Judge-yGet the app

Episode 12

Two out of Four Ain't Bad?

The JudgeMental Podcast43 minFull transcript

EP 12 Two out of Four Ain't Bad?
Watch on YouTube

About this episode

The Judgmental Podcast – Two out of Four Ain't Bad? Hosts: Hugh & Christine Episode Summary: In this episode, Hugh and Christine dive deep into the realities of judicial accountability and transparency in the court system. They discuss their recent “judicial roll call,” revealing surprising statistics about judge attendance and courtroom activity. The hosts share candid insights on the challenges of family court, the roles of GALs (Guardians ad Litem) and FOCs (Friends of the Court), and the systemic issues that arise from overworked court-appointed professionals. Key Topics: Judicial roll call results: attendance rates and what they reveal about court operations. The workload and expectations of judges, including public salary transparency and vacation policies. The influence and accountability of GALs and FOCs, and the difficulty in tracking their appointments. The “path of least resistance” in court: how reports and recommendations shape outcomes. The importance of public records, campaign donations, and the need for greater transparency. Reflections on the challenges of filing judicial complaints and the effectiveness of oversight bodies. A featured “clip of the week” analyzing a judge’s reaction to a guilty plea in criminal court. The impact of social media and public perception on the judiciary. Notable Moments: Shout-outs to judges who stood up for due process during the pandemic. Honest discussion about the realities of legal advocacy, client strategy, and the limits of the system. Calls to action for listeners to get involved, stay informed, and demand transparency from their courts. Connect with Us: Website: judge-y.com Instagram: @kentuckychristine YouTube: Judging the Judges Subscribe, share, and join the conversation as we continue to shine a light on the people and processes shaping our justice system!

Transcript

8,551 words · about 37 minutes to read. Automatically transcribed and lightly edited; speaker labels are approximate.

Christine[00:00:00] I think it's just bizarre sometimes that we're like, clap, clap, clap, clap. You did your job. You know what I mean? Like,

Hughwell, that's, that, that's how I felt today. I was like, wow, there's like half of half the family courts are open. Mm-hmm. And I, I just thought, oh, that's great. And then, yeah. Why is that great?

ChristineAll right. Welcome to the Judgmental podcast. We just did the judicial roll call, July 31st. Thank you. Michael Sternberg, out of Nevada. He's an advocate for family court reform. He suggested the time. How many were there?

HughFamily court. Five. We had seven over at district court and we had nine in circuit court.

ChristineYep. So it's 21 out of 39, which is a little bit more than 50%.

HughYep. It was exactly 50% of the family court.

ChristineYep. And I, I'm noticing a pattern. I feel like district court is [00:01:00] really like holding it down. Right? They, they seem to be the ones with the most judges. Most of the time,

Hughand it's usually one floor, one very busy floor. Yeah. Today it was, we had two busy floors. Each time we've been before, it's just been one floor with everyone on it, and the rest just looked dead.

ChristineYeah. And I do think that district court is really probably just operating at this capacity. So seven out of 16, I don't think the most we've ever seen was a Monday morning and we had, goodness, I think we had nine. Right?

HughYeah. , It was. I, I should have my phone. I have the notes, but it was shocking. It was, it was very busy.

ChristineYeah, but I mean, well, nine outta 16 is still barely more than 50%.

HughYeah. I, I did mention that while we were over, it's like, oh, this is a surprising number of judges. And I, I thought, how sick is that? Yeah. That it's surprising that we are a little over 50%. And I was, I was, it made me happy to see that many.

ChristineWell, and you gotta think like $6 million nearly in taxpayer salaries is what's paid to these judges, and I'm rounding up a little bit. But that being [00:02:00] said, if they're operating generally we've had as low as about 33% and we've had as much as 71%. Certainly. I think that's somewhat concerning.

HughA little bit concerning, but , I'm more concerned with, you know, I think you're getting those numbers from the, the writers of Project 2025

ChristineL-O-L-O-L. Yeah. Flashback Alison Russell. How you doing sweetheart? We would love to have you on the podcast if you're listening for the first time. We had a local Louisville litigator that insinuated that we were a part of Project 2025. We are not conspiracy theorist, although I'm leaning into a little bit independently as Kentucky Christine, which you love. LOL but truly we, there's nothing that we are doing in, we have no control over whether or not the judges go to work or have the courtrooms open. That's right. Right. Judgey is not giving them a heads up of when we're coming, but generally speaking, between the hours of, you know, nine 30 and four, I expect for the most [00:03:00] part, courtrooms to be open. That's my expectation. Say

Hughnine 30.

ChristineYeah. I know dockets sometimes start at eight 30.

HughMust be nice to start your day at nine 30.

ChristineRight? It's like, and then we have the judge that is doing the Judge Derwin Webb Division 10. We've talked about him previously. He is the judge that has done 64 podcasts and we are on, I think we're recording our 10th. I don't even know, honestly, we've published six and it is a full-time job.

Hugh. It's shocking. Yeah, I'm, I'm really surprised at how I'm finding time after hours, weekends, anytime where I have 15 minutes before my family goes somewhere, I run back and start doing some more editing. It is so much work.

ChristineIt is so much work. I mean, I would say we usually start texting each other between like seven and seven 30. And then I think usually it's like we're still working on stuff. One of us is at 10 30, 11, 12 at night. Absolutely. I mean, probably like 25, 26 days straight. And I love it. Don't get me wrong. I mean, and , this is our profession now. I mean, this is our [00:04:00] job. That being said, we, you know, Derwin Webb outta Division 10 is a full-time family court judge. I have no earthly idea how he's had the time to do this. Maybe that's why people are waiting on orders now. He was in court today. He had a

Hughbusy docket.

ChristineYeah, there were about six or seven, maybe eight people outside and we ran into one of the notorious GALs, FOC appointments. Did he say hi to you?

HughNo. Ignored me as if I didn't exist, but. I can't say that I, I was warm and fuzzy toward him as either, so.

ChristineFair.

HughYeah.

ChristineWe're talking about Jim Murphy, GAL and FOC. We talked about him significantly on two or three podcasts ago. He is a court appointed guardian ad litem in front of the court that is appointed on honestly, probably hundreds of cases.

HughIt's hard. I think I've heard from him. That's hundreds.

ChristineOh wow.

HughBut yeah,

Christineand so we can't get that information to you in [00:05:00] completely accurate. And the reason for that is the docket that we saw today where the judge was, is a confidential docket. So he is appointed as a GAL or FOC. He actually was coming outta the courtroom and asking to speak to two children, which were likely his clients. But there is no way to ascertain how many appointments he has on a confidential docket, at least that I'm aware of.

HughWell. Running his name through Court Net online, but you can't tell which ones are active.

ChristineWell, you, but you can only tell if you run his name up on court net. You'll only see the appointments for public records, not juvenile actions on the dependency, neglect, and abuse docket.

HughSo they don't even show up as a listing. Mm-hmm.

ChristineSo even if we can't get that information. Which Susan Bassi out of California is doing a lot of open records requests about how much some of the, they call 'em minor's counsel in California, how much they are billing and how many appointments they have. And I just think that for the sake of transparency, what's the problem in giving the public that information?

HughI would love to know.

ChristineYeah, I would love to know. We don't have to get the kids' [00:06:00] names or anything like that, but just, Hey, Jim Murphy was appointed to 372 cases this year as a GA or FOC.

HughYeah, I mean, what what's always concerning to me is when. You know, children's counsel, GAL or FOC, the generally the same pool of people that do both appointments here in Kentucky and in especially in Jefferson County, they're sitting in the courtroom and the court will find a case where someone will say, we probably need an FOC or a GAL, and they'll scan the room and say, you know, for instance, Mr. Murphy, you available to take anything on, and you never hear anyone say, no, I'm, I'm busy. I, I really don't have the capacity to take more on. It's always yes. Always. Yeah. I'll just take another. And you know that the cases that you have going on at that moment can't get any attention because there's way too much reliance on those people, and they have way too many cases.

ChristineIn fact, I've even seen attorneys take your advice strategically and try to be uber, uber polite. And Your honor, you know, Jim Murphy is great. That being said, I know how busy he is.

HughMm-hmm. [00:07:00]

ChristineAnd the judge is like, I'm doing it anyway.

HughOr they'll ask him, Mr. Murphy, you too busy to handle this. Oh, no, no, no, your Honor. I can handle it.

ChristineWhich we get so many complaints and we do have personal knowledge. This is not, the personal knowledge is not allegedly, but we have personal knowledge of cases that we have had where he has not met the child or children to our satisfaction. Right.

HughOr at all.

ChristineWhich I just, we go back to this all the time and I know everybody listening is, this is one of the hot button issues , but you cannot, in my opinion, represent your client without mating them.

HughWell, I mean, I think there are distinctions. So if you're FOC, you're not necessarily representing, you're not representing a client fact. If you're GAL mm-hmm. You are. Yeah. So if you're FOC or a fact witness, my issue is when a fact witness, an expert fact witness. Testifies about the children. So with the best interest of the child, all of these people have to act under the [00:08:00] law within the best interest of the child. And the best interest of the child is set out in Kentucky in KRS 403.270, and it lists a bunch of factors that you have to consider a judge has to consider. And one of the very first ones is the wishes of the child or children. Mm-hmm. And so I don't know how you can testify about the best interests of the child and talk about what the children want. If you haven't spoken with them

Christinechurch

Hughand you're not allowed to talk about what other people say the children want, that's hearsay. And there, there are exceptions to hearsay and there are certain exceptions that apply to FOC reports. Mm-hmm. But those are ignored and. Information, is obtained from third parties. Instead of going to the source and actually speaking with the children and speaking with the, they will find one person to get all the information from and report it as if they've done a full evaluation or a full investigation.

ChristineRight. And I think there is some argument to be made. That you have all of these people in [00:09:00] these custody or divorce actions, GAL's, FOCs, custodial evaluations, court appointed therapist. But we have something in the law called bolstering. And what can happen is like if you're in trial, you can't literally te have eight people testify to the exact same thing, like a jury case. Right. Is that your understanding of it?

HughIsh from, from, from an advocate point of view, I'll have as many people say the important stuff as I can until somebody tells me to shut up. But yeah, that it's bad practice.

ChristineWell, and I think that there is an objection to it. Sure. And you'll see it sustained in if someone makes it. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You'll see it in sustained in criminal. Cases all day, right? Yeah. Because there's also a standard that it has to be, it can't be more prejudicial than probative. And what that means is, you know, we can't have a trial where someone's on for a crime and we're gonna have eight days of just what a piece of shit this person is. Right. That is more prejudicial than probative. And also there are other exceptions. We could go down the rabbit hole of character, evidence, yada, yada. But what happens in these family court cases is when you have all of these experts and six or [00:10:00] seven people, it's a very small circle. We're appointing the same, typically court appointed therapists, the same pool of GALs FOCs, the same pool of custodial evaluators. A

Hughvery small pool. Yes, very small pool. A handful of people. And if you, for all of the cases,

Christineone of them on. To think a certain kinda way, they kind of all fall in line. Like if a custodial evaluator will be like, oh my gosh, this mom is alienating, then everybody will start writing their reports. Oh my gosh. Sure. It's alienation. Yep. There's really no independent thought. And what I mean by that is just like, are we just setting up a system to insulate itself from liability and for an abusive or toxic parent potentially to only have to manipulate? One player and then the rest of them just fall in line.

HughOh, from an advocate's point of view, I mean, it was always so critical for my clients. I, I would send them to a different custodial evaluator who did mostly forensic work to prepare for a meeting with the custodial evaluator because [00:11:00] that person will print out a report and so much of it is computer generated for most of those reports, but it looks like they have spent. You know, 50, a hundred hours writing it. And some of them then they do, some of them, there are so many psychological records and so many interviews., I've had cases where there's been hundreds of hours of, of interviews with people and things like that, the huge cases. But for the most part, the court looks at them as an expert. They have , the letters behind their names. And so what I always told my client is whatever they decided is. Highly likely, 90 plus percent of the time, well over 90% of the time, FOC is gonna fall in line. The GAL is gonna go along with it and the judge is gonna go all along with it. Mm-hmm. So, you know, as attorneys, we fight for our client's point of view. There are times that we know our clients are lying. And generally you can't continue to represent, you certainly can't put forth anything that you know isn't true. But from an attorney's point of view, you're hearing one side of the [00:12:00] story and you sort of know that. So you're. You're, you're trying to tell that side of the story and make it com as compelling as possible. And I always told my clients, you've, you've got to convince this person. Mm-hmm. Other people will rely on it.

ChristineYeah. And to break that down a little bit, that's the importance of hiring an attorney and utilizing strategy. So whenever we say the word forensic, essentially we just mean for court. I mean, in a forensic evaluator, like a forensic psychologist is just like a court psychologist. Like Yes. But what he did, and what I try to tell people all the time is you have to understand the game that you are participating in. And family court is extremely strategic. So he is prepping his client for what the custodial evaluator is gonna look like by sending. His client to somebody that's gonna prepare. Right?

HughSure.

ChristineAnd so that's like one avenue. So many people get into family court and by the time they realize what's happening, especially if they're pro se Oh, it's

Hughway too late.

ChristineWay too late.

HughWay too late. Mm-hmm. Especially with the custodial evaluators. I, I'd like, you know, on, on [00:13:00] my personal podcast, I'm gonna do a, a series about that because it's such an important piece of the family court system that exists right now. It's a broken piece, but it's. For people to understand how that system works, but the entire system reinforces itself, as you said, bolsters itself. Yep. So if I am an FOC, someone that is tasked by the court appointed to make a report over some factual circumstance, you know, investigate this, make a report to the court, and I have hundreds of cases and I'm overworked. The easiest thing to do would be to go along with what the custodial evaluator says because it's going to look reasonable. Mm-hmm. It's going to look, if you disagree, then you might get questioned about why you disagreed. You, you know, you're gonna have to work much, much harder to be able to back up your opinion. If you disagree with something in a custodial evaluator report, and if you're overworked and you're getting your appointments from that court, you don't want that to happen. You don't wanna be embarrassed. You don't want someone picking apart your opinion. [00:14:00] Path of least resistance is to go along with a custodial evaluation report. Same thing with a judge. If I'm a judge and I have thousands and thousands of cases, and a case is coming before me, and I have to determine you know, with a preponderance of evidence what the facts are in this case, going through someone who is, has much more time in the case than I would ever have as a, be able to have as a judge. I can see them looking and say, well, if I rely on this custodial evaluation right or wrong, I'm employed. I'm less likely to get appealed overturned on appeal because it's, that's a big piece of evidence.

ChristineWell, I also think too, it's not just to get an appeal. I think the system is designed to insulate itself from liability. So let's say, God forbid, something were to happen to a child which we all know is a possibility. It happens in this country and , the numbers, since family court has. Existed. The numbers of violence against children have only increased, which I think is something to look [00:15:00] at when you talk about the data. But they know that if a custodial evaluator comes back and says, this child should be with Dad, if they were to go against the custodial evaluator. And something happens, then the news is gonna run with it for days. If they follow the custodial evaluator and something happens, the judge can say, well, listen, I relied on this expert Yep. With 17 letters behind their name. So the system is designed to protect the judges from liability and judges are so, the only thing they want to do, a lot of judges wanna do, in my opinion, is to protect their power, protect them, as you know, so they have the ability to continue to be judge.

HughI don't, I think it's a huge generalization. I think as a judge. You have a giant mountain of work all the time, it's never gonna stop. You're never gonna be caught up. That's accepted. And even if you're coming to work and you're staying late, there's always more stuff coming through our courts. They're just, the system is set up [00:16:00] to develop habits on relying on people who then realize that you're not gonna get, they're not gonna get challenged. So they can, they can form their own biases and opinions and look at every single case the same way and run it through like it's a factory. And no one's probably going to read the full report. They're gonna look for the last page for the conclusion. And you know, the whole system just,

Christineyeah, I understand what you're saying, but imagine if you were an engineer at Ford and you were just like, well, I didn't have time to look at the full report. That kind of stuff. Oh, I agree. Is just not accepted in the private sector. It's unacceptable behavior. Oh, I,

HughI'm not defending it. I'm simply saying that I don't know that there's this, everybody's sitting there thinking, well, I'm gonna do this so I can stay in power. I, I think it's just the way that it's set up reinforces those efficient quote unquote efficiencies and. Shortcuts.

ChristineWell, they all seem to run [00:17:00] for reelection, you know, and we got, there's a couple Louisville attorneys that have been supportive on Facebook of the judges, obviously, in my opinion. I said obviously, but to just gain favor with the judges.

HughWell, but I mean, and also it's a huge generalization we've said on a previous podcast. I, I can think of examples right now of times where judges that I practice in front of a lot in Jefferson County would completely. End up marginalizing an FOC when the FOC got called out for getting some things wrong. No. Yeah. And then all they, they didn't rely on them. Yeah. They used their independent judgment. I also know,

Christinehave you seen it happen with a custodial evaluator though?

HughYes. But not in j Well,

Christineright. I didn't see

Hughin Jefferson County, I saw in Oldham County. I've seen a custodial evaluator come out very strongly on one side. And the facts were just incorrect in the evaluation, it took a, it took two full days of, of hearing, well, maybe two long half days of hearings, but completely ruled against the recommendations of the custodial [00:18:00] evaluation because. And I think that's the judge thought very critically and looked at the evidence.

ChristineNo, and I think that's absolutely great. But in 20 years of practice, you never saw a judge go against a custodial evaluator, statistically speaking. Yeah. In Jefferson County. Yes. Statistically speaking. Just think about that.

HughWell, and, and one of the more concerning things it were where you felt like it was. A system mm-hmm. Was when you would bring in someone to point out the glaring holes in a custodial evaluation report. Mm-hmm. To where for instance, in these custodial evaluation reports, oftentimes they will do certain personality tests. They will look for personality traits in the parties , to look at their ability to co-parent. Yeah. And. Oftentimes they're shortcut or they use something that should, you can't rely on this test to basically make a diagnosis for this, and you'll bring someone in to say, this is completely wrong, that you could not have determined this based on the limited testing that's done. But I, I don't know that I ever [00:19:00] saw, at least in Jefferson County, an evaluator or someone very credentialed come into critique an evaluator and it make any headway whatsoever. Right? Against the entrenched evaluators that are relied on. Here. Yep.

ChristineAnd they're also donating to judicial campaigns. They're allowed to do that. We know for a fact that Katherine Berla donated to Laura Russell's most recent campaign that's on KREF that is on my link tree. You can look and you should be looking when you. Go in front of a judge, you should absolutely be looking to see which a judge's, I mean, which attorneys have donated. There's

Hugha, there's a reason why that's public. Yes, yes, yes, yes. No one uses it, but you should.

ChristineYes. And I think that's just knowledge is power. Now I'm a proponent that that should not be allowed. And I think actually like attorneys are allowed to donate to judicial campaigns and I've done it. Y'all, me too. I mean, I've done it. It's wrong. I've worked on

Hughjudicial campaigns. Yeah.

ChristineI regret it. While I was practicing in front of them. I wouldn't do it again. I think we need to change the rules. But now attorneys are even different than these evaluators because these evaluators are expert [00:20:00] witnesses, and so that is a witness that is coming to testify before the court donating. That's a bigger problem, in my opinion. Well, both problematic.

HughI mean, think about it. I mean, the general public can donate to, are you disqualified if you have someone, yeah. Who's donated to your campaign? Oh, I think absolutely. That's sitting in front of you,

ChristineI think. Absolutely. But

Hughdoes anyone ever look.

ChristineI mean, I don't know. And I think absolutely that should happen. And again, just call to action to the general public. I'm gonna tell you, I'm taking meetings all the time with local leaders and people that are in politics. And that have tried to do advocacy work for bringing awareness to the judiciary. They really do think, the general consensus from people I've spoken to is that they think that the public is dumb and that the public won't pay attention to anything that happens with judges and that judges the incumbents will continue to run the show.

HughWell, that's politics in general. I don't think that applies just to judges. I think. That's most politicians. Well, it's

Christinenonpartisan. Oh, sure. And so I think though, this is the [00:21:00] feedback that I'm getting from the community. Like for example, no, I'm not kidding. If Craig Greenberg were to dance at a Christmas party with Mayor Craig Greenberg dropping it low bend over. To sexy red. That would be a bigger problem in the community. It would be because people know

Hughwho he is.

ChristineYeah. I mean, but we, how many? How many?

HughIf you've just stopped person on the street, we might want to do that and ask to name a judge.

ChristineYeah.

HughIn Jefferson County if they can name one. It's just, there's less interest in it if you don't know who the people are.

ChristineI think though that's a myth. Like I think there's a myth or that's been perpetuated that people don't care. You know, I could talk to , a wall, right when I'm in the community. Mm-hmm. I literally, every time I go get gas, I like show people the TikTok judge pictures like of her wearing the marijuana earrings or just like. Doing makeup and they'll be like, oh my gosh, my sister got a divorce. Oh my, I've been at the hair salon. And they'll be like, oh my God. That was my husband's

Hughjudge. Yeah. As soon as, as soon as I said no, no one knows. Once people have touched the court system, they don't forget and they remember everybody that was involved. 'cause it's a traumatic experience, so I, [00:22:00] yeah.

ChristineYeah. And I just want the public to know you guys are in power. Like follow email, your legislatures. If we could get a task force. Gather to just talk about what's happening in the judiciary, expose all the great judges talk about all the great things that the judiciary is happening in places in Kentucky. That way the general public will be more informed. I would love to see that.

HughOh, I would, I would too. Yeah. , Which we did we made some clips about some accolades for certain judges, and you mentioned that they. They don't get much traction. It's

Christinenot performing very well, but it is on TikTok, so you have to listen. It's just bizarre what the algorithm picks up.

HughI think people negative works and that's too bad and we gotta, we have to figure out a way to navigate that. Yeah.

ChristineI think I should give a shout out to two judges right now. We talked two episodes ago about the district court debacle in 2020 and 2021. About how the judges were trying to waive the 10 day rule and 10 day rule mm-hmm. As people in custody that need a preliminary hearing. There were [00:23:00] two district court judges at the time that are currently still on the bench. One is in district, one is in circuit. Stephanie Burke and Julie Kalen, both adamantly said on the record and to the to the chief judge at the time of district court and to the, we will keep our docket open. We are not gonna, we will not waive this 10 day rule. And I regret that I didn't mention that. And just because we say good things about judges doesn't mean we necessarily agree with everything they do. We aren't avatars. Right. I don't expect anyone to agree with everything I say. That would be boring, but yes, I think a shout out to, I don't yeah, no. Shout out Judge Julie Kalen and Judge Stephanie Burke for standing up in district court at the time.

HughAnd one of the other things I've noticed is when we're doing the roll calls, there are definitely trends with who's there and who's not. There are certain people that are almost always there, and I think at some point we will go through that. Mm-hmm. We, we haven't. Done that yet. We've just talked about the numbers, but there are definitely people that I think have been there every single time. Yep. No matter what time we've been there, their courtroom always seems to be open. They always seem to be there.

ChristineYeah. And I think that like [00:24:00] a one off, like I, nine of 13 judges, again, , I struggle a little bit with the morning, it being the morning like 10 45. To about 11, 10, 11 15. We didn't keep as good of track as when we left, we were chatting up. But that is a time when really it should be, you know, a hustle and bustle. But nine outta 13 isn't terrible. I mean, it is still the summer, you know, people might be getting a last minute vacation or something like , that end. But again, make your calendar public. Like one big question I get, how much vacation time do judges get, Hugh?

HughI do not know.

ChristineIs it? Is it statutory?

HughThere's an answer to that. That's all public. It's not

Christinestatutory.

HughIt's not statutory.

ChristineMm-hmm. They can have as much as they want. It's the honor system. Yep. Look at his face.

HughYou're shitting me.

ChristineYeah. No, they take up as much time. Really? Yeah. There is no obligation to work 40 hours. There's no obligation. To clock in, there's no, I mean, now they, they do have to, to get in the building. It's [00:25:00] my understanding that they have to scan into like secure parking. Sure. But that's not public record.

HughWouldn't even be tracked then. Other than the scanning in,

Christinescanning in and scanning out, which, I mean, I think that information should be public. I don't wanna know what kind of car they're driving or anything like that. Like, I'm not saying anything crazy like that, but just like, when are you in the building? When are you not in the building? Yeah. I mean that actually is the big, there's a litigation going on at the mayor's office right now here in Louisville. And that's one of the claims they fired someone. It's a long story. We don't need to get into the specifics of it. I've talked about it on my, at Kentucky, Christine, but they were saying that this. Employee wasn't scanning in and scanning out and now she's claiming that she had the privilege of working from home. But it's very interesting. I'm gonna tell you something right now. Judges, you can't work from home. Nope. You lost that privilege.

HughOh, I haven't seen it work since COVID. I did have some hearings where judges presided from their kitchen. That worked absolutely perfectly, [00:26:00] and it was because we needed to go in front of a. It needed to get resolved. Mm-hmm. And there was no other way to do it. And people just made do, I've had a, a judge in a spare bedroom. I've had a judge in a kitchen, I think two judges in, in, in their kitchens conduct hearings and knocked it outta the park, like recorded it correctly on Zoom. The record was made. It was, it went very well. So I'm not saying that there are technical limitations to it, but yeah,

Christineno. You lost your privilege. TikTok, judge you, you ruined it for everybody. I think now we know for sure what y'all have been doing because of some of her TikTok.

HughWell, it's funny. I think if I recall, she was one of the ones that conducted one of the hearings that we had to get done and conducted it from. I mean, she was remote somewhere. I don't remember exactly where it was, and she had a background on and you just. At the time, , everything was done remotely. Yeah. And, and so I, I had a, I always, if I had a trial [00:27:00] that was remote, I would set up in a conference room. I would set up boxes and put the laptop on it. 'cause I tend to stand and pace when I'm talking and thinking. So I was standing there and I just, in my head, I was in a courtroom. It really worked. And, and the hearing went well. And, and the staff was also on the meeting. I know it technically can be done.

ChristineYeah. The TikTok judge had a background that looked like the courthouse.

HughYeah.

ChristineAnd she actually, it's my understanding that she's got a studio. 'cause obviously she's a makeup artist part-time, and she does makeup videos and you have to have lighting for those things. So I think it was happening in the same room. But she actually did a TikTok, and I think this is, she gotten a little bit of heat from this, where she had that background put up the judge background, like the courthouse background. And she said, just because I haven't been in court doesn't mean I haven't been judging.

HughOh, that's interesting.

ChristineYou can't make it up.

HughOh, wow.

ChristineIt's like, bless her heart. You know what I'm saying?

HughWell, all I can say is it worked in that circumstance. Yes. And it was greatly appreciated by the, the clients who had a business that was [00:28:00] failing and needed to be. Divided. And, and, and if we had had to wait six more months on that case, the parties would've lost everything.

ChristineSo, but well, the height of the pandemic is a different Yeah. That was the height of the pandemic. I think it's just bizarre sometimes that we're like, clap, clap, clap, clap. You did your job. You know what I mean? Like,

Hughwell, that's, that, that's how I felt today. I was like, wow, there's like half of half the family courts are open. Mm-hmm. And I, I just thought, oh, that's great. And then, yeah. Why is that great? Why, why should my expectations be that low And, and I am from a private employer point of view, I think everybody should have honor system and you should have a team that you trust to take time off when they need. I was always a proponent of never saying no. If you have the right people, the job will get done. It's very different when taxpayer money and a public service is involved.

ChristineAbsolutely. All right, y'all ready? Speaking of these judges, let's watch the clip of the week. This was chosen by Hugh, not me. And this is from the creator. [00:29:00] What's the creator's name? This is user 5 0 8 1 9 5 2. 8, 3, 6, 5, 8. Pressure to plead guilty, furious judge over potential appeal.

HughYeah. Strange one for me to pick, given that this is criminal court and not family, but yeah,

Christineso my money's on that being a public defender.

HughOh wow. Oh, wow. He's gonna leave. He's gonna leave. What? What does that mean? The judge is going to leave,

Christinemeans he is gonna go into chambers [00:30:00] and Take a minute. Mommy needs a minute. Daddy needs a minute.

HughWow. I mean, there's, there's so much there. So. According to this judge, you can't plead guilty. You can't take a plea deal to avoid a trial unless you're actually 100% guilty and did everything you were charged with. I mean, losing his mind because the guy said he didn't do it, but he's pleading guilty.

ChristineYeah. And I don't know if he's in a state where we, they have an Alford plea. This is a felony. I would be willing to bet it's a felony, because typically with misdemeanors you plea and are sentence same day. So felonies you plea, and then typically sentenced within. In Kentucky, it's almost always a month later in most jurisdictions that I've practiced. And that's because you have to get time to have the PSI pre-sentence investigation done. An Alfred plea is where you admit sufficient evidence to find you guilty, but you do not admit guilt. Correct. It has no real effect

Hughbecause you still, it's still a guilty

ChristineYes. But you can still claim innocence publicly. Mm-hmm. That being [00:31:00] said, it's, you know, this one didn't make me as mad as it made you. And all of them make me mad.

HughIt, it made me angry because how many times have you heard a litigant sit there and, and they're agreeing with something, or they're going along with something and they get pushed on it? They say, well, no one's gonna listen to me anyway, or I haven't had a chance to speak, no one's cared what I've said all along. So yeah, I'm just going along with it like that's, that happens so often. Mm-hmm. That people just do not feel heard in the process.

ChristineYeah.

HughAnd they taking advice of counsel and this judge seemed to just. It was insinuating that this was a setup so that he could claim ineffective assistance of counsel, which means you say your attorney didn't do a good enough job and you didn't get your constitutionally guaranteed representation on a criminal action. And then it gives you a right to appeal.

ChristineYeah. It goes to your sixth amendment Right. To counsel. Mm-hmm. And effective assistance of counsel.

HughYep.

ChristineThat being said, when you plead a felonies everywhere in this. [00:32:00] Country, my understanding is that there's gonna be a colloquy done, you know, where do you understand your name? Sure. Do you understand your name? LOL. Do you understand your charge? Is this your name? Are you pleading free will? Yep. And so, and the reason that we do that is so when there is sentencing, you have a fair and adequate plea the judge had two options in that case. And I do think if. He's, the judge is clearly frustrated. The way judges speak to people is insane. Okay. That's like not appropriate, obviously, but the judge should just say, set it aside and we're gonna have set it for a jury trial or a bench trial if you wanted, which again. I can think of maybe two circumstances where you would ever want a bench trial on a circuit, court matter, criminal matter. But, or the judge just says, no, we had a colloquy. I'm sentencing you today. Sure. And then you can take it up in a, you know, just because people allege there's violations of their due process, they're ineffective assistance of counsel appeal. The judge should, that's their right. That shouldn't piss the judge off. Just let it happen.

HughNo, it [00:33:00] is their right. Andy, if you think that. The defendant doesn't understand what they're doing or got bad advice. It is very easy to say, I, there are irregularities here. I'm not comfortable taking this plea. Mm-hmm. We're gonna set this for another pretrial conference or some other conference. I want you to go speak to your counsel.

ChristineYep.

HughOr, you know, I wanna see, you know, counsel in chambers and discuss about, you know, something there. There are ways to handle if you have concerns. This didn't seem like a concern for a defendant. Mm-hmm. This seemed like a frustrated judge. Yep. Who was just. Having a tantrum on the bench.

ChristineYep. And I think the ramification for a lot of these videos that we watch would be to make a complaint against the judge. And in Kentucky we have the Judicial Conduct Commission, which is governed by the Supreme Court of Kentucky. So it's an internal body. Right. And you don't see much come out of the Judicial Conduct Commission. Have you ever looked at the form to file a complaint?

HughYes.

ChristineAnd it's like, first off. Judicial conduct commission. You can Google it in [00:34:00] Kentucky. They don't even have the ability for you to do fill the form out online. You have to print, write, and then send it.

HughThey make it difficult. Yep. And there are a lot of things antiquated about our government forms, government websites, and especially within the legal and court system, but not that antiquated, that, that just, it's hard for me to believe that that's anything but. Intentional.

ChristineYeah. And I even emailed them about that. I filed a complaint about the TikTok judge, which I've spoken openly about, and I remember it being a huge pain for me. Like even the way the form was. Mm-hmm. Like it was just like, and I emailed them, like, y'all, if I'm struggling with this, like, can you imagine pro se litigants like. Clearly, if you want transparency and accountability, you know, judges need to be held accountable. But when you have internal investigations that are confidential secret and then the outcome is typically secret. Mm-hmm. You know, what do you think about it?

HughWell, I, I think if I, if I know it's very [00:35:00] hard for anyone to file a complaint, and I know it, that it's very unlikely that anything comes of it. If they do. And then I also know if something does come of it, it's most likely gonna be something private and is talked about and the public's never going to know about it, and it's not gonna affect my ability to keep my job or to be reelected.

ChristineYep.

HughThat's going to, that's gonna inform how I behave and how I speak to people in my courtroom and

Christinemm-hmm.

HughAnd whether I follow the rules.

ChristineAbsolutely. And I just think that if there were more, if there was more oversight and more accountability that would nip some of these problems in the bud.

HughSure. And, and I imagine there would be tons of people that don't like rulings and they'll file complaints that's going to happen. And there will be 99% of it'll be complete and total. Bs. You know, people that are just angry and, you know, judges make people mad all the time. Most people in the court systems make people mad all the time. , I've had sheriffs insist on walking me back to my office because I made people so mad in the [00:36:00] courtroom. I, I understand that, but there are ways to deal with that. It's the same thing with, with, any feedback form for any industry?

ChristineYeah, I just really struggle. I think that's a talking point to some degree. So I was in the public defender's office for four years, never had a bar complaint. Four years, thousands of clients. My office, we had, my goodness, I wanna say between, between 10 and 12 in my actual office, we were in two circuits. The other circuit we really didn't see much like it was in the county, so we weren't even at the office that much. But I'm trying to think in my four years there, how many bar complaints were even filed by anyone against any public defender in the office. But

Hughthat's different. That's how Oh, it's very different because you're number one you're representing a defendant against the state. You don't have someone. Witness on the state who's gonna file bar complaints against you? I'm talking about No,

Christineour clients. Our clients I

Hughknow, but I'm not talking about when I said people are not happy with the attorneys I'm talking about. So when running a business, you have to really pay attention to online [00:37:00] reputation and Google reviews and things like that. And then review sites, especially Google says if you have had an experience with this person, you can write a review whether or not you actually did business with them. So. How, okay, I forget what percentage of the bad reviews that we ever got from the firm. A very high percent were for people on the other side who were not happy that they got a bad result because we represented their spouse and that still was a legitimate review. It's the same thing.

ChristineOkay. Back up. No, but back up. You don't get

Hughthat in in, you're not gonna get that in

Christinein four years as a public defender. People in go to prison, lots of people go to jail in prison. I never had one of them that I can think of ever file a complaint on any of the judges in those two circuits.

HughHmm.

ChristineSo that, that I'm aware of. And so that, think about it like that.

HughHow often was it in those cases where the judge made the ultimate decision on whether to convict them or not?

ChristineSentenced them or made suppression sentence is

Hughdifferent, but determining whether they were guilty or not. They,

Christinewe didn't have a family court, so we had those circuit judges were doing family court matters as [00:38:00] well. I mean, I never once heard of it. Literally, the judge used to practice in front of Beth Maze. Her husband has been to prison twice. Once for trafficking, heroin, and once for vote buying. And she was charged with forgery for entering an order in his case. And I never heard of a, judicial complaint filed against her while I was practicing. Now, obviously for the order it was filed and there was a full hearing. We can break that down on another one, but I just don't think that people, I don't think that we should have this fear that everyone's gonna complain against their judge. They have so much power that people are afraid to complain against him.

HughNo, that's true.

ChristineYou know, I mean, I'm just saying like, I don't know of any client I had in private practice that filed a judicial complaint. Do you? Did you? Or you can't say,

Hughoh, I, I know, I know. Several. Really? Oh, yes.

ChristineCan I see 'em?

HughNo.

ChristineWhy can't I see 'em?

HughWell, we, we actually, we had clients who insisted on doing it, and we would advise them against it. Because how is that going to help your cause at all? Filing what he said? Filing from, [00:39:00] from an advocate point of view, yeah. I was, from a, a human point of view and looking at it from the outside, it needed to be done, but I always urged them to do it after, after the case was resolved. Yep. Regardless of how it came out, if there was something worth filing a complaint about, but we had clients that went ahead and did it anyway and we had to do some damage control within the case because they, things would get mentioned.

ChristineYeah.

HughThings they would, it would get, you know, things like that get mentioned. They get mentioned in little comments at motion hour or in chambers and it's, they just,

Christineor the little rumor mill, like, oh, the little rumor.

HughMentioned by the judge in comments speaking with you, that someone has filed a complaint. The, you know, it's obviously coming into the process, which is why I always told clients, you know, almost nothing good is going to come outta that from your case standpoint. Well, and if you go and file complaints against anyone, and that includes, you know, threatening a bar complaint against the other side or the other attorney or call, I mean, those kind of things just.

ChristineStrategically bad

Hughstrategy. It's

Christinebad [00:40:00] strategy. Also, we know that nothing comes of it. And personally, there were times that I would have liked to have filed a judicial complaint, but I didn't because ultimately I still think our duties to our client and you know, I think that could have made it more difficult for the client. It's an interesting ethical issue as far as like having to. Tell on someone when we see bad behavior, but I think ultimately always our duty is to our client.

HughI agree.

ChristineLike there was one time I did not file a judicial complaint because my client didn't want it to happen, was just like, no, this judge is already terrible. You know what I mean? Yeah.

HughOh yeah. I, I don't know that I've ever recommended filing. I'm certain that in 20 years I would, I wouldn't have recommended filing something. Against the, now there are times where Recusals asking for recusals and, and things like that, you have to recommend it.

ChristineYeah. Oh, 'cause that's,

Hughthat's your duty. But filing a judicial complaint, I've had plenty of conversations with clients about that is clearly a violation of the code and [00:41:00] a complaint is warranted. But from. As an advocate on your case, this is not the time to do it. Yep. That is not going to help.

ChristineWhich is what is so shocking. And that's another thing when I asked him, can I see the complaint? And he's like, no, it's because I've never shared my complaint that I wrote. I mean, I can share the fact that I filed one that's different. Well, but the fact of the matter that, or like the details in the case, you can't share that. It's, it's questionable as to whether or not you can share it.

HughWell, from my point of view, anything that involves any of my clients, I'm not going to speak specifically about or, or I'm not gonna disclose anything. Even if they, they haven't been my clients for years. I, you know, , without permission. So that was my initial reaction to it. They am that

Christineattorney-client privilege. Yeah. Well, I want the tea, I want the gossip.

HughYeah.

ChristineOh my goodness. And if anyone out there has judicial conduct complaints that they have filed, please share with me. I would love to see the contents. It's actually fascinating because until about 2022, I think we'll verify that on the website. They actually used to track how many were filed [00:42:00] and what the outcomes of it were, whether or not it was a public or private reprimand, and it was about 2% ended in a private or public reprimand, which is an ex, it's, and again, it's very similar to the old school law enforcement internal investigations. Statistically speaking, I struggle with those numbers, but again, how can I say for sure? Because I've never seen the contents of it. You're a hundred percent right. Somebody could be like that, son of a bitch judge ruled against me. You know what I mean? And that's not a judicial complaint. No. Losing your case. Absolutely not being incarcerated for a robbery one. You know, that's not a judicial complaint. So we, I can't say for certain they could be doing a killer job. Yep. You know? Agreed. But y'all, anything that you have, please send to judge-y.com. I am at kentuckychristine, on all platforms Instagram, judging the judges. YouTube, please follow us, subscribe, like, share all the things. We heart you.

HughSee ya. [00:43:00] Yeah. Yeah. We need some. Justice. Justin found justice.