this is all that I do and, I
Christinegot no problems.
HughYeah. Well, you know, yes. That's going on in the back of my head. Although, honestly, the more people talk to me about their cases, the more. Yeah, , I think I, I oftentimes my wife get in an, and I get in an argument I annoy her [00:16:00] because it just doesn't seem like as big a deal. Yeah. 'cause of when I was practicing, I just saw 50 times worse, you know, all day, every day. But, but I mean, it's. That's not why you hired me. I always explain, that's not why you hired me. You hired me for this legal side of things. Not to get dug in on the emotional side, you want an objective person that can look at this and say, why this is a strong argument. Mm-hmm. Why we should actually focus on this versus that and not get down, you know, and, and. You know, mired in, in all of the emotional stuff, and there are people that are far better for it so that you can be more focused when we sit down and talk about legal strategy. And I would urge you to get involved and, you know, pick your own. Yep. I don't care. Here's some people that , I had a list of people that, based on my client's personality, I thought would be a good match, but I didn't care who they went to.
ChristineWell, just to be clear too, because this is where sometimes people that haven't been involved in the system and the road to hell,, is paved with good intentions. But I am all for therapy. I am all for learning about yourself. But be very careful with the court [00:17:00] appointed.
HughOh yeah.
ChristineThat's a difference. Like when you come to an attorney and they recommend that you go see a therapist that's very d. Then them recommending we get a court order to have a therapist appointed, that's gonna be a witness potentially in a case.
HughWell, I left out an awful lot about what I told people, 'cause I don't want to give legal advice to our audience, but there were a lot of pick someone, but here the parameters, because this person's records will likely be subpoenaed and you know, there, there are ways to deal with it where you're not causing yourself more of a problem. But that was. Yep. That's, that's more attorney client stuff that I Yeah, but I'm,
ChristineI'm nervous too. I mean, you also could ask ai, like what are the pros and cons of having a court appointed GAL court appointed therapist, the children having court appointed therapist. Yeah. Custodial evaluator. And I think you're gonna see a lot of pushback with the AI answers. Where it seems to me nowadays that I talked to three people, I wanna three, was it two or three that were saying in the second conversation they had with their attorney, they were recommending an FOC. That's bizarre to [00:18:00] me.
HughYeah. I mean, it's hard to criticize without knowing the circumstances of each one, but I do think that that's, that's a high number. Mm-hmm. I mean, I've always said there were circumstances where same attorney, I saw the fact pattern that I know how an FOC is going to handle it and that it's gonna go my client's way. That I've, I've had this same case in front of this same judge and I know what works in front of that judge, then I would recommend that. But there was just limited circumstances and that was just not because I thought it was a great process in general. Yeah. Or should be part of it. But that was the be gonna be the best outcome for my clients. So there were times I did it, but there are just people that are bought into it. Like, oh, there are kids involved. Boom. We got, we have professionals for that that are great at kid stuff, but they're not. They're not. They're not. It's everyone offloading the kid stuff 'cause they don't wanna deal with the hard stuff. Yep. And appointing people who are no better qualified. Yep. And are way overworked and don't have time, you know, the time to put into it [00:19:00] and it's just too much delegation
ChristineAnd also. It's good, you know, it takes a village type thing, but like if you have ai, like a chat GBT, along with your attorney, let's say your attorney tells you something, you ask chat GBT, and you get a different answer and you talk to your attorney and your attorney's like, oh, this is why it's nuanced here. Like that's something that you know absolutely. You, it could absolutely happen, but I just think it would be very bizarre for an attorney to get super, super, super defensive. Now, if it was second guessing absolutely everything that you were doing or that feeling like, Hey, you know what I mean? I could see where that would be a problem.
HughWell, the easier way to do it before you present it to the attorney. I mean, and anything that you do on ai, whether it's legal or anything else. One of the simplest tricks is to just ask it its sources and have it summarize the sources. Tell you if you got your, if you formed your opinion based on other sources. Yeah. What are those sources? And gimme a summary of the political leanings or Yeah. Of the types of things that those sources [00:20:00] report on. And you can get an idea of whether, , the information you're getting from that. , Ai, LLM, .
ChristineWhat's LLM mean? ,
HughLarge language model. , Sorry. That's, , chat. GPT, Claude. Those are large language model. , They're sort of chatbots that you can access a large language model. So does it means
Christinesomething different legally? You can get an LLM.
HughOh, yeah. No, no, that's true. I, yeah, so if you're, if you're getting a strong answer or something and you ask its sources, you may find that all of the information that's out there. Is from a small handful of people who all feel the same way about something. And that's, that's how search engines, that's how, I mean, people talk about AI being manipulated in that way. Yeah. But search engines are the same way.
ChristineWikipedia.
HughYeah. Or Google. If you Google something, it's going to give you answers based on what's there. It's not going to, you know, before it wouldn't make things up. For the most part, AI is not making stuff up. It's just hall hallucinating, a different way, hallucinating. [00:21:00] It's just looking at the stuff that's out there the same way a search engine does it. It's just thinking about it and communicating it back to you a little bit differently. I mean, it's just a glorified version of a search engine. Yeah. When you are using it in the way that we're talking about, there are things that it can do that's, you know, very different than a search engine, but when you're searching things, just know that what it's feeding you may be. All that's out there.
ChristineYeah.
HughBut it may not be unbiased, it may not be looking at a broad source of things , and just asking it where it got its information could be, , and if you go into your attorney and say, well, Tet EPT tells me we should be doing it this way, but it did get, it, got that opinion from only one or two places.
ChristineYeah. I mean, that's interesting. I, you know, I'm really scared of AI in a lot of ways. , That being said, you know, I utilize it and I do think it's gonna be a tool in the toolbox that attorneys are gonna have to use. You're gonna see attorneys really push back and you should be weary of that. , I do think, you know, it, , it's gonna change the profession. , And I think billable hours [00:22:00] for family court need to go.
HughYeah. , I agree with that. Having, you know, having made my career on billable hours. But you, you're kind of forced to. Yeah. You don't, I mean, we've, we've heard stories. , We've sat down and talked to people that have tried to buck the hourly. Billing stuff and even I work for
Christinea firm. Yeah, yeah.
HughAnd bar associations go after 'em. It's, I mean, it's ingrained in the system that this is how you have to do it and it's, and it's one of the big reasons that people are going to fight against deficiency. But I mean,
ChristineI think it's too late. Like I think they fought it too much. It's coming. People are gonna use that for sure. You know?
HughBut let, let's think about this. Even if you're not using it for legal research or you're not exposing it to any client information, and there's this whole. There's a way that you can do it. 'cause hospitals are using AI for everything and they're protected by more stringent rules than attorneys. There are ways to do it. Now, you could screw it up really badly if you don't know those ways and you're not trained in it. But when you're talking about just. Inbox management, phone call management, client, [00:23:00] you know, getting things out and like just having routines that cut down on. People are gonna see a 0.3 from a paralegal to send an email. Yeah. Oh, it can be automated. Save people a ton of money. And then you, you, you don't get into the AI screwing things up in the legal case, there's so many ways that it can be used that aren't, no one could even question the value of that they're gonna fight back against because it costs the firms money.
ChristineYeah. And they're gonna fight back in a way that's gonna ultimately hurt the legal profession. And I'm much more interested in how it can help the litigant and the pro se person. Sure. And you wanna find an attorney that can do both. And we will wrap up and I will. Say, , I lost, I'm adamant in my position, but I did lose, I've lost the poll. I've lost one of my longtime followers and fans. April. I'm just kidding. Thank you for your feedback. ,
HughThank you April. Thank you. People prefer my new favorite person
ChristineZoom court. And I mean, I am saying it's the beginning of the end for me, but I, you know, it won't be the first time I've been wrong, but yes. Overwhelming and we [00:24:00] want. Guys, get up in the comments. Just be respectful. Like, just, you know, but get in the comments. Tell us what you think, tell us what you want us to fight about. , So first and only time Berro has won. Cheers. Yeah, cheers on our little sparkling waters. Cheer all. We'll be back and we're gonna talk about just some wild case that happened in Kentucky where I think attorneys, GAls, everybody made a mistake probably.
HughYep. I, we probably aren't gonna fight much on that
ChristineLOL. All right, bye y'all. Oh Judgey judge y.com
HughPeace.
SpeakerYeah. Yeah. We need some. Justice. Justin found justice.