Episode 26
Wronging Rights

About this episode
Episode 26: Wronging Rights – The JudgeMental Podcast In this powerful episode, hosts Hugh and Christine dive deep into the complexities of family law, judicial accountability, and the controversial role of court-appointed experts. Joined by special guest Josh from Orange County, they explore the real-life impact of custodial evaluations, the financial and emotional toll on families, and the systemic issues that persist in the courts. Key Topics: Josh’s personal journey through the family court system and his fight for justice The challenges and pitfalls of court-appointed experts and custodial evaluations Why judicial transparency and accountability matter more than ever The emotional and financial costs of protracted litigation Honest reflections from two experienced lawyers on what needs to change in the system Highlights: Candid discussion on the “money grab” of expert appointments and the lack of scientific standards in evaluations The human side of family law: trauma, resilience, and the struggle to keep fighting for what’s right Open dialogue about the brokenness of the system and the importance of not giving up Call to Action: Have you experienced a custodial evaluation or have insights to share? The hosts are seeking stories, reports, and itemized bills—especially those involving Dr. Kelli Marvin, Kristen McCreary, or Dr. Kathryn Berla. Email your experiences to millertimelouisville@gmail.com or submit your story at judge-y.com. Tune in for an honest, unfiltered conversation that aims to spark change and support those navigating the family court system. Don’t forget: you’re not alone, and your voice matters. Listen now and join the conversation!
Transcript
6,613 words · about 29 minutes to read. Automatically transcribed and lightly edited; speaker labels are approximate.
Hugh[00:00:00] This right needs to be wronged. I mean, wrong needs to be righted. I wanna address this in justice, please let me do it.
ChristineAll right. Welcome to the Judgmental podcast. This is the after show, I guess, but we are just gonna follow up on our interview from Josh from Orange County. So, Hugh, what'd you think? That's your first time meeting you, I mean, meeting you? Yeah, meeting Josh.
HughOh, I, I really enjoyed hearing his story. I can't imagine what it was like to go through, , I'm glad ultimately the judge made the right decision. I know that it's probably been your experience as well, but in my, in my experience, challenging someone that the court has appointed almost never bears any fruit. I think it's helpful that they have a built in process for challenging it. And it's not something you're just sort of doing you know, as part of the litigation strategy. I'm so [00:01:00] happy to hear that another evaluator came in and would just say, this was done all poorly for all of these reasons. And the court will look at it and say, yep, I know that I appointed this person, but this is a faulty report and I'm not going to give it any weight.
ChristineAbsolutely. Now what I will say, and obviously, you know, when we have pro se people or litigants talking about their cases, I am not a hundred percent sure if the 7 31 is actually built into the system or if that's just their version of like, our version of an AOC form. I actually don't think. He was completely accurate that the person comes from a roster on the 7 31. Okay. Alright. But now that you could look at that two ways. Like what if the court just has it built in that you can dispute a seven 30 evaluation, which is just a guaranteed money grab for parents. So you could look at it both ways.
HughYeah, no, I mean, but it's, I mean. [00:02:00] It is that way anywhere. Even if you don't have that built in, you know that, you know this is, this is an expert who's going to testify this way. They have a report, they're gonna defend that report. You have to make a decision as a litigant, whether or not you want to spend money to do some sort of a counter report and look through everything. And sometimes when you're doing that. Boy, I have run into issues where I've had a court appointed expert who will be very protected of his or her files and will refuse to give copies to my expert. And I've had to, I've had to go to court and get court, you know, get a court order that they turn over the things so that I, that I can do, you know, my investigation and then you think, well. The court is gonna see their behavior, that they're trying to protect things and, and all of this. And then you get to court and you, you challenge it, you point out all of the errors, all the, the factual problems with the report, all of the tests that were done incorrectly. And then the, the rebuttal reports given no weight. And, and the court's just so often [00:03:00] side with the person that they appoint on all these cases.
ChristineYeah, that's so infuriating, and that's why I think I adamantly believe, I think if there's one fundamental change, we get rid of these court appointed experts. Now, this is America, so you're allowed to hire 27 experts if you want to, but they shouldn't be court appointed because that appointment comes with immunity and that appointment comes with, you're my buddy, you're my pal. And the judge, I've never read a custodial evaluation that I thought was legit. For the purposes of actually being science, yada, yada, you know what I mean?
HughYeah. I mean, I've, I've seen some, I won't say every single one has been bad. There, there were, there were a couple evaluators that I used for a while. Generally, people that want to do a good, thorough job and stay unbiased often to, they get attacked a lot and they don't stay in the business too long. They mm-hmm. You know, the, a lot of these people also have private practices, and if you are getting [00:04:00] terrible, nasty reviews every time you, you do an honest custodial evaluation, it's gonna affect your private practice. It could affect your insurance rates and a lot of people just don't wanna do it. But I, I, I will say that I've read ones that are very thorough, where I, I've even had some that went against my client. And the clients said, well, I've learned a lot from this process. They've pointed out a lot of things that I didn't realize I needed to work on. Like people that really engage and the clients both feel like they were listened to. I, I have seen some of those. It's been few, very few, a very small percentage, but I, I have seen those.
ChristineAgain, though, if you think, and I'm just gonna agree, we can agree to disagree, but it's one thing if you wanna go to therapy for the end of time and you wanna get evaluated and you wanna read this and you wanna read your astrology and you wanna, you know better yourself, and I'm all for bettering yourself, but the scientific. Component is where I just, you know what I'm saying? Yep. Like when it comes to criminal court and you're talking [00:05:00] about ballistics or you're talking about, you know, like knife wounds. There isn't a scientific measure that, in my opinion, that can predict a person's ability to parent that correlates with the best interest child for the court of law purposes. That's my point. No, and I think it is just a money grab.
HughYeah. I, I mean. It, it's interesting to me that when you read these reports, they're usually a collection of findings from very specific reports that look for certain personality And the reports themselves refer to the report, the final report or the interim report, which is where a lot of cases end because people don't wanna pay for the full report. It's just a lot of reference to these individual indexes where they're testing for one thing or another, and. You're correct. You don't have these, there's not a, a written or oral test you can give to someone and it's gonna predict whether or not you're gonna be a good parent. So what you're relying [00:06:00] on is these professionals to interpret, you know, read the tea leaves, interpret these tests that are not necessarily made for this process. They're made for testing for one or two specific things. So ultimately they've got discretion in which tests they use. Which personality traits they're going to test for, but then they're interpreting them because as you said, there's not one. Very specific test for it. Now, I,
ChristineI now, hold, hold on real quick though. Like, because you just said there's not a test for a good parent, good parents, not the standard, that's not the legal standard. So you could have two parents that aren't quote unquote good, but we don't believe that the state should take those children. Now, I'm not talking, I mean, I,
HughI agree. I, I think I was saying, I was just talking in general generalities instead of getting lost in the details as I, I tend to do, you're right. You're right, the standard is not good parent or who's the best parent that is. That is an important distinction.
ChristineWell, and another reason I say that too, and I love like reading the [00:07:00] tea leaves because essentially I think that's what they're doing. Is, it's just like they're just grasping at straws, throwing something to the wall to see what sticks. It's taking years off of a kid's life as far as like the money and the kid's life in the interim while this custodial evaluation is happening.
HughSo I, I, I disagree a little bit from my experience. I don't think they're grasping straws and throwing things against the wall. I think they really believe what they are saying because I've seen how hard. They defend their work and it's either that or they really believe in their defending their reputation no matter what happened or, yeah, defending their reputation with the courts because they're gonna continue to get the appointments. Now, as far as it being a money grab, I think from the side of any court appointed professional, there is a huge interest to do things in a certain way so that you can continue the money coming and the appointments coming. And during my 20 years of practice in family [00:08:00] court. I saw the cost of a custodial evaluation go up by five to 10 fold, and it really didn't, there wasn't much of a difference otherwise than you didn't spend nearly as much one-on-one time or actual in-person time with the evaluator. I, and I've seen plenty of, I've seen evaluations where, you know, at, at one point we were suspicious of a particular evaluator in town. And, you know, a group of attorneys got together and sort of anonymized some of the reports and compared them and it was clear that they were just based on a template with some names and facts and things changed. And I mean, that, that was appalling. But I, I think from, from,
Christineis that person still on evaluator? You don't have to say the name.
HughNo. Okay. There. I I, I think from a judge's point of view, right, when you have the best interest standard, there is this list of things you have to have considered and [00:09:00] you've been in court. You know how limited the time that we get in trial, I mean, one of the things. That Josh was talking about that kind of blew my mind was that this evaluator testified for three days, which means the judge just had a rolling amount of time and was gonna just keep going until the case was done. That has never been my experience in any court I've ever practiced, and that's, that's pretty amazing that they have that kind of time. Most of the time you don't, and most of the time the litigants. Are going to present, you know, the most pressing, the most what, what they consider to be the flashiest, most influential pieces of evidence. But from a court, you gotta look at a lot of factors under the best interest. I can understand the inclination to say, well, you know, if I hired this person to do this huge report, I can, I can just take notice of this report and accept it into the record. And it makes all of these factual findings that I don't have to actually get from the parties. I, I don't have to, I don't have to make people prove their case. It does my work for me. That's, it's not a money grab that's [00:10:00] getting, getting, you know, the judges aren't getting paid more from doing them, but they are getting Well, I
Christineunderstand. Stay in the inclination of being lazy and delegating your job. I mean, I wanna do that. That's what everyone wants to do. That's the American dream. But it, you know, I just, I can't, sometimes it's like, it's astonishing to me that some of the people, I'm not naming the names that we use as FOCs gals, custodial evaluators. I want every single attorney listening and every judge a listening. I want you to imagine that that is your child, your children, or your best friend's, child or children. And if you think they have the wherewithal and the skills to make decisions, then you need to immediately, and I wanna be clear immediately, give up your law license and start bartending and make me a good cocktail. I'll tip you well because you don't have enough sense to come in out of the rain.
HughI, I think. [00:11:00] I, I mean, to, from my point of view, I'm trying to, I'm trying to create an analogy in another part of law where if I'm going to sue you, right? And I'm gonna accuse you of something, and this is one of the things that was impactful from Josh's story to me, because I've seen it happen. I've, I've represented, you know, wealthy people in high asset cases and oftentimes represented the wage earner or the, the person that had the control of the finances. It doesn't matter who's suing whom in civil court. If I'm making allegations against you, what are the chances I'm gonna have a judge appoint someone to prove my case and make you pay for it? That would never happen. Never happen. Why is it happen in family court if one party's going to, I think that's, yeah. And then why do they get to keep doing it?
ChristineYep. And it's like, well another analogy when he was saying that, I remember, and you don't know this, but people that watch, oh, you may, I don't think you do, but Real Housewives of Atlanta they're, they were going to family court and there's an attorney there [00:12:00] that was like, you're gonna go in front of a judge with a Birkin, like you drive a, you, you carry a bag that's nicer than their car, they're gonna hate you. And I do think that there is some resentment from these judges Oh yeah. Who are really, really, really high earners. And so they're just like, well, whatever. You've got it. But I mean, my gosh. And Hugh I know you, you would sell your house for your children. Yeah. No question. Oh, yeah. To fight for your kids.
HughOh, yeah. No, no, no. Every, everything that he said was like, yep. That's, I mean, that's, what else are you gonna do? And, you know, that's what lots of people are doing because that's what you do for your kids. Mm-hmm. Like you go live on the street. I've actually had people that were living out of their car because they've sold everything , in the litigation process. And these are people that had. You know, $700,000 house and it was just to keep it going, to keep that fight up. 'cause they wouldn't give up on, you know, parenting their kids and that, that happens. But I, I've also experienced, as you were just describing when, so, so I think this is common among people, not just judges, that if, if you make [00:13:00] $50,000 a year, you think someone making a hundred thousand dollars a year just must have tons of money all, all over the place. Likewise, you reach six figures. You look at people earning seven figures and just think, oh. They could just pay for anything and everything, and you don't account for the fact that lifestyles eat up the money and there's just, you know, it, it doesn't necessarily mean you just have mountains of cash sitting around, but that, there's just this impression that people have. And man, that's such a successful tactic in family court. You go in and. Even if, I mean, even if it, it, it benefited the family, it's never been an issue. No one has done anything wrong with any money or whatever. The first thing you do, if you have the financially disadvantaged party is you go in and it's like, oh, look at all this money he or she makes over there and like all of this, and you set the tone for the judge to resent it and so that you get granted attorney's fees or they have to pay for everything as it goes along. And it, I mean, you see it every day. In fact, probably, I guarantee if you went, sat in, [00:14:00] sat in court in a motion hour and one day, you'd see it multiple times because it's successful and it stinks, but it works.
ChristineOh, yep. I saw it yesterday when I was in motion hour. It was like, you know, just some medical bills for something. And not to say just some medical bills, but that's where it gets like super weird and I'm like watching me in real time and like, obviously we've said this before, listeners, I was by, by no means. The high asset attorney, I did not practice nearly as long as Hugh. I am not, I would consider myself more knowledgeable in criminal law than family law, despite the fact I practiced there for 10 years. But you, you name a case, you had a fact pattern like that over 20 years, period. End of stories, like you've seen it all. You know what I mean? And so going, it's very different. I guess from my perspective, what I saw, because I didn't do protracted litigation high asset litigation and divorces very often because I didn't, you need to have a firm that has two paralegals and three other attorneys that can cover, [00:15:00] which you had.
HughOh, oh yeah. Absolutely. Yeah. You, you have to have a certain type of team to, to be able to do it.
ChristineAnd there's nothing wrong with that, but I guess the point at all, like you need that. But the point I'm trying to make is like watching in real time, just like there are so many like little moving pieces and then like one big machine where attorneys, we have to represent our clients to our best interest. That's right. We don't lie, but we have to represent our clients to the best interest. And if you have judges that are gonna allow these nonsensical arguments to success. They're made in good faith. I mean, it's really a struggle is what I'm trying to say.
HughNo, I agree. And when, when I began practicing one thing that was common and I, I never thought it was good business practice. In fact, it burned me quite a few times, but it was pretty regular that a, People would come speak to me. They didn't have a lot of money to pay for services, and they had been told by the first three people they interviewed that, oh, don't worry about it. I'll get, I'll make the other side pay. And you know, I, so I, of course represented people that were financially [00:16:00] disadvantaged all the time. Oh yeah. Even toward the latter part of my career. And, I always made people pay me. I never said that it's a guarantee the other side's going to pay, but when you have a certain person come in, doesn't matter which side it's on. If your person's financially dis disadvantaged and the other side just is sitting on a mountain of cash, you can just see 10 arguments to make them pay for everything and you know that it's gonna be okay. You know that just, and, and as he, you know, as Josh said in his interview, they were trying to bankrupt him to make him stop. And that's a real tactic. It happens all the time. You make them pay to keep fighting and sometimes it's used for good. Sometimes it's, you know, judges. I've seen judges do it when they suspect or they, they kind of know, but can't, you know, haven't had a hearing, can't make a finding that one parent is causing all of the litigation. And it's not really about any major thing. Like, it sounds like may have happened, at least the, the Josh feels happened to his case. We haven't spoken to both sides, so I don't wanna say that's what happened in this case, but it, you know, we, we've seen that as [00:17:00] practitioners, you see that happen. One side will be. Just is never going to let something go. They're gonna keep making allegations. They're just never going to have a good co-parenting relationship. I have seen judges be very smart in making the person that's doing that pay for everything and said, if you wanna keep doing this, you're going to keep paying for it. And maybe if it, if you really are proved right, I can allocate these things. But you know, sometimes I've seen it, I've seen it. Being used to sort of calm down the level of, of litigation. But certainly practitioners use it all the time. Just, we're just gonna it this So expensive. Yeah. Discovery tactics. You know, somebody doesn't have much money. They're not paying, they haven't paid a big retainer. They, they hired an attorney, you know, doesn't charge much and you just file a bunch of discovery so that they sort of cave. I mean, it's just, that's just litigation. That's how it's been and that's how it is in all, all types of
ChristineWell, two things there. I actually don't think that judges try to [00:18:00] utilize money to get a resolution though, in other areas of the law and hear me out. Like I don't think, I think family court like kind of encourages conflict and there's the money component to it, like in. Criminal court. I don't think that the judge is encouraging the conflict, if that makes sense. And it's not like the criminal attorney makes more money if it goes on longer or the prosecutor makes more money if it goes on longer. And in civil court, I don't necessarily think that there is this frustration that comes with filing motions like we know our family court judges will be like, seriously, Hugh, you back here again, this case again? Oh, I encountered that
Hughin civil court. Are you kidding? I, I never did. I would file, but I didn't do much file motions. Yeah, the, and I didn't do a whole lot, but when I did, you could tell that there was just sort of this unwritten rule that you don't do this or do that. And I would file motions really, because my duty is to go and officially ask for this. And I need to represent my clients. I want it [00:19:00] on paper. I want the record to show that I tried this, I followed this rule, I went through this. Yeah. And a lot of people, you know, it's a lot more, less formal than that, and they'll just call each other and get these things done. I would file it and people would lose their minds. I've, I've had people threaten sanctions because I filed. Motions that were you know, motions to dispose of part of the record because I met the requirements for it and I could dispose of a big part of the, the case that the person was coming after my client in a civil case, and they would, oh my God, I can't believe you would do this. Like, I've violated some common courtesy. So , I, I've definitely seen people react that way to pa, you know, to filing regular motions. But you're right, I mean. Family law is different. It's evolving. I mean, usually in a case in civil court, you have a cause of action. The cause of action has already happened and it's not evolving. Now, there could be some contract disputes where there are things going on. You might need injunctions to keep things from getting worse. So it's not that they never evolve, but you [00:20:00] guarantee that in family law, things are evolving and changing all the time. Mm-hmm. In every single case.
ChristineYeah, I mean, that's a good point. And that's why, you know, I, I, I don't know what the answer of the answer to fixing the problems in family court is above my pay grade. Mm-hmm. I just know that this isn't working, and I do think that we are getting progressively worse. Like there was one thing during the interview with Josh where you were like, there's a lot of attorneys out there, and I say that too. I'm not trying to say that in any way to make. Any assumption, like I'm like, there's so many attorneys that I talk to that don't like these judges, that don't like, and by like I mean like the procedures and like the way things are going, they don't believe in these custodial evaluators. But the reality is, when I was in Orange County, it was. It was just different. It was this feel, and I think they drove you out of family law. They drove, I went sprinting into the wall like a fucking character in a cartoon to get out of family court with you know, no intention of coming back. And you were, [00:21:00] I'm talking to people all the time that are just like, you know, I can't do this anymore. And I think what happens when the system keeps growing and growing like it is in california and Colorado is they get rid of all the attorneys that really give a damn.
HughYeah. I, I mean, there are a lot of people, and I, I'm not gonna name names. There are people that well, hell, it's, it's a lot of the people that you and I know in common and that, that that practice in family law in Kentucky, I've had conversations with them that, you know, things are broken. I mean, it's regularly accepted. People still have to keep. Pr. I mean that's what they do for a living. They have to keep working within the system. I think there is a difference between recognizing that it's broken and some are actively wanting to keep it broken ' cause it benefits them while others are. Not actively working to change things because that would actually hurt, you know, hurt their business. And they have a business and they have clients that they have to, you know, that there's all these, there's all of these competing interests there from representing your client, [00:22:00] not making the judge angry for if you have partners in your business not doing something that harms the business. So, I mean, I, I can kind of get that, but in my experience is that the. The, the most of the people that I litigated against regularly, we had very frank conversations about the problems and how, how things work from custodial evaluators to, you know, how it's gonna go in this division. It's just openly accepted. But I think a lot of litigators who, you know, they face, at least I did the way, the way they worked when I practiced it was my job to figure out where those problems were and to navigate them. So when I'm representing my client, it's not to solve the problem, it's to keep my client from being harmed by that problem. And I think that that's, if you're still regularly engaged in the practice, that's that's what you have to do. It's sort of your ethical duty, and that's a separate from whether or not they actually accept that there is a problem.
ChristineYeah, I feel like I was rude there. I was just scrolling 'cause we got this really profound question. I meant to screenshot it and send it to you. I can't find it 'cause we [00:23:00] get so many. But it was asking exactly what you're saying, like how do people continue to keep doing this? And you know, the reality is. You know, I mean, when I left, I struggled financially. I just couldn't do it anymore. But people, this is how you know we're in student loans. A lot of people in family court have significant student loans. This is the area of law that they know. I mean, you don't just quit your job because. You want to, you know what I'm saying? No. And so it's a really hard dichotomy and I do, you know, I go back and forth with lawyers, as you know. I'm currently on a break right now from family lawyers. And just to be clear, that's because I'm not giving litigants. They can't call me in tram dump because I'm not a therapist. I don't have anywhere to store it. And I'm sick and tired of a lot of the lawyers calling me to trauma dump. I don't have anywhere to store it. They need to fight these battles themselves. And they're lawyers. They're stronger than litigants. In the capacity of this, this, of solving problem arena. Addressing
Hughit. Yeah. No.
ChristineYeah, yeah, yeah. But I digress. But so it's just [00:24:00] like, I don't know what the answer is, but it's getting progressively worse. And I'm not trying to like blow a whistle, but I felt like the other day when we were recording, you were like, holy moly. Like you were almost like, yeah, this is really bad. Like some of the things that they're moving towards.
HughYeah, I know that's what, that's what scares me. And it's, it's hard to navigate how I want to keep fighting this fight, you know, and not make things, make things worse. And I think the, the way to do, it's just to keep calling it out. To say mm-hmm. In reaction to this, you shouldn't make matters worse. You should actually work to fix the problem to those that are actually listening and paying attention to, to those of us out here that are pointing out the problems. I wanna say also though, there's, there's another part to the answer, I think to that, that question from, you know, from a viewer, I think there are people that really want to help their clients. I think people get into family law. You don't, when you're in law school. You sample a lot of different types of law. There's [00:25:00] something different about family law. It is not just making sure forms are filled out correct correctly, or some laws are complied with. It is not litigation just for the game of litigation. People gen generally get into family law if, if it's, if it's the intentional way they started their journey and they wanna be a career family lawyer because it appeals to them because there is the human side to it. That doesn't exist in a lot of other places. So I think there are. A lot of people that are still out there doing it, they're doing it in a broken system and they're fighting as hard as they can for their clients and they still believe that they're doing, you know, they're doing their duty for their clients, but they, like I said, you have to navigate the problems where they are.
ChristineYep.
HughYeah, so I, I mean, I think that's, that's a big part of it. There are people who just, I mean, it eats them alive. The number of people I know that are popping pills to deal with the stress of representing their clients because we take that trauma home as attorneys. Mm-hmm. It was pretty staggering to me. Rough. Yeah. [00:26:00] It's pretty widespread.
ChristineIt's really rough and for people listening and if Hugh wants to cut this out, but there is this constant, we have a lot of conversations, obviously behind the scenes, but you know, in particular in talking to Hugh High asset attorney, there are several cases that he talks about. Almost once a week that have traumatized him. Oh yeah. That he still carries. Or cases where he begged people like, I will represent you for free. Yes. This issue is wrong. Like, and not to name names or anything like that. And there are cases, I still have clients that reach out and yeah, I mean the trauma, you know, the trauma of. Just, and you want, you know, when I was working for my clients too, there was so much good and resolve that I was able to get, and I do miss practicing law immensely. So it is a catch 22. You know, I'm constantly, you know, every, this isn't linear, this is complicated, and we constantly kind of go through these circles or these up and downs of like what the answer is.
HughYeah. No, that's right. Yeah. And you're [00:27:00] right about the ones I keep coming back to, they are the ones that I just. I absolutely hate what happened to the family. And you're right, there were, there were,
Christineand they keep you up at night. A couple, a couple times where
HughI said, I will take this too, all the way to the end if you have no money, no big deal. I want, I want to do this. Mm-hmm. This right needs to be wronged. I mean, wrong needs to be righted. I wanna address this in justice, please let me do it. And sometimes people are just too fatigued and just like, no, I give up and they walk away and you just think. How, you know, some laziness or some just, oh gosh. Some of them I know were just heirs, that were just, they were just political and they were, they were so easily correctable, but they, they, mm-hmm. They occurred at the end of such a long, expensive battle that people just give up and they give up. Yep. And they walk away from. Their rights, their property, all kinds of things. Usually. I mean, the ones that always, that haunt me, that I talk about are always kids cases. It's, you know, there's not a single case that I can even think of that involve [00:28:00] pieces of property that, you know, was super impactful, that went a certain way. But the, the kids stuff, it's. Yeah, there's, there's quite a few of 'em I won't get over. Yeah, that's right.
ChristineAnd it is you, it bothers you still to this day. And it's like, when I have people, the other hard thing is it's hard to take this hat off. Right? This lawyer hat off. And so we get all these messages and you know, I do all, most of our social media. All of our social media and like, just in this conversation, it's like, help me in Georgia, help me in, you know. And you wanna put, even talking to Josh, you wanna put your lawyer hat on? Oh yeah. And be a lawyer. Oh yeah. But you, it's, you can't do that anymore because you just can't do that anymore. And so it's a really weird place to navigate. And I do wanna hit on one thing that we're gonna get when you're listening to this we're gonna get hate and we already know. So. Not in hate because we chose to have some people on and not other people. Yo, we are very grassroots. We're trying to get judgy going. [00:29:00] We can't have everyone on to just tell their stories always. It would be. We wouldn't sleep. There's not enough hours in the day.
HughNo.
ChristineAnd on the flip side of that, I want you to be clear, we can't vet everyone thoroughly that we have on or that we talk to or that I comment on, on social media because spoiler alert, y'all don't have cameras in your courtrooms for the most part. And vetting would involve talking to the other party extensively. So we just need to, you know, I wanna be clear on this podcast. We are having conversations, we are opening dialogue if we like something on social media or if we have someone on, we are not a blanket adoption of everything that that person said or didn't say. And I know we've only had two guests on, but if we open this up and I don't know if there's anything you wanna add or if I said that clear enough.
HughNo, I, I think that that's, that's pretty clear. I, I think we, we've. The number of people that have reached out, we could just do a show that's interviews and do multiples every single day and still [00:30:00] not get to get to half of 'em or 10th of them. Yeah. You know, part of what we're trying to do isn't necessarily telling stories. I think that there have been certain aspects, you know, people that we have, people that we have scheduled that are gonna come on, people that, you know. There's something that we're already talking about. It's already part of a discussion. The custodial evaluation element of Josh's case was the focus, and that's something that is, is a big problem that we see here in Kentucky. It was, it's fascinating to figure out exactly what's happening in another state where it's, where it's the same, where it's different. And there were just a few elements of his case actually, not just a few. There are a lot of elements in his case that you and I have seen. Many times in our practice that people are telling us about every single day, and it just seemed very representative. Plus, you don't get a chance to talk to someone who's come out of it and challenged, you know, what's going on in the system. And he was only able to do it because he was able to access [00:31:00] capital to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars to do it most, you know? Mm-hmm. Great, great, great. Majority of people would've had to have given up. And just, yep. Just walked away. And, and, and he was able to do it because he was fortunate enough to have a good job and, and access to take loans. So I, I don't know. And
ChristineFaye, and I think his, his resolve at the end where he Yeah. Begs everyone just keep going. I mean, it was like, it's emotional.
HughOh yeah. Yeah. That absolutely. And I just, I, you know, not been through it, but I've got kids and I know that, I don't even like to think about if I were in that position. I mean, it's, it's really I, I'm amazed that people handle it as well as they do. But talk about a dark place. Yeah.
Christinesame z And so we're gonna keep grinding and talking to people. We really want, right now, I am doing in particular or we are, but like we want custodial evaluations or your state's equivalent. We would like evaluations or reports or any of that [00:32:00] that have been done by Dr. Kelli Marvin or Kristen McCreary, or Dr. Kathryn Berla. We want bills from custodial evaluations or the equivalent in your state itemized bills. Any kind of bill, please email them. It's Miller time Louisville at gmail. Always submit your stories to judge y.com. You got any profound statements after that interview?
HughNo, I, I mean, what can I say that he didn't say? Yeah, just don't give up if you're stuck in the system. Don't give up. Mm-hmm. Keep fighting.
ChristineAnd we we're trying to open these conversations so everybody you know can see that you're not crazy. The system is, I guess.
HughYep. Well said. All right. Thanks everybody. Peace.
Speaker[00:33:00] Yeah. Yeah. We need some. Justice. Justin found justice.